4 ms·
> Also, just as Judges can change their interpretation of the law for the better, they can also do the reverse. It would be better for example, if abortion righ
by eru 2y ago
> Also, just as Judges can change their interpretation of the law for the better, they can also do the reverse. It would be better for example, if abortion rights was made more explicit or made outright a right guaranteed by the constitution.
Yes, I agree about the possibility of reversal!
---
At the risk of going on a tangent:
There's some argument to be made that eg foreign policy is best handled at the federal level, but other things like rules on acceptable levels of noise or the schedule for garbage collection should be handled my more local authorities. It's easy to see that eg Florida has very different concerns about garbage rotting away in the hot weather compared to Alaska perhaps worrying about attracting polar bears?
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subsidiarity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subsidiarity
> Subsidiarity is a principle of social organization that holds that social and political issues should be dealt with at the most immediate or local level that is consistent with their resolution. The Oxford English Dictionary defines subsidiarity as "the principle that a central authority should have a subsidiary function, performing only those tasks which cannot be performed at a more local level".[1] The concept is applicable in the fields of government, political science, neuropsychology, cybernetics, management and in military command (mission command). The OED adds that the term "subsidiarity" in English follows the early German usage of "Subsidiarität".[2] More distantly, it is derived from the Latin verb subsidio (to aid or help), and the related noun subsidium (aid or assistance).
If you care about local self rule and subsidiarity at all, rules on abortion are something that should probably be handled by perhaps the counties or at most the states.
Compare also how things like education, traffic rules and manslaughter are handled by the states.
Curiously enough, Germany handles rules on abortion with an explicit law at the federal level, most other healthcare regulations being done at the state level. I wonder what the history there is. Perhaps it wasn't historically seen as particularly related to healthcare?
In any case, I agree that an explicit rule on abortion on any level is probably better than just relying on judges.
Laws can't and shouldn't handle every case explicitly, and it's good to have judges. But if you have an issues that's so politically prominent, it makes sense to give it an explicit rule.
- lokar 2y agoWell, the confederacy believed in subsidiarity.
- eru 2y agoWell, and Hitler was a vegetarian. What's your point? Btw, do we have any sources / evidence for whether the confederacy only believed that specific point for the specific question of whether the states or the union should decide about slavery? Or did they also have differences in opinion from the northerners on eg the role of municipalities and counties in educational policy or monetary questions etc?
- lokar 2y agoThe point is we generally agree that some human rights are too important to leave to local jurisdiction. They are universal, and everyone has an interest is seeing them upheld.
- eru 2y agoYet, manslaughter and murder are handled by the states in the US, and that seems to work out just fine. I can hardly think of a human right more important and fundamental and universal than the right not be murdered.
- shmeeed 2y ago>Curiously enough, Germany handles rules on abortion with an explicit law at the federal level, most other healthcare regulations being done at the state level. I wonder what the history there is. Perhaps it wasn't historically seen as particularly related to healthcare? Going on a tangent here, but one reason is that the law predates both the federal states (in their current form) and healthcare regulations. The relevant paragraph 218 StGB dates back to the creation of imperial law in the German Empire of 1871 and was later carried over by the successor states. Compulsory health insurance as a cornerstone of the federal healthcare system was mandated by Bismarck some 12 years later. (140 years ago, and some countries still dont have that, smh) But you're also right in that it wasn't made in the context of healthcare, but is actually a (priviledged) case of homicide law - which is obviously federal. It's got a quite interesting history really. I don't know how well this translates, but if you're curious, here's some in-depth info: https://www.bpb.de/shop/zeitschriften/apuz/290795/kurze-geschichte-des-paragrafen-218-strafgesetzbuch/ https://www.bpb.de/shop/zeitschriften/apuz/290795/kurze-gesc...
- eru 2y ago> But you're also right in that it wasn't made in the context of healthcare, but is actually a (priviledged) case of homicide law - which is obviously federal. That's only 'obviously federal' in Germany. In eg the US manslaughter and murder are handled by the states.
- shmeeed 2y agoOops, of course you're right, I didn't think of that.
- rayiner 2y agoIt’s funny you mention German law, because technically the law in Germany is that abortion violates the right to life guaranteed in the Basic Law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Constitutional_Court_abortion_decision,_1975 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Constitutional_Court_ab... It is in fact technically still illegal, with some formal exceptions to punishment: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abortion_in_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abortion_in_Germany