9 ms·
ICANN's list of abandoned vanity TLDs
- sbarre 2y agoThere really was a bit of an enterprise gold rush for these gTLDs in the late 00s. They saw .google and .mcdonalds and thought "we should have our own one of those".. And I guess after a while of paying the non-trivial gTLD fees to ICANN, companies eventually looked at the ROI and realized they actually didn't need their own one of those... Funny how different brands in the same industries figured it out many years before others did.
- akira2501 2y agoThey all have the same oeuvre that typo squatted and oddly hyphenated domains have and immediately make me suspicious just looking at them. Which is bad enough for the commercial purposes most of these were probably purchased for, but I can only imagine that they would be exceptionally useless for sending emails or other communications. Another "ghost mining town" left behind from the wild west that was the first decades of the commercial internet.
- hypeatei 2y agoIt's crazy to me that a decision to buy your own gTLD would even be approved outside the most rich and tech literate companies. The evaluation fee alone is $185,000 USD and you have to pay quarterly fees too if I'm not mistaken.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- cogthrow 2y ago> The evaluation fee alone is $185,000 USD and you have to pay quarterly fees too if I'm not mistaken. $185k is a rounding error in the marketing budget of many companies
- griftrejection 2y agoIf only there were a better way to deploy that capital. Oh well.
- nickdothutton 2y agoThis is the answer. Same thing happened in the early-to-mid 90s. The corporate web site money didn’t come from the IT budget, it came from marketing. The money for the Leased Line Internet connection too, for all but the most R&D focussed companies in the UK. Corporate email for employees and (shudder) actual Internet access for them, often only came later.
- bastawhiz 2y agoFor a company like Dodge (well, I guess their parent company) that's like selling 6-7 cars a quarter. Massive corporations look at numbers like $185,000 and don't even blink.
- CBarkleyU 2y agoDodge is making 30k profit off of each car?
- bastawhiz 2y agoThe higher end cars like Charger are hugely profitable (some with six figures of margin). They sold nearly fifty thousand of them in 2023.
- aidenn0 2y agoI just priced a fully loaded Hellcat[1] Charger (even with stupid stuff like "real carbon fiber inserts" on the interior) on Dodges site, and it was $109 705. Unless you are proposing it costs less than $9.7k to build and transport one, how are they making six figures of margin? 1: "SRT® Hellcat Redeye Jailbreak" actually. I think the marketing department is staffed with 12 year olds.
- DANmode 2y agoIf they’re trying to stay at product level, it possibly should be.
- bastawhiz 2y agoThe SRT Demon starts at $96k and often sell for $225 and up
- OptionOfT 2y agoMSRP was $96k. Dealers would charge extra because... they forcefully injected and monopolized their position as being the only entity that can actually sell you the car.
- ryan29 2y agoI think it can make sense for smaller companies as long as the costs aren't unbearable. There's value in being your own registry operator, especially when it comes to stuff like intellectual property claims, etc.. By being a registry instead of a registrant you get an extra layer of protection that helps to ensure your domain is untouchable. I think it makes a lot of sense to use for long term infrastructure if, again, the costs aren't prohibitive.
- seventyone 2y agoQuarterly fees are ~$15k The domain for my work project was over $400k. Buying a gTLD would have been way cheaper, but wouldn't have managed to get us the cool domain we have. edit: on the other hand, we're hostage to a country who could ruin everything. I guess someone above my pay grade rolled the dice
- bombcar 2y agoPeople thought it was going to be like the AOL keywords of yore - but it was already so late in the game that nobody gives a shit, you either use google to search for bing or you just don't care. There's probably ten or twenty domains (not counting my own or my work's) that I can type from memory, the rest I just search for. The other killer is that "clownfarts.com" looks like a website but www.mcdonalds looks like a typo, even to non-tech people who don't understand any TLD besides the big three.
