3 ms·
We keep paying more and more per student for public education. And what do we get in return? Robo-grading and prison-like treatment of students (closed campuses
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
We keep paying more and more per student for public education. And what do we get in return? Robo-grading and prison-like treatment of students (closed campuses, zero tolerance taken to ridiculous extent). And again we come around to the notion that if only we'd spend more everything would get better, which has worked so well every time it's happened in the past.
The increasing reliance on automated tools and standardized tests is just one of many symptoms of the increasing detachment between teachers and students. We have to stop doubling down on the prussian style educational system, it stopped returning dividends decades ago. More so we have to stop acting as though we can just solve our educational problems by throwing more money at it. We need to empower good teachers and parents, we need to encourage and support students. Right now all of the incentives in the system run counter to those things.
- adrianN 14y agoBut this article advocates using automated grading to reduce costs and free up teacher time for better things.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoCost is orthogonal to educational quality. As I said, this isn't an example of reducing costs so much as an example of the continual dehumanization of the education system. Any cost savings will just be gobbled up by the entrenched interests in the system, bureaucrats, administrators, etc. And any efficiencies making it easier to treat students like cattle and push "education" more and more toward useless rote memorization (teaching to the test) and busywork. These are not good things.
- ludflu 14y ago> Cost is orthogonal to educational quality. I've heard this (anecodotal) argument alot. Is there any empirical backing for it, and within what parameters does it hold true? My mother taught at a very expensive private school, which enabled me to switch from a lousy public school . The difference in the quality of teaching was dramatic. Private school teachers don't get paid alot more than public school teachers, and often less, although they are compensated with fringe benefits like I enjoyed, and prestige. In any case, elite private schools certainly get better results, which is why rich people pay alot of money to send their children to elite private schools. (Lots of this is attributable to the selection process, which is part of what parents are paying for.) In contrast, public inner city schools can't choose their student population, and lack basic things like, books, paper, and air conditioning in the middle of the summer. I'm sure that proper and equitable funding of public education wouldn't solve all the problems in US public schools, but starving them of much needed resources certainly exacerbates the problems they do have.
- jacktoole1 14y agoThe countries that perform well on international standardized tests generally spend much less money per student, but a teaching job is much more prestigious than it is in the U.S. I personally think that explanation fits both the "cost is orthogonal to education quality" argument of the parent, and your point that elite private schools have significantly better education quality, though I do not know offhand of studies about this.
- noonespecial 14y agoThe problem with "more money" is that the educational system seems to have a sort of hull speed when it comes to adding money. I'd guess that the same or less is being spent on actual education today and the excesses, whatever they may be, are simply siphoned off by the parasites in the system. It doesn't seem to matter how much $ per student gets added, teachers still end up buying classroom supplies with their own money. The system just has more $180k "administrators" now than it used to.
- btilly 14y agoUniversity education has been going up at 10%/year for decades now. Way above inflation. It is clear that it is going on an internal dynamic until those dynamics finally conflict with reality. That collision will be..painful. Given the crushing levels of student debt in this country it may happen sooner rather than later. If I were in charge, I'd institute a simple change. Improve financial aid. Beef up the federal loan guarantees. Only make either available at schools whose tuition was in the bottom 70% when you applied. With that incentive, I think that a lot of schools would find ways to reduce tuitions towards what (inflation adjusted) was more than sufficient several decades ago.
- _delirium 14y ago> University education has been going up at 10%/year for decades now. Accounting for inflation and number of students, university budgets have not been going up 10%/year; at some universities, the real per-student cost of higher education has actually been declining. What's been going up at 10%/year is the tuition "sticker price" for students who receive no scholarships or need-based aid. But this is offset by two contrary trends: 1) a decrease in the percentage of students who are actually paying the sticker price, especially at private universities; and 2) large decreases in state funding for public universities. Consider the University of California system (all figures below in 2012 dollars). In 1990, it spent $21,000 per student (dividing its total budget by its total enrollment). Today it spends $16,500 per student--- a decrease in the cost of education of about 25%. Tuition has nonetheless gone up, because the state-funded portion of its budget has declined even faster: from $16,000 per student in 1990 to $9,500 per student today, and possibly to $8,500 per student in the coming year. As a result, the student-funded portion has risen from $5,000 to $7,000 and soon $8,000 per student on average (with a sticker price a bit over double that). If you want the UC system to be able to run on tuitions that were sufficient in 1990, you'd have to also return state funding to what it was in 1990...