2 ms·
> If I need security, I buy anti-virus. But I can't opt out of Apples "security". I don't see that as a good thing. If apple wanted to offer that at checkout, I
by ben_w 2y ago
> If I need security, I buy anti-virus. But I can't opt out of Apples "security". I don't see that as a good thing. If apple wanted to offer that at checkout, I wouldn't mind at all.
I can't opt out of the police.
I can opt out of Apple's security by using literally any other brand of phone.
> Worst case scenario, I backup all my stuff.
No, the worse-case scenario is that malware knows everything you look at and everything you type (like bank details), everything you're listening to in real life, your location, your health data, etc.… and can also be used to spy on you through all the phones of the people around you in much the same way even if you don't download any malware yourself.
(And how many of those things would Facebook like to do in the name of "improved advertisement targeting"? If they had full access to photo libraries rather than just what's uploaded to their servers, I'd expect them to try to analyse all my friend's photos that happen to include me for this exact reason, and I'd expect that data to be mis-used by malicious parties just like other ad data has reportedly been).
There's a lot of reason someone should be enforcing rules on this; not so much that it should be Apple doing it.
> whose relationship should end after the device ships to my address
So, not a fan of security patches? :P
> But I like the ease of mind knowing I can take my ball and go home if Google goes rogue (and I can argue thst it has already done so, years ago).
Given that Google has (arguably) already gone rogue, can you actually take your ball and go home? There's a whole subreddit for that, yet every time I've heard other people try, it turns out much harder than anticipated.
> That's the power of open source. The best possible insurance when I go in loops under "official channels".
I have no more reason to trust open source than closed source: underhanded-C contest; at least one example of a Linux distro doing exactly what I'd expect if they were under a secret government order; Reflections on Trusting Trust; the foot-gun nature of C++ combined with its popularity; the number of times someone else has told me to fix something in a PR or QA report where I never spotted the issue while writing the code myself; and the obvious motivations of intelligence agencies worldwide to insert backdoors.
- archagon 2y agoWhat argument is there not to apply the same gatekeeping policy to macOS, then?
- Scion9066 2y agoHistorical inertia. macOS has implemented code signing and only allowing apps from the App Store or trusted developers as default for quite a while now but people still find a way to turn it off or bypass it and then get infected by malware/spyware/adware. Because it's expected that you can run any app on a desktop/laptop platform though, they can't just fully restrict it, and it shows.
- archagon 2y agoIf "historical inertia" is the only thing keeping macOS a general purpose computing platform, that is extremely troubling. Because it means Apple will not hesitate to lock it down in the future if it's able (e.g. through subversion of notarization). To me, this is one of the main reasons to fight for an open iOS: if people get accustomed to corporations revoking access to their software for arbitrary reasons, and if the technology exists allowing them to easily do so, then the gradual introduction of these measures to PC platforms will be met with a collective shrug.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoI mean, it's been happening for a decade now. They only take Metal as a GL, for instance. Their architecture is conforming to IOS. Without any intervention, it's a matter of when instead of if.
- talldayo 2y ago> but people still find a way to turn it off or bypass it and then get infected by malware/spyware/adware. Or they leave it on, and install malware/spyware/adware anyways: https://www.pcmag.com/news/beware-theres-a-fake-lastpass-app-on-apples-app-store https://www.pcmag.com/news/beware-theres-a-fake-lastpass-app... So suffice to say, their whole security scheme leaves a bit to be desired.
- ben_w 2y ago> So suffice to say, their whole security scheme leaves a bit to be desired. Indeed, but always was it so, and always will it be. Also, that story is exactly what I mean when I say that what Apple does is, despite the flaws, still better than nothing: you can't pull a fake app hosted on its own website — you might not even be able to go after the host or the domain registry without a court order, and even then the country in which they are based may not be on good terms with your own and may not care about that order. The analogy here would be using a headline of the police arresting a criminal to say "this shows that the idea of using a police force to prevent crime leaves a bit to be desired". Yes, and?
- johnnyanmac 2y ago> I can't opt out of the police. Given my cultural history, I sure do wish I could. Regardless, police have people holding them accountable some 20% of the time. No one's holding Apple accountable in the US, apparently. >No, the worse-case scenario is Okay... I'm a regular Joe. That sucks but let's not pretend I'm leaking government secrets even if all that happens. I see bad malware on phone (with my data backed up), I reset my phone. It's software, not a serial killer. You can argue identity theft and all that, but that's not a unique feature to IOS/Android/Windows/Linux. So I don't count that as a bonus/demerit to any given platform. >I have no more reason to trust open source than closed source I already gave a reason. The ball is in my court and I can take it home. There are bad actors but also good actors when bad actors arise. Thars a better check and balance than some conglomerate who never had my best interests in mind.
- ben_w 2y ago> I'm a regular Joe. That sucks but let's not pretend I'm leaking government secrets even if all that happens. I see bad malware on phone Back in the desktop days, Regular Joe had malware that they have no idea was on their system. > (with my data backed up), I reset my phone. It's software, not a serial killer. What it is, however, is a thief. Lots of people have juicy secrets, that's why privacy is important in the first place. Malware is very good at keeping hidden these days, running unspotted for a long time. Someone cleans out your bank account, or gets blackmail material on you, backup won't do jack. This is also why certain apps, including banking, include tests to make sure they're not on a rooted device. > So I don't count that as a bonus/demerit to any given platform. Sounds like you only accept silver bullet "solutions". Scare quotes because nothing ever is. The questions are "how often" and "where can be done about it", the answers are not "yes" and "turn it off and on again". > I already gave a reason And I showed why it wasn't sufficient. If you think open source will keep you safe, you are treating it as the exact silver bullet you're criticising Apple for not being. > Thars a better check and balance than some conglomerate who never had my best interests in mind. There's no real balance, and the checks are insufficient — there are definitely bugs that only get spotted a decade later, there are definitely state-sponsored flaws in OSS code, definitely some cases of normal criminals buying off some projects, and definitely cases where we don't find out about these things until much later. And of course, quite a lot of OSS projects are in fact directly funded and managed by a corporation — the cathedral and the bazaar have both blended into a metaphorical Amazon marketplace, complete with fake reviews for fake products.