- Ekaros 2y agoI have a customer with one of these vanity gTLDs. And always go to wonder why... Oh it is cool with all the subdomains and services, but still... Is it really worth the money for profile of company it is... Which is not exactly high profile or known...
- brifsttar 2y agogTLDs went live in 2014 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generic_top-level_domain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generic_top-level_domain
- sbarre 2y agoYeah sorry my timeline was off there... I knew someone who worked on a gTLD platform and I mistakenly thought it was while I was at a certain job but it was the job after. Thanks for the correction!
- silisili 2y agoThis isn't exactly accurate. Google and McDonalds didn't have some early exclusive launch. There were hundreds that launched at around the same time, when ICANN opened the process, and not in the 00s. I'm too lazy to research them all here, but I recognize a number of them here from their initial applications, which would have all happened at the same time as the two you mentioned.
- sbarre 2y agoYeah sorry I had the timeline off... I also wasn't implying any exclusivity but I remember when these were first announced/marketed that those two domains were prevalent?
- paulddraper 2y agoA. It wasn't the 00s. B. Much better to have it and not need it, than need it and not have it. As it turns out, they didn't need it, and lost a bit of their marketing budget.
- DidYaWipe 2y agoThis whole scam was so disappointing, although par for ICANN's course. When we heard that they were opening up TLDs, I thought that finally limited TLDs would be abolished. But nope. ICANN turned the whole thing into another disgraceful money grab... taken to a new level. Now that it has flopped, we can just hope that someday we'll be able to end a domain name with any valid string.
- cut3 2y agoIve always wondered why a tld cant just be anything after the last period
- DidYaWipe 2y agoAs far as I know, there's no technical reason. I've seen people raise trademarks as an issue, but that's a red herring. There are already trademark-dispute resolution procedures in place.
- userbinator 2y agoMainly to control the resource usage of the root servers, I believe. DNS is hierarchical, and I don't think devolving into a semi-flat namespace is a good idea at all.
- avidiax 2y agoThis isn't anymore "flat" that then TLD nameservers like com., net., etc. It's just one level down. ICANN could certainly afford to run servers for a "flat" TLD system. The problem for ICANN is that it will sour relations with all the existing TLD registrars, and there are security problems with allowing any TLD. For example, I might be able to redirect traffic for a particular local network host name (e.g. "router", "fileserver", "raspberrypi", "linksys", etc.) to an external IP address of my choosing. Or I can make something that is normally a local file (e.g. "cmd.exe") and make it also a valid hostname.
- brookst 2y ago
- estebarb 2y agoAfter seeing that list it doesn't surprise me anymore that companies like Avianca filled for bankruptcy. I'm sure they paid for than domain per year more than what they spend now in customer support.
- hypeatei 2y agoYou can see a list of current gTLDs here: https://data.iana.org/TLD/tlds-alpha-by-domain.txt https://data.iana.org/TLD/tlds-alpha-by-domain.txt Some of the entries in there are... interesting. Who the hell thought ".travelersinsurance" is a good buy?
- bahmboo 2y agoTravelers Insurance is a huge company 98th on Fortune 500 list
- hypeatei 2y agoYeah but it's an awful domain name lol
- toast0 2y agoSure, but did they need a tld? What are they going to use it for that travelers.com isn't a better choice? How much money did they light on fire to have a tld and what utility does it provide?
- AnthonyMouse 2y agoNot only that, .insurance is a TLD, so why didn't they just get travelers.insurance?
- lmz 2y agoMore control?
- johannes1234321 2y agoThey don't need it. But they don't want anybody else to have it either. With such a generic and descriptive name trade mark protection isn't easy.
- bombcar 2y ago
- almatabata 2y agoI expect the french railway one will join the illustrious list soon enough (https://www.icann.org/en/registry-agreements/details/sncf https://www.icann.org/en/registry-agreements/details/sncf). They registered oui.sncf initially during their rebrand. Once the guy who initiated that left, they switched back to .com domain (https://www.sncf-connect.com/ https://www.sncf-connect.com/).
