4 ms·
This is for a criminal case. The victims don't play a prosecutorial role here and are not actually parties to this case. The appropriate venue for the victims
by gunapologist99 2y ago
This is for a criminal case. The victims don't play a prosecutorial role here and are not actually parties to this case.
The appropriate venue for the victims is a civil jury trial (lawsuit), where recovery of losses is possible because the victims then become party to the case (plaintiff).
The reason this lawyer is requesting this is so that the government will be forced to lay its cards on the table during trial, which provide much stronger proof/evidence of Boeing's wrongdoing (which otherwise would likely be much harder to discover), and make it far more likely for a jury to award a huge award to the plaintiffs.
So this is completely rational on the part of the lawyer, but the judge doesn't have to go along with it at all, and might not.
- jessriedel 2y ago> This is for a criminal case. The victims don't play a prosecutorial role here and are not actually parties to this case. The desires of the victim in making formal accusations (“pressing charges”) are certainly considered by the prosecutors even if the victim is not a party to the trial. I’d image the prosecutor takes it into account in other situations too, like the terms of accepting a guilty plea. Do you have a link to something that suggests otherwise?
- philwelch 2y agoIs a trial really the only mechanism by which the government could share that evidence with civil plaintiffs?