2 ms·
HTTPS is more secure than HTTP... but when it's possible to get bogus SSL certificates like this, it's apparently not very much more secure.
by cperciva 18y ago
HTTPS is more secure than HTTP... but when it's possible to get bogus SSL certificates like this, it's apparently not very much more secure.
- ars 18y agoNot exactly. HTTPS does two things: 1: verifies who the other party is and prevents MITM attacks. 2: encrypts the connection and prevents snooping #2 still works fine, and for many people it's the only thing they care about since MITM attacks are quite rare, and if you typed the domain name yourself you don't need the verification either.
- brl 18y agoYou can't securely exchange keys to do #2 without having #1. Not sure why you think active attacks are more rare than any other attack against TLS/SSL sessions. Any time you are in a position to perform a passive attack (snooping) you could also perform an active attack (MITM). The only difference is which point-and-click attack tool you download.
- ars 18y agoNot true - otherwise self signed certificates would be pointless. #1 and #2 are independent. And you can snoop WiFi, but you can't do MITM. (Not easily anyway, you'd need a radio jammer and other gear.)