4 ms·
It doesn't have to be credible. It just has to be noise. The West can push back. Here's a 2023 list of separatist movements within Russia.[1] Most of these are
by Animats 2y ago
It doesn't have to be credible. It just has to be noise.
The West can push back. Here's a 2023 list of separatist movements within Russia.[1] Most of these are small and weak, but with outside support, pieces of Russia might be destabilized.
St. Petersburg/Leningrad oblast has potential, because it's close to Europe.
With Finland and Estonia both in NATO, access to St. Peterburg is available. The Russian military is rather busy with Ukraine, and there might not be enough troops available to quickly suppress an internal revolt.
[1] https://www.aalep.eu/major-secessionist-movements-russia https://www.aalep.eu/major-secessionist-movements-russia
- riffraff 2y agoThis makes no sense, the west has a system where people more favorable to Russia can be elected with some effort (trump, le pen, salvini, farage). Discrediting Putin online will have zero effect on Russian politics.
- fakedang 2y ago> Discrediting Putin online will have zero effect on Russian politics. Discrediting Putin online will have zero effect on Russian politics because the people already know he's shit. The issue is that a.) they can't do much about it, and b.) many actually support the invasion.
- ben_w 2y agoFarage can only theoretically be elected; in practice, he's never even won his own seat, and his party has had a high of one (out of 650) constituencies, but even that was as a result of someone defecting from a different party. I'm not even sure if he made a difference about Brexit vs. Johnson.
- sam_lowry_ 2y agoWhile US have had some influence on Russian domestic politics 25 years ago, it has none now. The list is interesting as the base for the scission of Russia once the West wins the war, though.
- bell-cot 2y agoGiven the past couple years' events in Ukraine, separatism or succession might look pretty unattractive to Russians. A far more enticing scenario would be a second Wagner Group Rebellion...one that was competently organized and lead, and successfully replaced the current regime. Putin most certainly remembers how disinterested both his citizens and his military were in opposing the tiny, ragtag Wagner Group's march toward Moscow.
- jajko 2y agoDon't hold your breath for that, steps have been taken that should prevent it in future. puttin' ain't the smartest currently, but he still has some chops form his KGB career and is paranoid beyond wildest imagination. Anybody who posed any sort of real threat has been murdered either by throwing out of some high windows or just whole family with kids slaughtered for show. People in the west don't grok how downtrodden russian population is, for centuries, cca continuously. Thats why democracy didn't work there, people let wolves do whatever they wanted since nobody understood that you actually have to stand up to them, so we are where we are. Military comes from the same population, just worse characters. There ain't no easy solution that we would like. They are not rational now and I don't think they will be till puttin' dies, and who knows what other clown will take the helm. They don't keep sharpest most rational folks at top levels, and next guy won't be somebody from lower ranks.
- bell-cot 2y ago> Don't hold your breath ... No, I don't particularly expect it to happen. But Russia has a long history of revolutions when things (especially wars) were not going well for the current Czar / General Secretary / whatever. > There ain't no easy solution that we would like. True, for the big picture. But my comment was in response to user Animats saying "The West can push back." (About the article, on Russian fake news operations targeting the West.) If pushing back is the game plan, then "what does Putin most fear?" is an excellent basis for the pushback strategy. Ideally, he'd pull the plug on his fake news, because the pushback was too scary.
- eru 2y ago> The West can push back. Here's a 2023 list of separatist movements within Russia. I'm not sure you necessarily want to fight fire with fire?
- ovi256 2y agoThey're already setting us on fire
- eru 2y agoMy point is that you might want to fight fire with eg water. So you can fight back, but you don't need to necessarily copy your adversaries tactics.
