6 ms·
Microsoft's Xandr grants GDPR rights at a rate of 0%
- themoonisachees 2y agoWhat!? The entire ad industry is a scam to everyone involved? Who could have for seen this?
- Freak_NL 2y agoBelieving that would be most inconvenient for a rather large number of actors though. Are there any known high-profile experiments where targetted versus content-related advertising was compared? Somehow it seems that targetted advertising works (or worked), or at least that's what all the big players believe.
- pacifika 2y agoYep https://tweakers.net/plan/4126/tweakers-stopt-met-trackingvrije-advertenties.html https://tweakers.net/plan/4126/tweakers-stopt-met-trackingvr... (Dutch, translatable). Trackerless advertising didn’t pan out.
- tsimionescu 2y agoAs far as I understand, this is from the perspective of someone selling ad space. Plus, a lot of the problems they cite are issues with ad platforms integrating with their systems, since most of the tech that ad platforms have assumes tracking, it wasn't working with their trackerless platform. The more interesting question is what real difference it makes to companies that buy advertising whether they buy targeted advertising versus trackerless advertising. After all, trackerless advertising was good enough for a very long time.
- squigz 2y agoI mean, I don't really care if it's more effective. If the cost is my privacy, and the privacy of everyone else in the world, then I don't care if it's less profitable to not do targeted advertising.
- baridbelmedar 2y agoI understand your point of view, and I'm not saying you don't have a point. But something tells me that you would take a more pragmatic approach if your livelihood or that of a close relative were directly affected by the company's poor sales as a result. Remember, everyone's job contributes to sales, whether they like it or not :)
- squigz 2y agoMaybe. Maybe not. Maybe I'd take a more pragmatic approach to drug policy if I or a loved one were a drug dealer, too?
- latexr 2y agoI for one take the pragmatic approach of not working for companies with practices I object to. Thus I’m never faced with that dilemma.
- baridbelmedar 2y agoWell, many industries rely on advertising to sell their products, and I wouldn't say those industries are inherently worse than others.
- latexr 2y ago> Well, many industries rely on advertising to sell their products I’m not objecting to advertising, but the privacy violations. > and I wouldn't say those industries are inherently worse than others. I wouldn’t (and didn’t) say that either.
- mtlynch 2y agoI'd imagine it's more complicated than that. If you use iOS or Android, I'd imagine there's some practice of Google or Apple that you object to, so it's not practical to do it in all cases. In my experience, I try to avoid companies with objectionable practices, but in a lot of cases, all the vendors are varying degrees of unscrupulous. Or the vendors that are ethical have a significantly worse customer experience because they're playing fair against competitors who are playing unfair. So, I'm left to either choose the least bad vendor or face massive inconvenience from not using a competitive vendor.
- otabdeveloper4 2y agoThere is no dichotomy of "targeted" vs "content-related". Advertisers want particular social groups. Large, well-defined ones. (E.g., "women with young kids and disposable income".) What particular features you want in your ML model to get those groups is a technical implementation detail.
- tsimionescu 2y agoWhat do you mean? There is a huge difference between putting an ad in a magazine for rich mothers with young kids (content-related) versus putting the same ad in a game that woman plays because her targeting ID identifies her as such (targetted).
- otabdeveloper4 2y ago> There is a huge difference Not to the advertiser, no.
- tsimionescu 2y agoOnly if the two they are equivalently effective. Advertisers believe today that direct targeting is more effective than content-based targeting. This is reflected in the much higher price they are willing to pay for direct targeting vs content-based targeting.
- Timshel 2y agoI believe Duckduckgo wrote some article on the subject (but could not find much with a quick search).
- skrebbel 2y agoCan we please stop with the “eye-roll i knew this all along” comments? They’re not very constructive. Yes, there are things that are bad. Yes, we all know about it. Feigning surprise doesn’t really add much.
- squigz 2y agoDownvote, flag, and move on.
- SteveSmith16384 2y agoHow do you downvote? I only seem to have an upvote icon.
- ryanjshaw 2y agoYou, somewhat ironically, haven't written enough upvoted comments to exceed the karma threshold necessary to hold down vote power.
- skrebbel 2y agoFair enough
- SteveSmith16384 2y agoI'm not sure what your point is?
- pacifika 2y agoOpt out https://monetize.xandr.com/privacy-center/opt_out https://monetize.xandr.com/privacy-center/opt_out
- vincnetas 2y agoFrom the linked page : * If you are experiencing technical difficulties in accessing data, deleting data, or opting out, please try another browser and let us know. And to no ones surprise, contact page is 404 https://monetize.xandr.com/privacy-center/contact https://monetize.xandr.com/privacy-center/contact
- bilekas 2y agoWorking link : https://about.ads.microsoft.com/en/forms/xandr-privacy-form https://about.ads.microsoft.com/en/forms/xandr-privacy-form Because "Microsoft"
- pndy 2y agoYeah but this is still one entity and setting is based on cookie, per device valid up until cache gets cleared. Browsers should handle tracking preferences in settings and it should be "deny" by default for all non-essential purposes. There are technical means but no will to respect such preferences. Tho, Global Privacy Control which is the successor to Do Not Track header managed to fine Sephora company in the US for ignoring opt-out request [1]. So, maybe there's some hope... [1] - https://web.archive.org/web/20230510060201/https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/sephora-pay-12-mln-privacy-settlement-with-calif-ag-over-data-sales-2022-08-24/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230510060201/https://www.reute...
