3 ms·
I think the tricky thing is the distinction between: (A) Democratization: Let everyone participate as individuals on a freshly equalized playing field that was
by Terr_ 2y ago
I think the tricky thing is the distinction between:
(A) Democratization: Let everyone participate as individuals on a freshly equalized playing field that was previously so slanted they couldn't even try.
(B) Democratization: Encourage lots of small disorganized weaker players into the market as unwitting prey for existing interests that have already established themselves with regulatory or competitive edges that they retain/maintain indefinitely.
- Terr_ 2y agoP.S.: A closely-related rant over another situation involving market-access and devil-in-the-details: Various attempts to "privatize social security" often with the pitch of "giving individuals more control." In this case I'm not focused on whether individuals can act wisely, but rather that such plans often means replacing an insurance policy with an investment account. Those two kinds of financial instruments have extremely different features, benefits, and risks! So even if believe that's a great idea, be be suspicious of anybody who seems to be trying to hide that aspect of their plan from the public, since it means they're trying to get voters to make an uninformed choice.
- greentxt 2y agoWell, if the privatized version doesn't allow other people to take my money away from me at the point of a gun and give it to other people, using the state's proverbial "monopoly on violence" it doesnt seem like a very fair comparison. Apples and oranges. Maybe that was your implicit point?
- Terr_ 2y ago> Well, if the privatized version doesn't [risk loss because of] the point of a gun Except it does. A soldier with a gun in your face can take your insurance payout just as easily as they can take your bank balance. With respect to a kleptocracy, neither option protects you. > take my money away from me Ah, this is the place where you've confused an apple for an orange: The premiums collected for "destitute in a ditch" insurance is not "your money", because that's not how insurance works. Similarly if you buy "house burns down" insurance and your house is fine until the day you sell it, then you get zero dollars back from the insurance company and nobody blinks an eye. Your payout is potential, conditional, and generally non-transferable, and that's normal, because an insurance policy is not an investment account. There was never a discrete "your money" pile sitting around in the insurance-company vault waiting for you to reclaim it. (Well, aside from in the minds of criminals plotting insurance fraud.)
- greentxt 2y agoPerhaps it is actually myself that's confused. I was not thinking in terms of "destitute in a ditch" money but rather the money that's currently being provided the the vast majority of American seniors. Sounds like you're talking SSI (dissbility) not social security (retirement). My bad.
- roenxi 2y agoThere isn't really a distinction between the two; they are the same sentence with different frames. However, if you don't let smaller players into the market then they'll be fleeced using some other mechanism (for example, taxed and then handouts given to the wealthy). If access to markets is expensive then small players won't be able to save at all since any method that lets people invest exposes them to risk, and once risk is involved larger players will outmanouver smaller ones. Damned if you do, damned if you don't but giving people easy access gives people the best shot at achieving prosperity.