3 ms·
I find it fantastical that anyone in the geopolitical environment would put themselves at the (near instantaneous) mercy of someone that far away - physically a
by lazide 2y ago
I find it fantastical that anyone in the geopolitical environment would put themselves at the (near instantaneous) mercy of someone that far away - physically and politically.
We’ve already seen the games played with hydrocarbon pipelines, and hydrocarbons are easy to store in large quantities, which greatly reduces the risk of someone playing ‘got you!’ on something that literally is a matter of life and death.
It still - clearly - happens, but when it does it isn’t as urgent as freezing to death tonight if you don’t do what they want. Unless they’re also bombing your storage tanks, which does happen, but is a significant escalation over ‘oops, we hit the power cable with an anchor again. Sorry!’.
For the Russia example, in the situations Russia wouldn’t want to cut it - the US and China would love to! Or have a proxy do it for them.
And if Russia has enough battery storage to last a week or two (minimum to outlast a storm; and also more than adequate to deal with daily insolation variation), they don’t have much of a need for these cables either, correct? At least most of the time.
In fact, in those cases the cables would actually present a bit of a problem, as they would potentially cause economic/trade/currency balances, similar to the Oil trade, and make it less economic to actually have the appropriate degree of local storage and production necessary.
The same issues pop up even regionally - Europe has a history of not always being super peaceful, so if, say, the UK wants to run a HVDC line to Spain, they have to think long and hard about the implications. As does Spain.
Because if Germany does that they did a few generations ago, that cable isn’t going to last long, and if the UK doesn’t have adequate safe alternatives, then they’re going to have a really hard time fighting back. And if Spain decides to raise rates to ruinous levels of the UK ‘brexits’, what leverage does the UK have?
Let alone not freezing to death. And Spain needs to consider they might be broke in such a situation, and having a hard time paying their own bills.
And if they do have adequate alternatives, then why is it a big deal to have the cable? What does it actually offer?
As to if it’s a single cable or a million of them or a lattice or whatever - the big question is ‘why?’ when the rest of these factors come into play. The materials cost to build and maintain it doesn’t help either.
- ben_w 2y agoThat all sounds like politics? If so, that's a point we agree on :) None of that seems like physical issues, despite you mentioning that on the first paragraph. > For the Russia example, in the situations Russia wouldn’t want to cut it - the US and China would love to! Or have a proxy do it for them. If they have alternatives, otherwise they're all in the same boat whose name is "interdependence". China's also the only country that seems to have any even slightly serious interest in attempting to build anything close to such a grid in the first place, as part of their own soft-power projection, and are the only country producing enough aluminium to attempt it anyway — half of all current global production is factories they switched on since 2006: https://international-aluminium.org/statistics/primary-aluminium-production/ https://international-aluminium.org/statistics/primary-alumi... Nobody else but China will bother in the foreseeable future, and even China might not. (Which is yet another rephrasing of the same point I've been making throughout). > And if Russia has enough battery storage to last a week or two (minimum to outlast a storm; and also more than adequate to deal with daily insolation variation), they don’t have much of a need for these cables either, correct? At least most of the time. Sure, but a week of storage is at least* 14 times more expensive than overnight storage. If you see your enemies building up a lot of storage without any clear reason, you know Something Is Up, just like if you see them amassing tanks on your border. If they have a clear reason, "there is no power grid in the first place" being one, then it's harder to know they're doing something odd. > And if they do have adequate alternatives, then why is it a big deal to have the cable? What does it actually offer? Lower price. I'm expecting batteries to get cheaper, but the current price is in the order of $100/kWh capacity, if they last 1000 cycles that's $100/MWh delivered*. If you have to size your battery packs for long-term use, be it Dunkelflaute or seasonal or military shenanigans, you don't get to discount that, it's what it is; but if you're only using it for emergencies, then those batteries don't wear down as fast just because you don't go through those cycles so often — how much depends on the duration and frequency of the emergency, and also how well your batteries cope whatever they do in a non-emergency condition. A global mega-project is obviously going to be more expensive than the mere material costs; even the opportunity cost of what else they could do with the same resources is a huge question, and why it's heavily in the "politics and economics" domain rather than the mere physicality. But the mere physicality that I'm openly and explicitly and repeatedly acknowledging comes with additional political difficulties**, that's a few hundred billion for a thing that lasts 75-120 years based on other examples; it would carry in the order of a terawatt continuously, 24/7, for about 1/250th - 1/440th the price of batteries: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=%28239+billion+USD%29+%2F+%2875+TW-years%29+in+USD%2FMWh https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=%28239+billion+USD%29+%... * Night has significantly lower demand: you've got 50% power demand, that's 1/3rd of the total daily energy demand from draining batteries, so they only add $33/MWh to the deliverable cost. ** It's frustrating that this combination is still ignored so often when I mention this physical possibility; how can I possibly be clearer that I know that all the other stuff besides actually building it is hard?
- lazide 2y ago? Politics cause physical issues. Like things getting bombed. And physical things like distance impact politics - it’s easy to blame a country on the other side of the world vs a neighbor (that people know), or ourselves, for instance. And why it’s a fantasy is the large capex needs to be spent - while the period of least trust and apparent need exists. And a lot of distance needs to be built before it produces any potential value. And the physical issues. And the politics. And since the benefit comes from the long distances, this isn’t something that is ignorable. If such a thing already existed, for instance, and countries were using it without abusing it, then being able to justify the cost - and not feel a need for lots of storage - is likely easy. And it’s easy to trust someone when you can see the actual economic incentives for them to behave, and have a track record of it happening. And if everyone is (actually) using it, then it is hard to pick one party (you) off without the whole group ganging up on the offender. But without such a thing existing, everyone needs to worry about whoever is funding it (if a large country) abusing it to control them, or if everyone is funding it, some random country they don’t like throwing up roadblocks to stop the project actually working for them - and bankrupting them. And since it wouldn’t benefit all countries simultaneously (due to the physical difficulty in constructing such a thing), and it won’t even be actually useful until it is very long already, there is a larger risk of hard feelings and sabotage. And since they would be dependent on it reaching so far, and countries being so far away playing nicely, the risk on that front is huge. And the only meaningful way to mitigate that risk is to build lots of storage at a national level. Which also removes the primary advantages of the project in the first place.