4 ms·
Perplexity's grand theft AI
- visarga 2y agoCopyright should die. It was already standing on just one foot since internet made mass copying trivial. File sharing has been going on for decades. Now they want to extend copyright to restrict AI which doesn't even replicate the source text, and instead aims to answer a user question by combining information across multiple sources. We have seen other models that don't rely on protection flourish - Wikipedia, open source, scientific publications, open weights models, and even fashion. They all are permissive, and thriving.
- ricopags 2y agoApply that idea to the journalism perplexity stole, which obviously has value. Forbes worked for months to create a story only to watch an IP launderer garner more financial reward.
- visarga 2y agoI would agree if newspapers stopped reporting on social media posts, for which they don't ask permission or pay royalties. Not to mention that most articles are just rewording press agency news releases and other publications. And isn't Google stealing the content from the whole internet and making a huge profit from it? Why the double standard. Perplexity has links to sources too.
- ricopags 2y agoIf you pay attention to what I wrote vs what you wanted to read, you'd see the false equivalence is yours. Pay-gating copyrighted content is different indeed from public-posted social media content. In the instance of the Forbes theft, Perplexity offered links to other copycats, but never the original [costly] reporting.
- pqdbr 2y agoAnd how do you think all the content creators (either mainstream or independent) are going to keep churning quality content if they get one order of magnitude less traffic than before, while the AI "answer engines" sell premium subscriptions to provide answers based on scraped content bypassing paywalls?
- visarga 2y agoAI engines are the future of search and task solving. They will absorb a lot of information from their users, much more than old search engines, such as problem solving strategies, what works and what doesn't. Just consider the fact that chatGPT as 180M users and probably solves 1B tasks per month. It collects contextual data, guidance and feedback on a massive scale, going into the next model with some PII and copyright mitigations. We will go to LLMs for advice because they will have the best data, refreshed by hundreds of millions of users. LLMs will naturally collect the most up to date feedback from the world, they don't even need to do anything, just wait for users to copy paste the relevant data and provide iterative guidance.
- GaggiX 2y agoI believe that sooner or later we will see something similar to Perplexity that runs directly in your browser, opens the pages for you, and answers your question. Unless it has already been done.
- lovethevoid 2y agoArc Search does that already. Can’t recall which provider(s) they rely on.
- GaggiX 2y agoI should have specified that by "runs directly in your browser" I meant running it locally on the machine. EDIT: You still have to rely on a server to index the web pages of interest.
- VeejayRampay 2y agothe content mentioned in the article was behind a paywall though, how are you going to circumvent that legally?
- visarga 2y agoAnd people will see less and less of the original material, popups, cookie warnings, floating videos and offers to join a mailing list. It's so sad (not)
- mattigames 2y agoExcept that they will see a lot less revenue and a lot less engagement and the creators will lose incentives to keep creating, to be clear I also wholeheartedly hate a lot of those practices but it's a fact that many of them increase engagement.
- CaptainFever 2y agoRight, I just realised this debate is basically the same debate towards ad-blocking and paywall jumping (e.g. via archive.is). Of course opinions vary on HN but generally it feels like a "ad-blocking is cool, paywall hopping is cool, but the server also has the right to not give us the information". Given this, this is pretty sensational reporting by The Verge -- calling it theft, comparing it to crypto, breaking the "foundations of the internet" (... the Internet is about sharing) etc. This is a non-story, we already have these tools, this just adds an AI summary layer on top.
- caboteria 2y ago> So that’s Perplexity’s real innovation here: shattering the foundations of trust that built the internet. The question is if any of its users or investors care. Ron Howard voiceover: They do not.
