5 ms·
See https://archive.is/20240626025842/https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-06-25/brazil-supreme-court-decriminalizes-marijuana-for-personal-use https://
by eru 2y ago
See https://archive.is/20240626025842/https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-06-25/brazil-supreme-court-decriminalizes-marijuana-for-personal-use https://archive.is/20240626025842/https://www.bloomberg.com/... for the whole text.
When I only read the headline at first, I thought: the object level decision sounds good, but I'm worried this went via the judges, not lawmakers.
Funny enough, when I open the article, I see that Brazil's President of Senate had exactly the same complaint.
Something curious from the article:
> Brazilian drug law states that it is a crime to buy, keep, transport or bring drugs for personal use, in this case with a light penalty. Each judge can decide what quantity or amount of marijuana is consistent with personal use or drug trafficking. According to top judges that vote in favor of the decriminalization, this perception reinforces bias, especially against poor and Black people.
I would like to see the original quote from the judge here. I doubt the original talked about 'Black people' the same way that (translated) phrase would be understood by an American audience.
EDIT: https://www.dw.com/en/brazils-supreme-court-decriminalizes-marijuana-possession/a-69475215 https://www.dw.com/en/brazils-supreme-court-decriminalizes-m... gives the name of the judge.
> Supreme Court judge Alexandre de Moraes said these existing laws disproportionately harm "young people, especially Black people, who are treated as drug traffickers for possessing small amounts."
So let's see if that's enough to dig up the original quote in Brazilian.
Another update: https://www.poder360.com.br/justica/leia-frases-de-moraes-sobre-a-descriminalizacao-do-porte-de-maconha/ https://www.poder360.com.br/justica/leia-frases-de-moraes-so... has was it likely the source of the English phrase:
> Ao defender sua posição, o magistrado escreveu, por exemplo, que “os jovens, em especial os negros (pretos e pardos), analfabetos, são considerados traficantes com quantidades bem menores de drogas (maconha ou cocaína) do que os maiores de 30 anos, brancos e portadores de curso superior”.
The important bit here being 'negros (pretos e pardos)'. A literal translation for 'negros' would indeed by 'blacks', but I wonder what the exact connotations in Brazil are.
Wikipedia has https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Afro-Brazilians https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Afro-Brazilians
The whole article is interesting, but here's something relevant to US cultural influence:
> According to Edward Telles,[22] three different systems related to "racial classification" along the White-Black continuum are used in Brazil.[23] The first is the Census System, which distinguishes three categories: branco (White), pardo, and preto.[23] The second is the popular social system that uses many different categories, including the ambiguous term moreno (literally meaning "tanned", "brunette", or "with an olive complexion").[24] The third is the Black movement, which distinguishes only two categories, summing up pardos and pretos ("blacks", lowercase) as negros ("Blacks", with capital initial), and putting all others as "whites".[25] More recently, the term afrodescendente has been adopted for use,[26] but it is restricted to very formal discourse, such as governmental or academic discussions, being viewed by some as a cultural imposition from the "politically correct speech" associated with the United States.
> Sociologist Simon Schwartzman points out that to "substitute negro for preto, suppressing the pardo alternative would mean to impose unto Brazil a vision of the racial issue as a dichotomy, similar to that of the United States, which would not be true."[41]
- HeatrayEnjoyer 2y ago>the object level decision sounds good, but I'm worried this went via the judges, not lawmakers. Some said the same about the US Supreme Court ending criminalization of gay marriage, but no one today has a problem with it other than actual homophobes. Court decisions often limit or strike down laws, but for some reason it's always a problem when doing so increases human rights. We should welcome more rights however they are earned. Many have had to be won through blood and destruction, I am thankful whenever that isn't necessary.
- eru 2y ago> [...], but for some reason it's always a problem when doing so increases human rights. Huh, who says that? I just want, ideally, democratically elected lawmakers to make an actual law explicitly spelling out things. Because what a judge cobbles together, another judge can take away. (Yes, I know there's 'precedent' in some legal systems. But that just means that the next judge needs to come up with some reasons why her new case is sufficiently different. Not that hard.)
- toomuchtodo 2y agoWe, most unfortunately, don’t live in this ideal world. Occasionally, we luck out and reach consistency eventually from a policy perspective, with fits and starts along the way.
- eru 2y agoYes, I know that we can't all have a pony. Though some places' lawmakers still manage to make explicit rules on cases where it matters than some other places. (Btw, I'm not even talking about what rules I agree with or not. Eg Americans really like their state-owned mail service. So in that particular area, democracy is delivering what the people want, whether I like it or not.)
- rayiner 2y agoWhat exactly is this “ideal world,” and how could it possibly be judged as such by any standard other than reflecting whatever the democratic polity wants?