9 ms·
The Bleak Genius of Michel Foucault
- janice1999 2y ago> In practical terms, Foucault’s and his followers’ assault against sexual normalization has helped bring about institutions that disavow normativity at every turn. I assume this is an oblique defense of Foucault's lifelong and vocal campaign to remove the age of consent so adults could have sex with children. Foucault was also recently accused of having purchased boys for sex by his friend Guy Sorman. https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2021/4/16/reckoning-with-foucaults-sexual-abuse-of-boys-in-tunisia https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2021/4/16/reckoning-with-...
- dralley 2y agoAside from this, the pretension is literally dripping from that sentence, my god. It's difficult to value the "genius" of people (and frankly entire fields) who seem to apply most of their cleverness towards being inscrutable for no good reason.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- prewett 2y agoI think the purpose of the inscrutability serves is to "idea launder" obvious falsehoods into something believable, much like the convoluted path one takes to convert stolen money into believably-legal money.
- blacksmith_tb 2y agoWell to be fair there are two arguments, one is that you can't use normal commonplace phrasing to describe something that's at odds with the 'normal'; the other is that in a publish-or-perish academic world each new generation of thinkers invents a new jargon to differentiate themselves from their predecessors (and keep their jobs). Not that both couldn't be simultaneously true, but I think it's a little too cheeky to say they're making it up for no reason at all.
- bitwize 2y ago"Idea laundering". You've neatly summarized what I believe Curtis Yarvin to have been doing, both with his political writing and his computational silliness like Urbit.
- hackandthink 2y agoThe article about Foucault's pedophilia is worth reading. I'm not really surprised. When I read the piece on Pierre Riviere decades ago, it creeped me out. https://markkukoivusalo.org/thinkers/foucault/cp/pierre-riviere/ https://markkukoivusalo.org/thinkers/foucault/cp/pierre-rivi...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- lores 2y agoI don't think you copied the right link.
- hackandthink 2y agoI no longer have the book. Unfortunately, I can't find a corresponding quote online that I seem to remember. I mostly remember the feeling there is something wrong with this guy.
- pasabagi 2y agoApparently bullshit, though: https://www.lexpress.fr/idees-et-debats/michel-foucault-et-la-pedophilie-enquete-sur-un-emballement-mediatique_2148517.html https://www.lexpress.fr/idees-et-debats/michel-foucault-et-l... Guy Sorman wasn't Foucault's friend, and later said (about his statement) that he never actually saw anything he described, but just a 'convergence of disturbing clues'. You have to bear in mind that accusing gay people of pedophilia is pretty standard fare for homophobes up and to this day.
- complaintdept 2y agoIIRC Focault still signed a petition to legalize sex with children. Not sure why, but it wasn't an entirely unpopular opinion among (often) leftist intellectuals in Europe at the time.
- pasabagi 2y agoI mean, it seems a bit unclear what his political positions actually were, but it does seem they were just opinions. As philosophers go, that's pretty small beer: Thales used to roast people alive in a brass container, Marcus Aurelius was responsible for numerous genocides, and Heidegger was a card-carrying Nazi.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 2y ago>Thales used to roast people alive in a brass container Source?
- teractiveodular 2y agoThat would be Phalaris of brazen bull fame, not Thales. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phalaris https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phalaris
- MrBuddyCasino 2y agoFoucault, Jean-Paul Sartre, Simone de Beauvoir and Jacques Derrida signed a petition to decriminalise pedophilia [0]. The age of consent at that time in France was 15. "In a sense, all the rest of my life I've been trying to do intellectual things that would attract beautiful boys." [0] https://x.com/AuronMacintyre/status/1806019580315463689 https://x.com/AuronMacintyre/status/1806019580315463689
- slibhb 2y agoThe author is a social conservative. He's by no means defending Foucault's "assault against sexual normalization". My sense is that, by "recognizing Foucault's bleak genius," the subtext is "we need God because otherwise there's nothing but depravity".
- slowhadoken 2y agoNoam Chomsky called Foucault a morally bankrupt phony. I think Chomsky was being kind.
- idontknowtech 2y agoFoucault is the primary intellectual force behind the contemporary social science trend of seeing everything through a power relationships lens. His influence cannot be overstated, at least in the American academy. It's bizarre.
- slowhadoken 2y agoI’ve read Foucault. I’m familiar with western and continental philosophy. I studied psychology, sociology, and political science too. Foucault‘s influence, as well as French existentialism and post-structuralism in general, are to blame for the current state of social science. Boiling everything down to a cultural power struggle is a pyramid scheme, a cult that infiltrated American academia. It’s certainly not a moral philosophy and Foucault’s life reflects that.
