2 ms·
The media's coverage of this as a "conservative win" is extremely misleading. This case is simply about whether agencies or judges should interpret what federal
by rayiner 2y ago
The media's coverage of this as a "conservative win" is extremely misleading. This case is simply about whether agencies or judges should interpret what federal regulatory statutes mean. Chevron itself was written by five conservatives (and one democrat--with three other justices not participating) and overruled a decision authored by then D.C. Circuit Judge Ruth Bader Ginsberg. She had sided with an environmental advocacy organization in finding that the EPA's interpretation of a Clean Air Act amendment was incorrect.
Chevron has always been a double-edged sword for both conservatives and progressives. In many cases, public interest advocacy organizations would much rather have judges deciding what laws mean than bureaucrats, because agencies tend to be staffed with industry people who are--while well meaning and operating in good faith--often veterans of industry and very sympathetic to it.
- shawndrost 2y agoWhat an incredible coincidence that everyone -- the media, the judges who voted 6-3, and HN commenters like yourself -- sees this case along ideological lines!
- rayiner 2y agoEvery case is obviously going to be viewed through the legal of legal ideology. That’s different from making it seem like it favors one particular political ideology. Liberals hated Chevron because agencies were generally less willing to push the law in their favor than judges. Under this ruling, they can go and sue in the ninth circuit and have liberal judges Decide what the clean air act means.