5 ms·
>in practice it’s all vibes Vibes matter. When walking down the street, a person isn't going to do a full evaluation on a homeless person. They are going off v
by al_borland 2y ago
>in practice it’s all vibes
Vibes matter. When walking down the street, a person isn't going to do a full evaluation on a homeless person. They are going off vibes, and if the vibe is unsafe, it makes the city feel unsafe. People with money to spend tend not to go to cities and areas that feel unsafe, which over time will cause a city to die, which is bad for everyone.
>Best-case scenario, they’re completely sane. Now what? Do you keep a completely sane person locked in the mental institution forever?
....
>the social workers can’t show up at their door, because these patients are homeless and hard to track down.
...
>Okay, sounds like you need to get them homes. But there’s not enough government-subsidized housing.
Why does the mental institutions have to be "lock up"? It seems like there could be levels to this. Lockup for those who are still potentially dangerous out in society, and have something more akin to a halfway house where someone can live and are free to go and do stuff, but have a place to come back to to keep tabs on them and make sure they are taking their meds. Provide a path to full independence, but with some guardrails to make sure they are doing it in a way where they have a place to live and are taking their meds, and not just throwing them back on the street and expecting things to be different than when they were picked up off the street.
This will probably be expensive, but looking at what the homeless problem has cost some very expensive cities, it seems like it would be worth it.
- inglor_cz 2y agoIndeed one of the phenomena that surprises me is just how much do cities like San Francisco spend on homelessness without visible success. It is something like 50 000 dollars per homeless person per year.
- mrguyorama 2y agoThat's just the base cost of a human being using the absolute ragged edge of what remains of our "safety net", primarily ambulance calls and unpayable hospital bills for very basic and unnecessary things. The homeless people in my small (60k people) city have an ambulance called about once per day because they get heat stroke, because if they try to stand somewhere they wont get heat stroke, they will be arrested. Those wasteful usages of our absurdly BS priced medical system balloons how much a "homeless" person "costs". It doesn't matter that the only actual resources used where a hospital bed and some OTC medication, the hospital will claim that expense as 10k and bitch and moan that they can't afford it. Then you have the secondary effect that a 100 bed shelter in California will be absurdly expensive to operate simply due to rent, like disproportionately so.
- beardyw 2y ago> Lockup for those who are still potentially dangerous out in society, and have something more akin to a halfway house where someone can live and are free to go and do stuff. There are a lot inbetween those where people will wander off and then get confused.
- al_borland 2y agoIf someone isn't stable enough to not wander off and get confused/lost, then they shouldn't be let out on their own.
- worldvoyageur 2y agoI am not an expert but it seems that many of the real challenges outlined in this blog are handled with what my city (Ottawa, Canada) calls 'supportive housing'. Basically, a purpose built building with 30-50 small apartments and social services co-located. Residents have to meet conditions to get in, to remain in and progress to the point that they can function in more regular market housing, thus freeing the slot for another resident. https://ottawainnercityhealth.ca/programs-services/supportive-living-programs/ https://ottawainnercityhealth.ca/programs-services/supportiv... ' Our supportive living units are run in partnership with other organizations and provide specialized supports for individuals exiting homelessness. This includes substance use support, mental health care, and peer support. Our programs are designed to be client-centred with a harm-reduction-focus. [...] Carruthers is a supported housing program operated in partnership with the John Howard Society with 46 units. Originally, the substance use treatment available focused strongly on Injectable Opiate Substitution (IOAT) with 20 of the available apartments being reserved for people who were enrolled in that program. Many of the original residents have now migrated to other forms of treatment and to different lives where volunteering, work and time spent with family and friends are a priority. [..] The Richcraft Residence was the first OICH housing program which offered all available substance use, physical health and mental health treatments in one location providing a full menu of care options for residents. ' Upstream of supportive housing you need good street facing services with social workers and police well coordinated and tracking clients. Downstream of supportive housing you need to help people maintain the progress they made at living more indepently as a functional part of their wider community. Remaining problems include: - keeping clients alive long enough to recover before they die from opiod poisoning - having enough of supportive housing capacity to meet the need. - the candidates who do not want to participate, even space was available.