- Ukv 2y ago> At this point, Wired jumped in, confirming a finding from Robb Knight: Perplexity’s scraping of Forbes’ work wasn’t an exception. In fact, Perplexity has been ignoring the robots.txt code that explicitly asks web crawlers not to scrape the page There's a distinction that is being missed between: * Web crawlers automatically accessing pages, such as recursively following links to index them for search engines * A tool accessing a URL in direct response to a user request robots.txt is only intended for the former. For instance, archive.is state: > [Why does archive.is not obey robots.txt?] Because it is not a free-walking crawler, it saves only one page acting as a direct agent of the human user. Such services don't obey robots.txt (e.g. Google Feedfetcher, screenshot- or pdf-making services, isup.me, …) Perplexity do (as far as I've been able to find) respect robots.txt for their scraping. What the investigations confirmed it was ignored for was users entering a URL to summarise. There is still a conversation to be had. I think users should be able to browse the web with whatever tool they want to - whether that's a standard browser, a minimal reader mode that doesn't show ads, or a statistical summarisation tool - but it does pose a problem for sites that rely on standard browsers letting them show users advertisements, get them to sign up to mailing lists, collect data, etc. if users decide to choose tools that don't allow that.
- tomp 2y agoExactly. AI that answers questions using online sources isn't a web crawler, but a web researchers.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- maypop 2y agoThere’s a bit of a middle ground where the user may say something like “tech articles from new site” which would require the agent to move around reading and aggregating information to return to the user. Is this the former or the latter?
- zamadatix 2y ago
- orasis 2y agoIsn’t it ironic that journalists themselves aggregate content in a way that discourages the reader from clicking through to the primary source? This type of summarization and aggregation seems to be exactly what consumers want.
- goodoldneon 2y agoClicking through to what, in person interviews with sources? Your comparison makes no sense
- mminer237 2y agoMy impression is that most news now is just reported by a single source or a wire service, and 90+% of sites just write their own article based on that first news site's article.
- viraptor 2y agoBad journalists do. The good ones quote/link their sources. You can do the general idea of journalism in many ways. (Tabloid writers are journalists too... in theory)
- thunkshift1 2y agoAnd where does one find this ‘good’ journalism? It seems to be the exception rather than the norm as majority of the articles are summarizations, opinions, rip offs from reddit, clickbaits that quote from ‘experts’ or ‘sources’ who or not named
- viraptor 2y agoThe most recent on my mind: Polymatter videos. For example the latest one https://youtu.be/H5EF8v0iGBs https://youtu.be/H5EF8v0iGBs and the sources https://docs.google.com/document/u/0/d/1ph76k8iQVG5U1K2qpIupIQ-VqAj37tuUr7jWH2alasA/mobilebasic https://docs.google.com/document/u/0/d/1ph76k8iQVG5U1K2qpIup...
- 2y ago
- sva_ 2y agoI think what Perplexity is trying to build is cool, but seems like they do quite a bit of dodgy shit. On his recent appearance on the Lex Fridman episode, Perplexity CEO Srinivas admitted that they'd abuse Twitter's academic grant program and autogenerated thousands of grant applications with GPT. If he so laughingly reminisces about doing that, I wonder what kind of other dodgy shit they do behind closed doors.
- danlindley 2y agoRelated: Perplexity AI is lying about their user agent https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40690898 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40690898
- dang 2y agoThanks! Macroexpanded: Perplexity AI is lying about their user agent - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40690898 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40690898 - June 2024 (531 comments)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tomp 2y agoLying article lies. > Though Forbes has a metered paywall on some of its work, the premium work — like that investigation — is behind a hard paywall No it's not, see for yourself! I can read it just fine... https://www.forbes.com/sites/sarahemerson/2024/06/06/eric-schmidt-is-secretly-testing-ai-military-drones-in-a-wealthy-silicon-valley-suburb/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/sarahemerson/2024/06/06/eric-sc...
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoRelated: Perplexity is a bullshit machine https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40728732 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40728732
- Havoc 2y agoBit confused about why perplexity in particular? “Leveraging” other people’s content is basically par for the course. Whether it’s training or google news or Google books or stability A.I. images it’s all doing the same just to different degrees
- fxj 2y agoSo when I pay an intern to do a google search and make a short report of the facts that he was finding and giving it back to me, this is not a problem, but when I ask an AI to do the same it suddenly is problem. Well I dont get it. just my 2 ct
- JonChesterfield 2y agoThe complaint here is the internet used to be "ad supported", and while showing ads to your intern isn't great, it's better than showing them to a web crawler