- amarcheschi 2y agoI think this should be the page where you can make a gdpr data access/deletion/correction request https://monetize.xandr.com/privacy-center/access_correction_delete https://monetize.xandr.com/privacy-center/access_correction_... I have just done one just to wait for their rejection and then file a complaint to the Italian privacy authority Furthermore, you might wanna look into adnauseam, a ublock origin fork that blocks ads while simulating a click on them so that the effectivity of ads is decreased
- amarcheschi 2y agoThey answered with "Thank you for your inquiry. We take privacy seriously at Xandr and appreciate the time you’ve taken to contact us. Our privacy center allows consumers in specified jurisdictions to take certain actions such as requesting access to, correction or deletion of personal information and to opt-out of the sale or sharing of the same. We must be able to verify your identity in order to process your request. However, because our advertising platform does not contain information that would allow us to identify an individual, such as name or email address, we will be unable to verify the identity of most requestors and therefore cannot fulfill such requests as a result. To the extent we maintain identifying information about you outside of our advertising platform, such as for business contacts in California, we will use this data to verify your request. Further, if you are submitting a request on behalf of someone else, we may ask for additional information from you in order to verify we are authorized to process the request. Additionally, all consumers may opt out of interest-based advertising using our global opt-out. To learn more about our privacy practices, review our Platform Privacy Policy. We hope that this information is helpful. If you have any further questions, let us know. If you are in the European Economic Area, you have the possibility of lodging a complaint with an European Data Protection Authority and of seeking a judicial remedy. Regards, The Xandr Privacy team " I'm gonna try tell them about the cookie they talk about the article, I wanna know what they're gonna say
- fullspectrumdev 2y agoI got a very similar word salad response from another data broker type company ages back. I should try again.
- bilekas 2y ago> Your privacy is important to us. This privacy statement explains the personal data Microsoft processes, how Microsoft processes it, and for what purposes. When you're selling it, I'm sure it is important to you.
- 1oooqooq 2y agoExactly. The only privacy respecting feature I have ever worked on in the Ad space was because vendors (the ad industry clients) were abusing the platform and pushing expensive rich-media formats when only paying for "banners". So we prevented the banners from escaping the iframes they were served in and added measured APIs to allow richmedia ones to annoy the user outside the iframe. it also had the benefit of cutting down spam since most spammers were scraping the webmail contacts by placing ads. lol. the early 2000s were wild.
- resource_waste 2y agoI remember the contradictory thoughts when I first filled in my work iPhone with my personal data. Apple had some sort of mind control that had me excited to give them my personal information. At the same time, I was horrified that I was giving so much information to Apple. With Apple, it felt fine, their branding made you feel special. With Microsoft, you feel extorted. I'm sure people will nitpick differences, but after PRISM, its just branding. Apple commercials make you feel better about Apple, even when they do M$ level of bad things. M$ is just so terrible at pretending to be pro-consumer, they are oblivious.
- Barrin92 2y agoIt's like when, as a European user, you go to a website that's called something like Idaho Gazette because you follow a HN link and after seven years they still block you but tell you how important you are to them. I think if that was the case they could've just chosen to not collect any personal data from the five Euro users that show up once a year which would have taken less effort than putting that banner up
- nerdponx 2y agoIt would have taken more effort, because the data collection is not something they have the ability to selectively disable, it's so backed into their platform and business model.
- Havoc 2y agoEU just needs to keep slapping them with fines until it sinks in that laws are not suggestions
- justinclift 2y agoTo clarify, the fines should grow in size per offence (triple?) and be enforced. Not just miniscule things repeated ad-nauseam.
- 1oooqooq 2y agoThis is the industry standard for advertising. Even way before GDRP! Remember when Verizon was caught "super cookie"ing all their subscribers http requests? What did verizon do? moved the super cookie shenanigans under their subsidiary AOL. Then when AOL got a slap on the wrist too, what verizon did? bought Yahoo and moved the shenanigans there. ...When those tactics where not technically possible anymore it sold all ad subsidiaries for the purchase price. I call that «Regulatory Condoms». It works fine for enforcement that gives warnings before fines.
- HenryBemis 2y agoHeh nice term! Being respectful to my colleagues, I call this "privacy theater", borrowing from the "security theater".
- 1oooqooq 2y agoQuit the puritanism. it's less disrespectful than insert cookies on your clients http requests tho.
- BiteCode_dev 2y ago[flagged]
- andruby 2y agoIs the word “condom” considered disrespectful? I can understand terms that are discriminatory in nature or historically. But an anti-conception piece of rubber?
