3 ms·
Nice experiment, but they are still measuring neutrons, that are quite small. I don't understand why they try to sell this as a macroscopic experiment. Bell ine
by gus_massa 2y ago
Nice experiment, but they are still measuring neutrons, that are quite small. I don't understand why they try to sell this as a macroscopic experiment. Bell inecuality can be also measured at long distances, but it doesn't make it a macroscopic experiment.
- pottspotts 2y agoI would argue that the neutrino is relatively large compared to the quanta typical of these kinds of tests, but in the abstract they suggested a basketball!
- gus_massa 2y agoI think most test of bell inequality are made using photons. I'm not sure about this inequality. Neutrons are much bigger than photons [1], but somewhat similar experiments of interference have been made with helium atoms and even small molecules (with 10 atoms or so). So if they say it's big in the quantum word, I expect at least a molecule. And the article saying macroscopic everywhere really sugest basketballs. From the initial description, I was optimistic and I was expecting small dots of "dust", or a tiny thin membrane. There are some experimental results with extremly small object, but I guess they have a lot of thechnical problems and are difficult to use them in complex measurements. [1] Ignoring a lot of technical details.
- drdeca 2y agoNeutrino ≠ neutron. The “ino” in neutrino is like a diminutive. Neutrons are much heavier than a neutrino. I don’t think they have a positive lower bound on the size of the smallest mass eigenstate of neutrinos (though they do on the other two).
- gus_massa 2y agoI agree. (I missed the "ino".) It's also important that (as far as we know) the neutrino is an elementary particle, but the neutron is composed by three real quarks and a lot of virtual quarks and gluons, it's a huge mess of smaller particles together.
- klyrs 2y agoMuch better if they use a proton beam, and combine it with similarly split electron beams. Then, collect the resulting hydrogen in two bottles and measure the resulting mass. Boom, quantum gravity.
- mannykannot 2y agoI have learned to pay special attention when the phrase 'in a sense' is being used - sometimes it is in a relevant sense, sometimes not. Unfortunately, I'm not knowledgeable enough to make the call on this one.