3 ms·
You're missing the point: shutting down short-term renting will not really move the needle. What's usually the case is that even if you put those 10k units (or
by kelnos 2y ago
You're missing the point: shutting down short-term renting will not really move the needle. What's usually the case is that even if you put those 10k units (or whatever) back on the normal long-term rental (or buy-to-occupy) market, prices will stay roughly the same. You need to build 100k new homes (or more!) to actually reduce home prices. The demand will not even be remotely satisfied by banning STRs.
Existing homeowners don't want new housing built, because it'll reduce their home value. Homeowners tend to vote more than renters do, and tourists of course don't get a vote. Airbnb is a convenient bogeyman to distract people from the garbage zoning laws and barriers to development already in place.
The problem is pretty much always NIMBYs.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoI'm not missing the point. I'm asserting that if locals want to ban short term rentals, they can, and there is nothing anyone outside of the jurisdiction can do about it. Arguing over whether the bans move the needle is immaterial, although you are free to complain about it, as it is the only recourse available.
- shiroiushi 2y agoI'm not sure what the point of your argument is then. Locals can vote for all kinds of things, smart or dumb. They could vote on whether to ban the color purple on storefronts, for instance, though (IMO) it would be a stupid law to pass. This discussion is about AirBnB and housing prices, so just loudly proclaiming "locals can vote for policies they want!" isn't productive here at all. The entire point of this discussion is to argue the merits of these initiatives.