- londons_explore 2y agoThe RTB industry is IMO missing a trick by using properties of people for targeting rather than "info vectors" and "bloom lists". The info vectors would be generated by a neural net based on all information known about a customer. The vectors would specifically not be usable to identify a customer, and therefore not count as PII under GDPR rules. The vectors would be trained to predict the probability of clicking an ad (the pCTR). Using that training metric, everything an advertiser cares about will end up encoded in the vector, whilst no individual private piece of info (eg. sexual orientation) is extractable with any certainty. Notably, these vectors will be addable, allowing multiple companies to add their vectors on one visitor, creating a new vector with even greater predictive strength, but no company shares their private customer data to competitors. The 'bloom lists' will be able to identify customers, but only probabilistically. They will encode data such as "user bob@mail.com has an account at Walmart, Lowes and Target". However, the data they hold is only right ~99% of the time, since it is implemented with a bloom filter. That allows businesses to do remarketing to specific users, for example past customers. No individual user could ever be sure they are or are not part of such a filter, and hence it again doesn't meet the EU's PII definition. By using the above two, I believe the total CTR can be increased (since users get better targeted), whilst also giving users the privacy they expect.
- staunton 2y agoNo inference made on data is ever guaranteed 100% to be right. So I'd expect the legal standard in this case to be "are companies able to identify individuals from the data" and if that's possible in 99% of cases, any court will rule against you.
- AlexandrB 2y agoI think a lot of people think that bad targeting is a technology problem, but isn't it also an economic one? It doesn't matter how good your categories are if ftx.com pays for a massive ad buy across all demographics and annoys the shit out of everyone. The opposite is also true - products I might actually be interested in probably don't get enough budget for me to see an ad for them more than once.
- 2y ago
- botanical 2y agoCompanies need to be slapped with a non-negligible percentage fine of revenue. They will learn fast to respect the law, and by extension, people's privacy.
- pvillano 2y agoI dream of a fines system that has "all the money you made doing this" as a minimum.
- Jyaif 2y agoFines should be at minimum "all the money you made doing this / percentage of chance of getting caught", to keep the profit expectation at 0.
- emn13 2y agoIf your aim is to keep profit expectation of violations at no more than zero, then it's also necessary to hold company _owners_ liable for more than their shares are worth. Otherwise, corporations will just play shells games (which they already do for all kinds of liability) to reduce the fines to peanuts via limited liability/bankruptcy. The chance of that reform seems very slim, so perhaps we could at least tax shell companies some percentage of both revenue and value, and not just profits - to represent the real costs of shifting liability. Not that that's likely either, but we can dream.
- paholg 2y agoMinimum of "all the money you made doing this" plus a percentage of total revenue, IMO.
- exe34 2y agoeven better, define a process where instead of a fine, a percentage of the ownership goes into a national wealth fund. boom, basic income is funded.
- 2y ago
- robertlagrant 2y ago> Previous research has shown that Xandr collects hundreds of sensitive profiles of Europeans containing information about their health, sex life or sexual orientation, political or philosophical opinions, religious beliefs or financial status. Specific segments include things like ‘french_disability’, ‘pregnant’, ‘lgbt’, ‘gender_equality’ and ‘jewishfrench’. I don't read German (which I think the justifying article is written in) - is this linking directly to personally identifiable information? If I have an ID in a cookie that links to these groupings, it is not necessarily the same as a GDPR breach. Would someone mind clarifying this one who's more familiar with Xandr/reading German?
- Y-bar 2y agoI think Article 4, section 1 answers your question with regards to online identifiers such as cookies: > ‘personal data’ means any information relating to an identified or identifiable natural person (‘data subject’); an identifiable natural person is one who can be identified, directly or indirectly, in particular by reference to an identifier such as a name, an identification number, location data, an online identifier or to one or more factors specific to the physical, physiological, genetic, mental, economic, cultural or social identity of that natural person; https://gdpr-info.eu/art-4-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-4-gdpr/
- robertlagrant 2y agoI don't think it fits the bill. If I tell you I have a cookie with ID jeeg274642, how are you going to identify me? That's different to thing like a Twitter handle that can be traced straight to a person, as some can.
- Y-bar 2y agoBecause I know where jeeg274642 belongs in the set of [gender, nationality_and_region, age_group, pregnancy_status, ...]. Just like a Social Security Number, a cookie (or whatever storage tech is used) need not contain the exact data of the individual, it only need to reference or be precise enough it for it to be a means of identifying them.
- karaterobot 2y agoMaybe it's because I just woke up, but this headline was really confusing to me. I believe it's saying the ad broker Xandr, owned by Microsoft, does not comply with GDPR, and has a 0% compliance rate with GDPR requests.
- nottorp 2y agoBut... in addition to going to the authorities, which may fix something but only for the EU... Just make more public how good their targeting database is. For example, tell their customers. Might be more efficient.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]