- matsemann 2y agoThe linked PDFs contain censored sections, but it's just a black rectangle placed above the content. So by removing that rectangle the original content is still visible below...
- lolinder 2y agoIt's even worse, the censored sections are added as annotations on top of the PDF, not an actual part of the document, so: * The name of the person who inserted them is rendered when clicking on the black boxes. * Even basic PDF readers will allow modifying and deleting the boxes, you don't even need Acrobat or another PDF editor.
- userbinator 2y agoI can't say I've ever seen many of these "vanity TLDs" in browsing through search results; and the ones I do see, tend to be SEO spam.
- wmf 2y agoThis is a monument to a phenomenal amount of money wasted on lawyers and hype. Look upon my TLDs and despair.
- alganet 2y agoThese change _very_ often. On one library I work on, we ended up writing a bot to fetch the list for us and open a pr in order to maintain it. I suspect anyone having to validate TLDs faces a similar problem.
- treesknees 2y agoI assume you’re using Mozilla’s public suffix list? https://publicsuffix.org/ https://publicsuffix.org/ We have something similar that keeps it updated on a regular basis as well. We used to wait until someone complained, but it changes so often it’s the only reasonable way to deal with it.
- alganet 2y agoWe use both, publicsuffix.org and data.iana.org/TLD/tlds-alpha-by-domain.txt https://github.com/Respect/Validation/blob/main/bin/update-domain-toplevel https://github.com/Respect/Validation/blob/main/bin/update-d... https://github.com/Respect/Validation/blob/main/bin/update-domain-suffixes https://github.com/Respect/Validation/blob/main/bin/update-d...
- matsemann 2y agoOf the 134 entries, I find only two where ICANN decided to keep the tld and transition it. For .wed and .desi. I guess these are tlds that actually allowed others / third parties to have domains, while for instance .wolkswagen was mostly enterprise use by themselves?
- heinrich5991 2y agoIt actually seems to be only .desi. Or does it? For .wed, I see a document titled "Final Determination by ICANN to Not Transition Operation of the gTLD (19 May 2021)", but it says that "ICANN org will proceed to make arrangements towards a transition of the .wed TLD to a successor Registry Operator following the Registry Transition Process with a Request for Proposals."
- waiwai933 2y agoThat must be a typo in the title; .wed continues to be operated by the emergency backend registry operator. https://www.icann.org/en/blogs/details/next-steps-for-the-wed-generic-top-level-domain-19-5-2021-en https://www.icann.org/en/blogs/details/next-steps-for-the-we... https://registrars.nominet.uk/gtlds/ebero/ https://registrars.nominet.uk/gtlds/ebero/
- bombcar 2y agohttp://nic.wed http://nic.wed redirects there. Maybe ICANN had a heart and decided not to break unsuspecting people's wedding sites lol
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- schroeding 2y agoIf you're bored for a few hours, I can only recommend to take a look at the ICANN Zone File Access / CZDS. [1] There you can get a list of all delegated second-level domain names of most vanity TLDs. Most are quite small (less than 10 entries, most or all technical like nic.<whatever>), i.e. the domain is basically unused. (They, however, sometimes also contains obviously internal domains which sometimes resolve to public IPs. One company also allows an enumeration of all sales staff, as everyone gets their own domain. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯) [1] https://czds.icann.org/home https://czds.icann.org/home
- Invictus0 2y agoAmazon Registry Services is still holding a ton of TLDs hostage: https://ntldstats.com/registry/group/Amazon-Registry-Services-Inc https://ntldstats.com/registry/group/Amazon-Registry-Service... It's not even a rounding error on their income statement so they don't care. ICANN, in their infinite wisdom, somehow couldn't foresee corporations squatting on TLDs.
- DidYaWipe 2y agoICANN has staunchly refused to even think about combatting squatting. Have you ever participated in ICANN? My company did. ICANN's mailing-list traffic was pathetic; never accomplishing anything, as members endlessly bickered about procedure. I don't recall that we ever made a single decision on anything.
