2 ms·
On not believing the reduced engagement rumour and the suggested 'lite-youtube-embed'[0]: I am not surprised to hear that a different player will be treated di
by qwery 2y ago
On not believing the reduced engagement rumour and the suggested 'lite-youtube-embed'[0]:
I am not surprised to hear that a different player will be treated differently by users. You just need it to look slightly different or behave slightly differently and it's completely alien and not to be trusted.
The lite-youtube-embed as demoed (even with the title visible) doesn't let me click through to the actual youtube page. There's no link. It could even appear as a no-right-click-esque attempt to prevent me from going to the actual source of the "content" -- it's hostile. Of course, this specific feature could be added easily enough, but it points out a bigger issue.
I almost never play embedded video, but when I do it might as well be the normal youtube experience. If you've wrapped it in what looks like yet another layer (for an unknown purpose), I'm going to be less likely to click on it. You're asking me to contend with youtube/google and another unknown entity.
This article's "nothing sacrificed" is an example of the mistaken belief that developers know how their (or other) software is used by users. You don't and you can't. Not really. You're always guessing.
To be clear, I also want less videos everywhere, less google in everything, less megabytes of javascript in everything, etc. Please stop embedding youtube videos everywhere, to vote for a better web.
[0] https://paulirish.github.io/lite-youtube-embed/ https://paulirish.github.io/lite-youtube-embed/
- X-Cubed 2y agoLikewise, the Save to Watch Later button is also missing from lite-youtube-embed, which is a feature I use a lot. Yes, you can get to it by playing the video, but that defeats the point. I don't want to play the video, I don't want to wait for the video to load only to pause it and click the Save to Watch Later button.
- creatonez 2y agoHuh, even YouTube's official embed UI didn't make the "Watch on YouTube" button obvious enough for me to click on it, so I always hit play, paused the video, and clicked the "YouTube" button in the bottom right instead. Now that I'm aware of it, I wish it was in these lite players, though at least this one doesn't completely bar you from an easy way to get the link.