5 ms·
Why are doctors so easy to manipulate? They learn about addiction in medical school. Why would they believe a pharmaceutical company saying "...oh but this opio
by SoftTalker 2y ago
Why are doctors so easy to manipulate? They learn about addiction in medical school. Why would they believe a pharmaceutical company saying "...oh but this opioid is not addictive..."
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- logicchains 2y ago>Why would they believe a pharmaceutical company saying "...oh but this opioid is not addictive..." Because the pharma company offered them direct or indirect benefits for doing so. Doctors are just as human and just as susceptible to financial incentive as anybody else, that's why for decades there were doctors advertising the health benefits of smoking.
- LordKeren 2y agoIt’s easy to overlook that OxyContin was very effective. Even a doctor acting in good faith was likely to prescribe the drug— because it worked well. It really did help people struggling with pain management. The downside, of course, was that Purdue pharma was knowingly misleading doctors on the addictiveness of the drug. Also the amount of doctors that were willing to turn a blind eye to the clear signs of addiction is very worrying.
- radlad 2y ago> Also the amount of doctors that were willing to turn a blind eye to the clear signs of addiction is very worrying. No disagreement, but I think it's worth considering how stigmatized addiction is in our society. I expect many patients would hide any signs of addiction from their doctors - especially since it might result in losing their supply of OxyContin, or worse, their career.
- LordKeren 2y agoYes, whole heartedly agree. The social impact of addiction and the ostracism of those suffering with addiction has undoubtedly only made this situation worse. I was more leaning towards doctors/pharmacies that were operating as pill mills - I.e. the handful of regions in the Appalachias where there were more scripts for Oxy than there were people in the county
- bobthepanda 2y agoAlso Purdue themselves were pushing pain management as an outcome to manage, to sell more Oxy. Totally pain-free medical care is a bit misguided.
- alan-hn 2y agoBecause physicians don't get much if any training in evaluating evidence and research, they generally believe what they're told by scientists. Which is a shame, they should be taught critical evaluation of literature They also don't have time because of the artificial limits of physicians graduating every year, combined with more bureaucracy being pushed on them day by day
- tracker1 2y ago"trust the science" edit: it's meant in sarcasm, mostly.
- alan-hn 2y agoWe can trust the process of science but we need to be mindful of how to critically examine a body of literature. When I see most lay people examine literature all they do is cherry pick what they like and discard the rest and ignore any analysis or methodological concerns
- tracker1 2y agoThis generally seems to be true. It doesn't help that poor reporting methods exacerbate the issue.
- alan-hn 2y agoOh absolutely, science journalism is absolutely terrible for the most part. That's why I always try to find the original paper they're reporting on to see what's actually going on Most journalists don't understand research either and I've even seen some PhD science writers get things wrong too but usually less often. Science journalism is filled with incredible sweeping claims and jumps in logic that boggle the mind and are nothing like what's in the research being reported on, it truly makes me disappointed
- tracker1 2y ago
- bloopernova 2y agoBecause doctors believe studies and health system policies pushed aggressive treatment of pain. And our unequal society forces a lot of people to damage their bodies in the pursuit of happiness (i.e. earning money). That damage becomes chronic pain. And unfortunately, painkillers often have a euphoric effect. So people might use that effect to escape the grinding reality that they are trapped within. Consider how popular cannabis is, especially among older adults in states where recreational use is legal.
- iwontberude 2y agoWhat a positively wonderful way to look at life.
- Y_Y 2y agoI can't make sense of this either as sarcastic or earnest. I though GP was a fairly neutral (and imho accurate) appraisal.
- iwontberude 2y agoI think it’s accurate but it’s bleak imho
- acomjean 2y agoIt seems that in the US there has been a trend to "de-regulate" or let businesses regulate themselves. It works for a while, but eventually it seems to go south. I think "regulatory capture" is the term. I think of Boeing being allowed to inspect there own planes.. I think drug manufactures submit there own studies, as the FDA doesn't have a budget to test all the things themselves. The opiod manufactures are organized too. They have trade groups and conferences.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- marcuskane2 2y agoDe-regulation and regulatory capture are almost opposite things. De-regulation is a solution to the problem of regulatory capture. Regulatory capture is a central problem in America today. The big powerful entities- major corporations, large unions, special interest groups, etc have the time, resources and incentives to lobby for laws (regulations) to be written in their favor. The result is the American public is very heavily regulated, but in ways that are beneficial primarily to the powerful incumbents. This spans everything from copyright law favoring big hollywood studios to USDA regulations favoring the handful of major meat producer corporations to medicine, manufacturing, retail, real estate, etc. Regulatory capture is also why the divide between leftists saying more regulation and rightists saying less regulation are both often missing the real problem. The US already has millions of lines of text for regulation, the problem is that so much of the regulation is bad and written to favor whoever donated or could sway votes to whichever representative crafted the language.
- jimbob45 2y agoArguably, you have it backwards. Self-regulation doesn't work for a while, and then it works ultra well. Boeing got away with poor self-regulation for decades but now their business almost certainly will implode within decades and their market position will be taken over by those who were willing and able to self-regulate. They were rightfully punished and the US government was (theoretically) able to spend more resources regulating elsewhere. That said, the lag time between the beginning of failing to self-regulate and the beginning of consequences showing up are likely too far apart to make it a sound doctrine for the US government.
- HWR_14 2y agoWhat makes you sure doctors are "so easy to manipulate"? Is the general public more immune? Are there many professions that are more immune?
- bumby 2y agoI read the OP as "professionals should be less easily manipulated than the general public because of their background knowledge on the subject". Consider whether most would think a mechanic is more or less easily manipulated into unnecessary vehicle repairs.
- HWR_14 2y ago> whether most would think a mechanic is more or less easily manipulated into unnecessary vehicle repairs. That's different. This is closer to a mechanic using a part from Company X in the repairs of their customer's car, because a rep told them it was more durable.
- bumby 2y agoYou're right, that's a better example. But wouldn't you expect the mechanic to have a more discerning eye in that case as well? The more contextual knowledge you have, the better you should be able to tell legitimate claims from BS.
- HWR_14 2y agoTo catch some BS, sure. I wouldn't expect them to fall for obvious lies. I doubt a mechanic would be significantly educated metallurgy or production techniques to spot BS in part lifespans. Or to spot pseudoscience in air filters. I would expect them to notice their repeat customers not getting the benefits. But keep in mind that doctors saw their patients appearing pain free and high functioning.
- bumby 2y agoYou may be right and I may be guilty of hindsight bias, but I would probably put this in the realm of BS. It’s not like opioids were unknown to cause addiction, and when physicians witness the company continuing to up the dosage and wordsmith terms like “breakthrough pain” I would expect a cognizant doctor to be throwing red flags. To overextend the mechanic metaphor, it would be like making a part out of aluminum and claiming it has infinite fatigue life. We know aluminum doesn’t so the threshold of evidence needs to be very, very high or the mechanic should remain skeptical. If the part continues to fail, but the manufacturer keeps making new, novel excuses the mechanic should be throwing the BS flag about their infinite fatigue life claims.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Auracle 2y agoA friend of mine recently died from cancer. I had looked up some particular things about it while he was still alive, and apparently some cookies got crossed and I was marked as an oncologist. I've had some ads on Facebook or Instagram telling me, the "oncologist," about particular cancer drugs. Of course, everyone in the US has probably seen regular ads for various cancer drugs. Doctors pretty much need to be intelligent and hard working to get through med school and residency. After that, they might not necessarily keep up with things. You'd think oncologists would know the best treatments for each patient, but if that were true those ads would be worthless - and I doubt those companies like to throw money away.