5 ms·
EVs still have major quality problems, and it's mostly about the software
- palata 2y agoCould be summarized as "Software has major quality problems, and EVs need a lot of it".
- audunw 2y agoWhy do EVs need a lot of it? Our Kia Soul EV 2015 model doesn’t have any more software than its gasoline counterpart, maybe a couple extra menus related to showing EV info, that’s all. I doubt that the software for the inverter is any more complex than the ECU controlling an ICE. Our Ioniq 5 has a lot of software. Some of it enables huge benefits with EVs: like I can pre-heat or cool the car from the app. Love it. But it’s not necessary. While I love the Ioniq 5 I think the older Kia Soul EV strikes a nearly perfect balance between features and simplicity, and I think the market needs more EVs like that.
- Grimeton 2y agoMaybe using Javascript in such an environment is not the best of ideas.
- legitster 2y agoIt's worth pointing out this is according to JD Power - that industry funded award program that gets featured in car commercials all of the time. It's also an initial quality study - ie the number of problems reported in the first 100 days. It doesn't speak to the overall longevity or reliability of the car's design, just the presence of manufacturing defects.
- theandrewbailey 2y agoIs there a modern but dumb EV? I refuse to believe that just because these cars move around because of batteries means that they need to be connected to the internet. There were EVs over 100 years ago. I wonder how many software updates they had.
- audunw 2y agoHyundai Kona electric, Kia Soul EV second gen, or Kia Niro EV is fairly modern, but not too “smart”. There’s no reason EVs need to be connected to the internet. While the newer lines of Hyundai and Kia EVs can connect to the internet, that’s only for remote control and updates for the infotainment system. The engine control software is still updated off-line if needed. Unfortunately I’m not aware of any EVs made from the ground up as an EV that is also super simple. Not any that are mass produced in large quantities, in a popular form factor, and easily available in a western market at least. I think the problem now is such an EV - if it was really optimised for low cost - would be too popular. There isn’t enough battery factories to satisfy the potential demand. So car companies would rather use the battery production capacity they have access to for selling expensive high margin vehicles. As long as that market isn’t fully saturated that’s how they get the most money out of the available capacity. And honestly I think it’s a good thing for this part of the EV transition. It’s good that car companies can actually make some money on EVs for a while as it incentivises continued investments in EV R&D and more battery factories. We just gotta hope that we get a smooth transition into the design and production of more affordable models.
- SkyPuncher 2y agoNo, legacy auto manufacturers have a major problem worrying usable software. My Ford hybrid is a buggy bundle of crap, but thankfully it does one thing extremely well - wireless CarPlay. Flip side, our Hyundai is amazing and I’m confident the EV version of their car would work just as well.
- audunw 2y agoCan tell you from personal experience.. I’ve had zero issues with Hyundai 5 software. Well, it’s a bit slow sometimes. But no serious issues. And we bought it within a year of being launched. Our Kia Soul EV 2015 has been nearly perfect, except one small issue in the first year where it could drain the 12V battery. But it was fixed fairly quickly. They’re not up to the level of Tesla when it comes to making improvements to the software. There are several things they could do that would make huge improvements to the UX. But the over-the-air updates have just added some minor features that I really don’t care about.