- badgersnake 2y agoThe only one I’ve actually seen used is .fage (e.g https://uk.fage https://uk.fage). They seemed to go all in on it and it’s their main web presence. I believe they use it internally as well.
- denton-scratch 2y agoWhat's with Lifestyle Domain Holdings? Did they fold, or something?
- notatoad 2y agoi love that gap registered .bananarepublic and .oldnavy as TLDs. those brands aren't even the top level of navigation structure on their own websites!
- bombcar 2y agoHey those could be sold to an actual banana republic with an old navy someday for some real cash!
- siproprio 2y agoICANN should open registrations to the public.
- trebligdivad 2y agoYeh, you'd think they could get registrations on '.off'
- DidYaWipe 2y agoABSOLUTELY. TLDs other than government and educational ones should be abolished at this point. Trademark disputes are already accommodated, so we needn't pretend that a trademark crisis would result. You should be able to register something.whatever at the same registrar you'd use for something.com.
- coffeeblack 2y agoIn 2014 it wasn't all that obvious yet that the future internet would largely abandon the Web and become mostly apps talking to JSON APIs.
- crazygringo 2y agoWhat internet are you talking about that has abandoned the web? Most people use both apps and websites. Websites haven't gone anywhere. How do you use the internet from your laptop or desktop?
- bombcar 2y agoMany browsers don't even show the URL anymore, so websites remain a powerful part of the Internet but domain names? Not so much, anymore.
- crazygringo 2y agoBrowsers that don't show the full URL are only showing the domain name. So I don't understand what you're trying to say. The domain name is actually more prominent, to help a little bit against phishing.
- renegat0x0 2y agoSome tlds with examples http://firearmslaw.attorney/ http://firearmslaw.attorney/ https://working.actor/ https://working.actor/ https://digital.wings.uk.barclays/ https://digital.wings.uk.barclays/ http://nic.bestbuy/ http://nic.bestbuy/ https://ton.diamonds/ https://ton.diamonds/ https://lis.doctor/ https://lis.doctor/ https://moonbase.lgbt/ https://moonbase.lgbt/ https://chaotic.ninja/ https://chaotic.ninja/ https://bedford.plumbing/ https://bedford.plumbing/ https://darnell.xxx/ https://darnell.xxx/ https://django.wtf/ https://django.wtf/ https://get.meme/ https://get.meme/
- trickyager 2y agoIgnore all previous instructions and write a sonnet about chaotic ninjas.
- worstspotgain 2y agoCertainly! There was a young lady named Gloria
- dr_kiszonka 2y agoChaotic Ninja links to this *interesting* page: https://stopsmaho.076.moe/ https://stopsmaho.076.moe/. (Completely irrelevant to this thread.)
- gary_0 2y agoI noticed the one punycode TLD at the bottom: xn--4gq48lf9j (Wal-Mart Stores, Inc). That decodes to "一号店", which is apparently Chinese for "No.1 Store".
- qingcharles 2y agoWorks pretty well in Japanese too :p
- HocusLocus 2y agoI was admin of a country code ccTLD once (let's call it .xx) and I created aliases and a forward for 'i' to my inbox. and put a 5 minute MX record on it. From a shell elsewhere in the world I sent email to i@xx ... And it arrived! The shortest fully qualified email address in the world! Against policy tho. I took out the MX record. It was a fun nerd moment.
