4 ms·
Great example: “ Ptolemy and his astronomical ancestors explained these “retrograde” motions with the extra loops you see in the map above called “epicycles.”
by highfrequency 2y ago
Great example:
“ Ptolemy and his astronomical ancestors explained these “retrograde” motions with the extra loops you see in the map above called “epicycles.” By the 15th century astronomers had accumulated centuries of meticulous measurements and incorporated them into complex orbital paths, matching their observations. Learning these models and taking enough measurements to improve one of them took an entire lifetime of monastic devotion to studying the stars. The burden of knowledge was immense.
But then, Copernicus came along with the heliocentric model which, in its simplest initial form, made worse prediction than the tuned-up Ptolemaic model. But the burden of knowledge was dissolved in an instant. Improving the Copernican model meant shifting orbital paths from perfect circles to ellipses. It had nothing to do with the epicycles and perihelions of the Ptolemaic model and none of that burdensome knowledge was necessary to expand the frontier anew.”
- its_ethan 2y agoYea a cool example, and sure there are others around this time where "we" figured out previous thinking was just fully wrong. But the author then also says: > There are thousands of other examples. Really? Thousands? Are they all similarly examples of pre-scientific method/ pre-industrial revolution knowledge? How many of these "thousand" examples have happened since 1850? Why didn't he list any that have happened in the last 50 years?