4 ms·
What market is Apple dominating? Microsoft is still king of the desktop. Android has a bigger install base for phones. Others attempt to make tablets, they just
by al_borland 2y ago
What market is Apple dominating? Microsoft is still king of the desktop. Android has a bigger install base for phones. Others attempt to make tablets, they just aren’t appealing to people… and the market seems open, as people often say iPadOS cripples the iPad hardware. Google wins on services.
I think of Apple kind of like Nintendo, but for computers.
- sneak 2y agoApple gets to charge 5-10x market rates for credit card processing inside all iOS apps, which is a big and captive market. Normal is 2-3% and they charge 15-30%.
- dagmx 2y agoThe 15-30% isn’t for credit card processing. In countries where Apple has allowed external payments, they’ve broken out the cost for payment processing to 3%. If you’re talking about standard rates, 30% is standard in most online stores like Steam, Google Play, PSN etc… None of them purport that the 30% is solely for payment processing.
- talldayo 2y ago[flagged]
- dagmx 2y agoI’m not arguing your shifted goalposts because it’s pointless and subjective to argue perceived value. The person claimed it was just payment processing fees and I corrected them objectively .
- talldayo 2y agoObjectivism isn't correct, here. You are comparing a captive audience with zero internal competition to three competing platforms, all that set their pricing in accordance with their competition. Apple has no competitive pressure, therefore comparing their pricing to competing stores is rationally nonsense. The rates on PSN, Steam and Google Play Store are "standard" because they have competitors that hold that price accountable. Apple does not. If you cannot see the anticompetitive harm there then I don't know what to say to you besides "better prepare your 401k for the worst".
- al_borland 2y agoIf the Google Play Store and the Apple App Store have the same fee structure, and your argument is that Google got their through competitive pricing… how can you claim Apple is taking advantage of their position when there is no price gouging going on when compared to other platforms that are offering the exact same service on another platform?
- paulmd 2y agoNo App Store runs at 3% transacgoon fee - that’s the credit card interchange fee. Steam is 30% (with limited exceptions for review samples and humble bundle and other limited off-platform transactions). Microsoft store and PlayStation store are 30%. google play store is 30%. So no: apple’s fees are competitive. Actually the 15% tier is below-market - and larger players can negotiate better rates. Out of all the complaints you can level against apple - non-competitive transaction fees aren’t one of them, 30% is the going rate for that.
- Krasnol 2y agoThe US market, for example, but I wouldn't draw the line at countries. The linie lies where your wallet is. Or at least where some pretend it is. The problem is the fact that it's hard to switch for many people who are not on the technical side of life. They really are locked into an environment. This is why it's so important to broaden this environment. Give people choices outside.
- al_borland 2y agoIt’s hard to go the other way as well. I worked with a guy, who was reasonably technical (it was his job), who switched from Android to iOS. He was calling me in his office every other day to complain about something or to figure out why his Google stuff wasn’t playing nice with the Apple apps. Changing platforms is inherently difficult and requires a lot of education and discovering new solutions to old problems, regardless of the platform. Every platform has lock-in for non-technical users when it comes to this.
- Krasnol 2y agoOf course it's both ways. The difference is what it's about here. On Android, you have a huge variety of alternatives. You don't have them at Apple. It's even worse: they are making it hard for you to chose alternatives. Often it doesn't even make sense, since software and hardware are made just for each other. The lock-in factor is much smaller on Android. PS. I was that guy. Had to switch to Apple at work. It was a pain. Not only for me, which is why they switched back after the person who decided it got fired (for different reasons). We've lost a lot of money that year.
- talldayo 2y ago> I think of Apple kind of like Nintendo, but for computers. Then hopefully you understand why people get more upset over Apple's arbitrary "ecosystem" decisions than they are with Nintendo. I love Nintendo, even for all the mistakes they make. But they sell a toy; a games console that is strictly used for entertainment with no auxiliary purpose. Nobody is suing Nintendo because their PDF won't open on their Switch; Nintendo just doesn't offer that functionality, from anyone. There is no unfair market segmentation because Nintendo doesn't segregate functionality by-developer. > What market is Apple dominating? Have you not been following the DMA? It's software; they refuse to offer any form of competitive software distribution. Because of Apple's first-party advantage, they can explicitly block competitors from ever shipping a viable business, and until recently they even blatantly forbid the distribution of GPL-licensed apps. If Apple wants to play the Nintendo defense, then they can get both barrels that Microsoft dodged. I really have no patience for grown-up developers that want to rely on the benefit of the doubt we give a toy company.
- xtiansimon 2y ago> “Because of Apple's first-party advantage, they can explicitly block competitors from ever shipping a viable business…” What does that mean ‘shipping a viable business’?
- talldayo 2y agoDepends on the business. Let's say you're Dropbox, or a similar third-party subscription backup service. You want to offer a competing service to iCloud for iPhone users, but there are a few hitches in the way: 1) Apple doesn't give you the same APIs they use to integrate iCloud. Your service literally cannot compete with their service on a functional basis. 2) You cannot out-price Apple without a sweetheart deal from Apple themselves. This creates a situation where Apple's consent is required to offer pricing that would be disruptive to any of their services. 3) The de-facto integration, promotion and nagging that iCloud enjoys constitutes product bundling. As we know from their deal with Google, Apple prices their defaults at a ludicrous amount, in order to create a disproportionate first-party advantage relative to competitors. User control is put up for auction under the guise of security and simplicity, when it's really being divided among sinister benefactors. With these combined, it is effectively impossible to present a competitive first-party software experience on Apple platforms. It wouldn't matter if your service was genuinely superior to Apple's offerings because, much like Microsoft, Apple enjoys a privileged position where they can block competitors from their internal market if they pose a legitimate threat.