- tim333 2y agoIndeed I think the west is better sticking to pushing for rule of law, secure borders, human rights and the like. IMO on Ukraine they should have said invading a basically peaceful democratic state to grab its land is unacceptable and we'll support Ukraine winning and taking their land back with whatever weaponry necessary. Instead of the wishy washy, no real goal, drip feed some weapons to get a stalemate where Russia keeps some land. Why still no f16s two and a half year in? Why can't Ukraine hit the airfields they are bombed daily from and so on? Why won't the US govt say they'd like Ukraine to win? Even if they don't, just saying it would be a good tool to scare the Russians into better negotiations.
- eru 2y agoIt's even worse: Russia invaded Ukraine in 2014. It's now 10 years into this conflict.
- ClumsyPilot 2y agoThis is more like trying to fight fire with cancer - not effective and likely to backfire. Russia is not going to come apart, especially not areas close to the capital. And if it did, you would have thermonuclear weapons in the hands of rando’ nobodies.
- mamonster 2y ago>St. Petersburg/Leningrad oblast has potential, because it's close to Europe. With Finland and Estonia both in NATO, access to St. Peterburg is available. The Russian military is rather busy with Ukraine, and there might not be enough troops available to quickly suppress an internal revolt You have to be absolutely delusional to believe St Petersburg would be seceding. It's arguably even more imperialistic than than Moscow itself, and it is managed by the staunchest Putin loyalists (Current governor, Beglov, is a full-on militarist and Putin lieutenant since the 90s).
- pjc50 2y ago> The West can push back This sort of hybrid warfare does not work in non-free societies. No, the strategy that works is shipping Ukraine a series of rocket artillery with gradually increasing range to target oil infrastructure in the interior. Oh, and sanctions that actually prevent military engineering, such as on machine tools. (edit: if you actually want to peel territory off Russian control, you could start with the satellite states in the caucasus, or the weird Russian exclave in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transnistria https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transnistria )
- justsomehnguy 2y ago> Here's a 2023 list of separatist movements within Russia >> Sakha: Sakha or Yakut separatism seeks the creation of an independent Yakutian state. The primary cause of Yakut separatism is economic exploitation by the federal government. Tell me you never looked at the map without telling me anything. > Most of these are small and weak, but with outside support, pieces of Russia might be destabilized Ah, yes, when the Free World (tm) doing this it is the Right Thing (tm). It's only when whose untermenschen not from the Free World (tm) is doing exactly the same then it's totally not the Right Thing (tm). > With Finland and Estonia both in NATO, access to St. Peterburg is available. The Russian military is rather busy with Ukraine, and there might not be enough troops available to quickly suppress an internal revolt. I wouldn't even bet my pumpkin latte what if Russia would 'support from the outside' some separatism movements you would scream bloody murder. It's always fascinating to see people actively inciting a war, while comfortably sitting an ocean away from any consequences.
- ClumsyPilot 2y agoYe, it’s wired how advocating for/inciting civil war in a nuclear armed state is not questioned as A) inhumane B) violation of all proclaimed western values C) mad dangerous
- surfingdino 2y agoThere is no need to do more than park the might of the NATO military along the borders and watch the Russian army die in Ukraine. The war in Ukraine is waged in Excel and it is an equation with the expected outcome of destroying their military, equipment and personnel. Dead men won't have children, so the more of them die there the weaker Russia will be in the decades to come.
- ramesh31 2y ago> Dead men won't have children, so the more of them die there the weaker Russia will be in the decades to come. Sadly it seems this is Putin's goal as well. What we are seeing is looking more and more like a mass genocide of Russia's undesirables by means of Forever War, with any further territorial gains as a nice bonus. And with all forms of dissent ground into the dust, and a global market more than happy to keep buying his oil, he can continue at this pace indefinitely.
- surfingdino 2y agoNot indefinitely. He lost skilled workers, his infrastructure is falling apart and the Western companies that used to maintain it are not coming back. He will be soon leasing Siberia to China.
