4 ms·

Google sent a copyright violation notice for each .DS_Store anyone at my company uploaded to Drive for nearly a year (yes, many support tickets were filed). It

Google sent a copyright violation notice for each .DS_Store anyone at my company uploaded to Drive for nearly a year (yes, many support tickets were filed). It wasn't Apple's fault, but it still would have been nice if there was a way to turn them off.

heavyset_go 2y ago
That's scary considering how willingly they'll shutdown accounts for tripping their automated copyright violation service.
- prurigro 2y ago
  For sure! I made sure to have an open ticket with them until it was resolved so I'd have someone to call if some other automated system decided to shut down our services for it.
janalsncm 2y ago
Why? Somehow DS_Store is claimed as a copyrighted file?
- biztos 2y ago
  White noise was claimed on YouTube[0]. When is someone going to copyright .gitignore? You could register gitignore.me right now! Fame, riches, lunch with Myhrvold[1][2]! [0]: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-42580523 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-42580523 [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_Ventures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_Ventures [2]: https://www.amazon.com/Modernist-Cuisine-Science-Stainless-Slipcase/dp/1734386142/ https://www.amazon.com/Modernist-Cuisine-Science-Stainless-S...
- prurigro 2y ago
  That's a good question. I get the impression the system is fairly opaque even to the people working there. I was told it was "resolved" and had my ticket closed a bunch of times, only to have another 30+ copyright violation emails the next time someone uploaded a batch of files from MacOS. If the person who finally managed to figure it out ends to reading this, thanks for the resolution :)
- Pikamander2 2y ago
  The process likely went something like this: 1. Pirates uploaded a folder full of copyrighted files to Google Drive, accidentally including some DS_Store files along with the actual media. 2. The copyright owner filed a DMCA takedown on the whole folder, accidentally claiming ownership of a bunch of generic DS_Store files. 3. The above two steps have likely happened many times, not just once. 4. Google's takedown system now automatically flags DS_Store files as having multiple copyright violations. 5. A Google employee might be able to whitelist a user's individual DS_Store files to temporarily suppress the violation on their account, but since they can appear in different folders with different data and are constantly receiving new copyright claims, their system likely errs on the side of caution and continues to flag them as copyright violations so that Google doesn't accidentally lose its safe harbor protections. In theory, a Google engineer could code in a special case to avoid this problem, but good luck finding and talking to one who's authorized to do so; Google is notorious for having one of the lowest employee;revenue ratios in the world and writing useless FAQs instead of having a proper support channel for when things go wrong.
  - Wowfunhappy 2y ago
    > In theory, a Google engineer could code in a special case to avoid this problem And then in this alternate universe, pirates start naming all of their files ".DS_Store"!
gumby 2y ago
Holy cow, that’s crazy!

heavyset_go 2y ago

That's scary considering how willingly they'll shutdown accounts for tripping their automated copyright violation service.

prurigro 2y ago
For sure! I made sure to have an open ticket with them until it was resolved so I'd have someone to call if some other automated system decided to shut down our services for it.

janalsncm 2y ago

Why? Somehow DS_Store is claimed as a copyrighted file?

biztos 2y ago
White noise was claimed on YouTube[0]. When is someone going to copyright .gitignore? You could register gitignore.me right now! Fame, riches, lunch with Myhrvold[1][2]! [0]: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-42580523 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-42580523 [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_Ventures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_Ventures [2]: https://www.amazon.com/Modernist-Cuisine-Science-Stainless-Slipcase/dp/1734386142/ https://www.amazon.com/Modernist-Cuisine-Science-Stainless-S...
prurigro 2y ago
That's a good question. I get the impression the system is fairly opaque even to the people working there. I was told it was "resolved" and had my ticket closed a bunch of times, only to have another 30+ copyright violation emails the next time someone uploaded a batch of files from MacOS. If the person who finally managed to figure it out ends to reading this, thanks for the resolution :)
Pikamander2 2y ago
The process likely went something like this: 1. Pirates uploaded a folder full of copyrighted files to Google Drive, accidentally including some DS_Store files along with the actual media. 2. The copyright owner filed a DMCA takedown on the whole folder, accidentally claiming ownership of a bunch of generic DS_Store files. 3. The above two steps have likely happened many times, not just once. 4. Google's takedown system now automatically flags DS_Store files as having multiple copyright violations. 5. A Google employee might be able to whitelist a user's individual DS_Store files to temporarily suppress the violation on their account, but since they can appear in different folders with different data and are constantly receiving new copyright claims, their system likely errs on the side of caution and continues to flag them as copyright violations so that Google doesn't accidentally lose its safe harbor protections. In theory, a Google engineer could code in a special case to avoid this problem, but good luck finding and talking to one who's authorized to do so; Google is notorious for having one of the lowest employee;revenue ratios in the world and writing useless FAQs instead of having a proper support channel for when things go wrong.
- Wowfunhappy 2y ago
  > In theory, a Google engineer could code in a special case to avoid this problem And then in this alternate universe, pirates start naming all of their files ".DS_Store"!

gumby 2y ago

Holy cow, that’s crazy!