- Karrot_Kream 2y agoWith the problems of modernism apparent in the philosophical academy, continental and especially leftist philosophy had a huge void of ideas. Post-structuralism took root precisely because it shrugged the idea of having An Answer but also explained many of the problems with modernism and salvaged the ideas of the Left as best as it could without having to exhume Hegel viz Marx. Rational critiques of post-structuralism remain as lurid as ever but I still see a huge void in modern western philosophy that post-structuralism dances in the ashes of. If anyone is aware of other non-rationalist western philosophies, I'd be curious as I'm only aware of the Lacanian schools and then more standard post-structuralist stuff like Foucault and Deleuze. I'd also be careful of trying to read a philosopher's life inside their ideas. Deleuze led a very bog-standard life for a white man in the postwar era in Europe despite advocating for fairly radical philosophies. It's the ideas that take root and shape the academy and then society. If you wish to push back on post-structuralism, criticize the idea, not the people. Foucault himself may have been depraved, but others certainly weren't.
- stefantalpalaru 2y ago[dead]
- viccis 2y agoFoucault was a genius with many of his critiques of power. The panopticon, biopower, his genealogical historical narrative techniques, etc. His works are also often a surprise to people I know who read them for the first time because they expect chattering gibberish like Derrida, Lyotard, etc., but instead meet fairly sober minded critiques grounded in historical evidence (that can and has been argued against and critiqued itself, but that's par for academic discourse) Unfortunately, he was terminally French, leading to some very bad stances that were sadly popular around that time (that petition...), and was slandered by a fraud and reactionary (Sorman) who admitted recently to making it up. This has allowed the dimwitted and incurious to discount his trenchant analyses out of hand rather than engage critically (for example, look how much of the conversation in here concerns salacious rumors rather than biopolitics or the disciplinary society ). Him being openly gay and one of the first major AIDS casualties also fuels this discourse, as when I search for "Sartre" here, I see next to no discussion of his hobby of (heterosexually) raping young girls with the aid of Simone de Beauvoir. I temper my expectations because this is a tech/stem centric place, but the general lack of philosophical literacy is always disappointing to me in such crowds!
- lores 2y agoEr, do you have any sources for Sartre and de Beauvoir raping young girls? I can't seem to find one.
- ddulaney 2y agoThe allegations are originally from Bianca Lamblin. A quick-and-dirty summary is on Sartre's Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean-Paul_Sartre#Allegations_of_sexual_abuse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean-Paul_Sartre#Allegations_o..., and you can follow the citations back to Lamblin's original allegations and later reporting on it.
- lores 2y agoThanks!
- 2y ago
- paulpauper 2y agoSimilar to Chomsky, Derrida, Rorty and other contemporary intellectual 'greats' of the post-war era , Foucault owes some of his inflated legacy to existing during a pre-internet, pre-Twitter era, when the marketplace for intellectualism was less saturated and academic press and the mainstream media provided a funnel for the masses and other academics to be fed these ideas or a diluted version of them. Thanks to twitter, podcasts, e-zines, and blogs, anyone with a degree can do a good enough job imitating someone like him and also get a lot of acclaim and status. Anyone with a doctorate or a master's degree can write a book and go on podcasts to promote it, or write a Substack blog. The funnel and gatekeeper institutions like the École normale supérieurem, Eton, or Oxford and the exclusivity and prestige they signaled during the 60s and 70s, is long gone or also diluted. In some ways this also parallels the post-Cold-War decline of Continental Europe as an economic and cultural superpower, as most of those intellectuals originated from there.
- financltravsty 2y agoWhat is next?
- hackandthink 2y agoMy unscientific research contradicts this thesis. Foucault became a classic who approaches Aristotle and Plato. Anecdotally, the post-structuralists were still a curiosity in the 80s. https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=Chomsky%2CDeleuze%2CFoucault%2CPlato%2CAdorno%2CPopper%2CMilton+Friedman%2CSowell%2CBuckley%2CAyn+Rand&year_start=1960&year_end=2019&case_insensitive=on&corpus=en-2019&smoothing=3 https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=Chomsky%2CDele...
- light_triad 2y agoIf you're looking for an intellectual critique of Foucault, one of the best is Jean Baudrillard's book Forget Foucault from 1977. Baudrillard both admired the depth of Foucault's historically informed philosophical analysis but questioned its objectivity especially given Foucault had little to say about how power evolved with mass media & technology - and was in a sense always fighting the last war: > "If Foucault spoke so well of power to us — and let us not forget it, in real objective terms which cover manifold diffractions but nonetheless do not question the objective point of view one has about them, and of power which is pulverized but whose reality principle is nonetheless not questioned — only because power is dead?" > "We are no doubt witnessing, with sexual liberation, pornography, etc., the agony of sexual reason. And Foucault will only have given us the key to it when it no longer means anything" https://medium.com/@noahjchristiansen/jean-baudrillards-call-to-forget-foucault-aefbbfbadceb https://medium.com/@noahjchristiansen/jean-baudrillards-call... https://teddykw2.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/jean-baudrillard-forget-foucault.pdf https://teddykw2.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/je...