2 ms·
theoretically your result has to be (1) novel and (2) published with such a good explanation that people understand both the result and what's novel about it, a
by kragen 2y ago
theoretically your result has to be (1) novel and (2) published with such a good explanation that people understand both the result and what's novel about it, as well as how to reproduce it, but yes. the difference between tinkering and science is documentation, and it needs to be public and conscious of the existing discourse to be scholarship
- gwervc 2y agoThe biggest difference is gate-keeping by peer review, which is quite random. Reproductibility is a meme in most fields.
- jvanderbot 2y agoEven in random noise, with enough samples the signal is measurable. Thus - publish or perish.
- kragen 2y agoi knew someone was going to reply by pointing out that academia often fails to live up to the standards of scholarship and, where applicable, science. but that's sort of missing the point; i was describing the standards, not how the existing institutions' performance measures up to them
- brabel 2y agoNo offence, but what's novel in this post??? I found it pretty basic, or?