- ramesh31 2y ago>Not indefinitely. He lost skilled workers, his infrastructure is falling apart and the Western companies that used to maintain it are not coming back. Indefinitely meaning at least his lifetime of the next 10-15 years. It doesn't take much skill to manufacture rifles and artillery shells. Probably there will be some uneasy truce reached in that time. But in the end this war will most likely look a lot like Iran-Iraq: ~1 million total military dead over ten years with no meaningful gains on either side.
- ClumsyPilot 2y ago> mass genocide of Russia's undesirables by means of Forever War The war indeed has no clear endpoint, and claiming that ‘Russia is hurt, that is good’ is not a replacement for having a plan. One must consider casualties on the Ukrainian side, and they should not be in vain. This is how you end up with a debacle like Afghanistan. Re. Genocide I think it’s unhelpful to muddy the water. Russia is a multi-ethnic and multi-religious state. It’s made up of ethnic and religious republics - for example Chechnya is Islamic. Some of these ethnic groups don’t like each other. Putin does not allow talk of ethnic cleansing or similar because it will open the door to internal conflict and would be the beginning of Russia falling apart. Look at the tone in the press for internal consumption, both in Russia and in the certain western supported Middle Eastern country. Use google translate, for example: https://www.vesti.ru/article/4029512 https://www.vesti.ru/article/4029512 And then compare it with the tone of this, written by a minister of national security: https://x.com/itamarbengvir/status/1808031178277925263 https://x.com/itamarbengvir/status/1808031178277925263
- cies 2y ago[flagged]
- pjc50 2y agoRussia has already made Ukraine into its next Afghanistan. They'll eventually leave after huge casualties. > strong bloc of Russia-China-Iran-DPRK-Belarus Lol.
- cies 2y ago[flagged]
- pjc50 2y ago> See how Mariupol is being rebuilt You cannot expect praise for needlessly destroying somewhere and then rebuilding it.
- cies 2y ago> You cannot expect praise for needlessly destroying somewhere and then rebuilding it. The word "needlessly" is being contested. If the Minsk accord were adhered to it was not needed. Apparently some felt this was needed. Also: what did US/Ukraine do to rebuild Iraq? As that was my point... The wars are very different and IMHO Russia behaves much better in all phases (the lead up, and the war itself) than the US did in all it's invasions (and Ukraine did in it's invasion of Iraq).
- distances 2y ago> The wars are very different and IMHO Russia behaves much better in all phases (the lead up, and the war itself) than the US did in all it's invasions This, like most of your claims, is full-on delusional, or just brazen propaganda. I probably shouldn't bother even answering. Russian attack is best compared to USSR and German attacks in WW2, not any modern scenario. Both in the authoritarian and imperialistic setup, and in the execution that has no qualms with generating war crimes of all kinds.
- lossolo 2y ago> The West can push back. Isn't it obvious that the West, particularly the US, as their decisions are most influential, does not want to fully push back? By "fully" I mean desiring Russia's collapse. That’s why, even after two years, they haven't provided jet fighters (yet), nor have they permitted the use of their weapons to target Russia more extensively (only on borders with Kharkiv after 2 years of war). Actions speak louder than words. This behavior is clearly reactive, enough weapons are provided to maintain the status quo, ensuring that Russia does not advance further, but not enough for Ukrainians to alter the current situation on the battlefield. If the US wanted to, they could supply Ukraine with enough weapons to defeat Russia on the battlefield. But that’s not the goal, it’s not about Ukraine winning, but about not losing and preventing Russia from winning. A complete defeat of Russia is contrary to US interests, anarchy and chaos in a nuclear state would be far more dangerous, especially given that regions like Tajikistan have significant potential for terrorism (consider how ISIS started). Such a scenario would likely push Russia closer to becoming a Chinese vassal, which is against US interests. If you believe that a genuine democracy could emerge from that chaos, then you don't understand Russia at all. The deep state there is as entrenched, if not more so, than Putin, and it holds enough power and influence to prevent any truly democratic force from emerging. There is no real opposition left after Navalny's death.