3 ms·
> Abortion A case ultimately rooted in the legal theory or “emanations from penumbras” in the Constitution. > fair share union dues Forcing government employ
by rayiner 2y ago
> Abortion
A case ultimately rooted in the legal theory or “emanations from penumbras” in the Constitution.
> fair share union dues
Forcing government employees to pay dues to a private organization they disagree with politically.
> Chevron
Overturning an earlier case that had ruled in favor of an oil company.
> Citizens United
Held that making a political movie about Hilary Clinton was free speech.
> gutting the Voting Rights Act
Finding that Congress couldn’t impose different voting rights requirements on different states based on a 40 year old formula.
> this week effectively legalizing bribery of government officials
Overturned a conviction for accepting bribes in connection with an official act, where the jury was instructed that it was irrelevant whether the defendant had corrupt intent at the time of the official act.
I don’t know what historians will say about the current Supreme Court. But historians (and journalists) are feelers (in the Meyers Briggs sense), not thinkers. They think in terms of human stories and impacts on people, rather than logical systems. Who cares what feelers think about legal precedents?
- skhunted 2y agoYou are not engaging in a good fait discussion if you think Citizen's United was just allowing a movie to be made about Hilary Clinton and that it was truly about free speech. It's about the consequences of the rulings and what the ruling said. The consequence of Citizen's United have been very bad for politics. Since Citizen's United outside spending on federal elections has greatly increased as a percent of total spending. Super PAC spending has greatly increased. This ruling was not about free speech. > gutting the Voting Rights Act Finding that Congress couldn’t impose different voting rights requirements on different states based on a 40 year old formula. Another example of disingenuous discourse. Thousands of polling stations have closed in the south as a result of the ruling and those closure occurred in areas to disenfranchise black and other undesirable voters. The Voting Rights Act had become so commonly accepted that it passed Congress on its last passage almost without any nay votes. Even die hard conservatives were caught off guard by the courts ruling. You are not living in reality with these beliefs of yours.
- tptacek 2y agoRayiner has written at length and persuasively about Citizen's United and is, on this issue, clearly engaging in good faith. You disagree with him, which is unsurprising, but not an indication of falsity on his part. If you feel like someone isn't discussing things in good faith with you, the right response is to stop discussing. Assume good faith https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- skhunted 2y agoI’m not assuming it was in bad faith. It is a bad faith argument to say that Citizens was merely about allowing a group of people to make a movie about Hilary Clinton. Do you think he is immune to making bad faith arguments? That he has argued in good faith in the past does not mean he can’t argue in bad faith in the future. Dred Scott was just about property rights and how the government shouldn’t be allowed to take your property.
- rayiner 2y agoLegal precedents are about the facts and law at issue in the case. Courts do not weigh in on larger policy debates in society. Your suggestion that Dred Scott was “about property rights” and slavery was incidental is blatantly inaccurate. It was a lengthy legal defense of the institution of black slavery as such: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dred_Scott_v._Sandford https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dred_Scott_v._Sandford In your view, what should the Supreme Court have ruled in Citizens United? That movies made through corporate entities aren’t protected by the first amendment?
- skhunted 2y agoCourts do not weigh in on larger policy debates in society. It is entirely naive to think this of SCOTUS decisions in landmark cases. It is naive to think these 9 people are immune to political considerations of their decisions. It’s the legal equivalent of the story we tell children about Washington chopping down the cherry tree. It’s a feel good notion to think that SCOTUS justices don’t weigh in on larger policy debates and this notion has no basis in reality. SCOTUS is political institution that weighs in on legal and occasionally political matters. It’s a balancing act they must perform if they wish to preserve the integrity of the institution. When they act as they have in recent years the possibility arises that people lose confidence in it and thus erode its power/prestige. This is true of all institutions that oversee governance of a nation. When things get too out of balance political forces, sometimes in the form of violence, effect the necessary changes to reach a new equilibrium that the populace is sufficiently satisfied with.