3 ms·
In theory, yes. In practice judges in Civil Law systems also tend to let themselves be guided by precedent. (Conversely, in Common Law precedent crumbles befo
by eru 2y ago
In theory, yes. In practice judges in Civil Law systems also tend to let themselves be guided by precedent.
(Conversely, in Common Law precedent crumbles before a judge sufficiently motivated to find reasons why the case before her differs enough to warrant a new judgement. Often there are even multiple precedents to choose from, depending on which features of the case you want to emphasise.
Identifying a precedent is like find a metaphor or analogy.)