4 ms·
Omnipotence is provably impossible: "Could Jesus microwave a burrito so hot that he himself could not eat it?" etc. Super-intelligence, not so much — there's p
by ben_w 2y ago
Omnipotence is provably impossible: "Could Jesus microwave a burrito so hot that he himself could not eat it?" etc.
Super-intelligence, not so much — there's plenty of examples of above-average humans in many areas, and no reason to think that putting the top expert in each field into one room is impossible, and no reason to think that this configuration cannot be implemented in software with a sufficiently powerful computer.
And that's without the things that machines already beat us at, because super-human chess playing software is easily available, and computers that do arithmetic better than the entire human species even if we were all trained to the level of the current world record holder are cheap enough to be given away free glued to the front of a magazine, so there's no single person who has a particular advantage with those things.
What chess does do, is give an example: if I was playing a game with Kasparov, I would have no idea which move he might make at any given moment, but despite that I'd still expect him to win.
With an AI, I don't even necessarily know what "game" it's playing even if I'm the one who wrote the utility function it's trying to maximise.
- wait_a_minute 2y agoOmnipotence just means being able to do whatever power can do. So it is incoherent to ask if God could make a square circle. The words don’t mean anything. God could make a burrito too hot for himself to eat. Then he could make himself capable of eating it. Rinse and repeat.
- orbisvicis 2y agoYeah I never really bought that language argument - the idea that the paradox arises solely from a schism between language and reality. I prefer to think eschatology solves the issue quite nicely. The omnipotent entity is the one for which such a situation never arises. Similarly if a universe evolves to give rise to God, who is to say that God was never present. Or all around us, really? Either way I'd say Matthew 4:1 solves that paradox in a way that satisfies billions of people. Though I am getting a kick out of imagining Mexican/American Jesus munching on burritos.
- ben_w 2y ago> Matthew 4:1 I don't understand why that would have any effect? "Then Jesus was led by the Spirit into the wilderness to be tempted by the devil."
- orbisvicis 2y agoSidestepping the issue of whether or not Jesus is actually omnipotent, the devil tempted Jesus and Jesus was like, "nah, not going to happen".
- ben_w 2y agoThere's two things there, and I don't get either of them. First, if you want to sidestep if Jesus is omnipotent, then it's no longer saying anything about omnipotence. Second, you also have to make the devil omnipotent. Actually, the second point has a sub-point, because if it's two different entities then you get "an unstoppable force meets an immovable object" which is more easily resolved by "the force just passes right through the object without influencing it" — for the self-contradiction I gave to even be present, you would need to regard the devil as being another aspect of Yahweh in the same regard that Jesus is an incarnation of Yahweh within Christianity (not to be confused with how Jesus is seen in Islam, which totally rejects this as polytheistic idolatry).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]