3 ms·
> Dumb decision Well, what's the alternative? Do you believe all local laws such as "FooBar park closes at dusk" are federally unconstitutional, and that actua
by Terr_ 2y ago
> Dumb decision
Well, what's the alternative? Do you believe all local laws such as "FooBar park closes at dusk" are federally unconstitutional, and that actually enforcing any of them is "cruel and unusual punishment" against people who desire to camp there overnight?
Remember: It's perfectly possible to say that certain situations are unlawful/unjust/immoral for other reasons, it's not like "I think it violates the 8th Amendment" is the only option.
However, "it violates the 8th Amendment" is was what got argued in the court, and I think the conclusion is reasonable: The entire category of local laws (which are not new) are generally and by default not-against-the-8th.
- Terr_ 2y agoP.S.: To reiterate, exactly what do you think the "not dumb" result should have been? What sentence of words could the Supreme Court have responded with that would satisfy you while (A) not wildly overstepping their own powers and (B) not upending centuries of other law considered good and (C) not creating massive new problems and loopholes? Here's a quick "unit test" to apply: Could I steal and eat all the food I want with total impunity, provided I am careful to ensure my wallet is always empty so that paying for it in that moment is never an option?
- jjk166 2y agoI believe "cruel and unusual" is obviously context dependent and intended to prohibit the government from applying punishments that are technically permissible under the law but which society considers completely unreasonable under the circumstances. The argument that fining a homeless person is not cruel because fining a rich person is not cruel and thus fines can not be cruel is absurd.
- relaxing 2y agoYeah man. Punishing someone for being is poor and living outside of society by making them poorer and pushing them further outside society is cruel and unusual. The majority’s justification that it is fair because it applies to those whom it will never apply to is particularly craven.
- HDThoreaun 2y agoThe US has a long history of punishing people for being poor. Certainly nothing unusual about that.
- vharuck 2y agoIn this case, an alternative was the city providing a homeless shelter. The only shelter in town required those staying there to participate in religious activities. So the homeless people had to choose between (1) arrest (2) forced religious participation, or (3) leaving town.
- Terr_ 2y ago> In this case, an alternative was the city providing a homeless shelter. No, in this [court] case an entirely different question was brought before the judges. "City policy shoulda been this other thing instead" was never on the menu of potential answers. The Supreme Court is--fortunately, for now--not some sort of King Solomon dictator that can jump the rails from "whose baby is this" to "all babies must be fingerprinted by midwives."