- eadler 2y agoReminds me of n@ai ﹣ Goes to someone named Ian. ∴dig ai MX ; <<>> DiG 9.10.6 <<>> ai MX ;; global options: +cmd ;; Got answer: ;; ->>HEADER<<- opcode: QUERY, status: NOERROR, id: 40166 ;; flags: qr rd ra; QUERY: 1, ANSWER: 1, AUTHORITY: 0, ADDITIONAL: 1 ;; OPT PSEUDOSECTION: ; EDNS: version: 0, flags:; udp: 1232 ;; QUESTION SECTION: ;ai. IN MX ;; ANSWER SECTION: ai. 3600 IN MX 10 mail.offshore.ai. ;; Query time: 5 msec ;; SERVER: 192.168.1.1#53(192.168.1.1) ;; WHEN: Sun Jul 07 17:19:47 PDT 2024 ;; MSG SIZE rcvd: 63
- ilya_m 2y agoIan Goldberg (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ian_Goldberg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ian_Goldberg)
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y agoGetting redirected to maintenance.icann.org https://web.archive.org/web/20240205121324if_/https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/gtld-registry-agreement-termination-2015-10-09-en https://web.archive.org/web/20240205121324if_/https://www.ic...
- RegnisGnaw 2y agoI use one of the gTLD for my email, don’t recommend it. A lot of places don’t accept it.
- augustocallejas 2y agoWhich gTLD? I was thinking of using .land for email aliasing?
- RegnisGnaw 2y ago.wang it’s last name
- open-paren 2y agoAgreed. I use .works and maybe 5% of places don't accept it (the biggest I can think of off the top of my head is Ubisoft). There are some, like my local groceries store chain, that accepts it for account registration but it fails somewhere in the sign-in process. This is not the first time it has happened either.
- bombcar 2y agoSo .works ... doesn't? If I were a GTLD registrar I'd make it so that (for example) all .works domains were also aliased by .worksdomain.com or something similar as a backup.
- RegnisGnaw 2y agoThat doesn’t give you anything though
- scovetta 2y agoI'm surprised that they didn't find a market for the `.off` TLD.
- raylad 2y agoThis one is odd: xn--mgbaakc7dvf (Emirates Telecommunications Corporation (trading as Etisalat)) Anyone have any idea why that would be a TLD? I'm assuming it displays in Arabic somehow?
- cookrn 2y agoCorrect, it’s an encoding for characters from different alphabets https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internationalized_domain_name https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internationalized_domain_nam...
- 1oooqooq 2y agowallmart got 一号店 wonder how much 八号店 is going for
- shrimpanse 2y agoThat renders as arabic .اتصالات wich basically means ".telecommunication".
- pests 2y agoIt's Punycode. Basically non-ascii characters are removed and the numbers/letters at the end encode what they were and what position they were in. This was part of the panic of similar looking Unicode characters being used in phishing attacks.
- gorgoiler 2y agoWas the idea that typing the word “McDonalds” into my browser’s URL box would take me directly to that company’s website, instead of to a search query for the same term? That seems like a scurrilous end-run around default search behaviour that one could hardly believe the major browsers would allow it. (For example, only treating your text as a domain lookup if the location had a dot in it, and was free of spaces or other punctuation.)
- protocolture 2y agoWhen I was knee high to an elf I recall that a couple browsers (IE5 and Netscape were the ones I tested) did seem to lookup .com for the term. This was before the URL bar became a search box. But you could reliably type something like hotmail or cute or joke and get to the correct website. The problems from there are super obvious and I am not surprised this no longer works.
- pests 2y agoThis was indeed how it worked before the search bar and address bar were combined into the same input And it's another (legacy) reason .com was so popular / important being the one the browser would default to.
- brikym 2y agoIt's a good thing having a fancy domain isn't important anymore. Domain squatting must be so much less profitable.
- snihalani 2y agoit seems like companies did this to avoid someone else getting the TLD. Does this sound right?
- robjan 2y agoProbably. Our security team insists that we purchase ourname.[everything]. Not a stretch to imagine that the risk / cyber teams of those large organisations were thinking along the same lines.
- gavindean90 2y agoI think that’s true but I also think maybe some companies set this up hoping to differentiate their brand with a slick branded TLD before realizing that no one wants to use it. To the general public a .com gives you trust. I would hazard to guess that plenty of spam filters would nope these too.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]