4 ms·
This is not the first time I'm noticing how US is checking every passenger against some database with everything he said online. This makes me a lot less likely
by mtgx 14y ago
This is not the first time I'm noticing how US is checking every passenger against some database with everything he said online. This makes me a lot less likely to ever visit the US, and if awareness about cases like these grows, I'm sure others will think the same way.
- rdtsc 14y agoThis makes me more scared living in the US. I am approaching the level of fear of the government that is close to what I remember having from the older Soviet Union (note: I never living the harsher political times there, mostly during the mid 80s when stuff was thawing out). It is not a fear that legally I can't talk or do things. It is fear again irrationality and against bureaucratic mistakes. You pissed off one police officer or one border patrol agent and now you are on some kind of secret database or black list for life.
- mtgx 14y agoSomeone who has lived in communist countries understands the danger of this trend a lot better than Americans do, it seems. There is Reddit in other sites that raise awareness about situations like these, but I don't think there's a critical mass yet to turn things around. The vast majority of Americans is probably still more afraid about terrorists than they are of this trend in Government, therefore the trend will continue.
- gavinlynch 14y ago"The vast majority of Americans is probably still more afraid about terrorists than they are of this trend in Government, therefore the trend will continue." Government border checks are a bigger problem than religious terrorists?
- ta12121 14y agoNo, intrusive government government checks combined with government databases of citizens' online activities are a bigger problem than religious terrorists. And the answer is yes.
- gavinlynch 14y agoIf you don't want it known, don't put it into the public sphere. You call the checks intrusive, I don't quite mind the idea that we are attempting to figure out who exactly the people are that are coming across American borders into this country. I'm sure you disagree. And my answer would simply be no. In no way do I see monitoring the flow of humans into our country as a bigger problem than religious terrorists whose sole intent is to murder and maim as many innocent people as they can. shrugs
- Karunamon 14y ago>I don't quite mind the idea that we are attempting to figure out who exactly the people are that are coming across American borders into this country. What exactly does the kind of software a person develops have to do with whether they should be allowed entry into the USA?
- gavinlynch 14y agoVery disappointed to hear that most people view a simple border check as more dangerous than a fanatical religious terrorist. Again, I know this is not a popular view, and will surely get more downvotes. Just kind of sad to me, to be honest.
- jchrisa 14y agoif furniture is more dangerous than terrorists, then the bar isn't very high for border checks
- rdtsc 14y ago> most people view a simple border check as more dangerous than a fanatical religious terrorist. Which terrorist? So by your logic, because there was a fanatical religious terrorist at some point in time, it is perfectly ok for this country to start prying into everyone's (public and private) accounts, infer who knows what from what they read there ("You write on twitter you are going to have a _blast_!? in Boston" "Ok, step over here please"), and then proceed to interrogate people at the border. It seems like the guy was added to some black database somewhere. Are you in that database too? Can you check who is in there? Do you know how one gets added or removed from it? Are you prepared to justify all the groping, and x-raying going in airports because because of a religious terrorist. What else are you willing to sacrifice because of this religious terrorist. I am, for one, also very disappointed to see that you and others have drunk the cool-aid that has been flowing from Washington D.C. (This is a War on Terror, Be Afraid, Be Prepared for More Attacks, We Must Invade etc. etc.)
- yeahsure 14y agoTrend is the keyword. The Gov won't stop at border checks.
- gavinlynch 14y agoWhat will they do next?
- excuse-me 14y agoI think somebody wrote down a list: For Quartering large bodies of armed troops among us: For protecting them, by a mock Trial, from punishment for any Murders which they should commit on the Inhabitants of these States: For cutting off our Trade with all parts of the world: For imposing Taxes on us without our Consent: For depriving us in many cases, of the benefits of Trial by Jury: For transporting us beyond Seas to be tried for pretended offences
- orthecreedence 14y agoRandom house checks, stops on the street, curfew, mandatory information delivery from private companies (not that this isn't happening already)...just to name a few possibilities.
- noarchy 14y agoThe US border agents claim the ability to set up checkpoints as far as 100 miles from the border, as I recall. And they use this power. I live in Canada, but driving through Vermont I've seen "border" checkpoints located several hours from what you or I might think of as the actual border.
- scarmig 14y agoWell, consider Arizona: right now, I have a grad-student housemate who simply cannot set foot there, despite being here 100% legally. Unfortunately for the purpose of visiting that state, he has noticeably brown skin, and his papers are hundreds of miles away in the home he grew up in. That's a pretty deep restriction on freedom. Even if someone has their papers easily accessible, it's a very scary thought that if you're driving from one city to another, the government officer has the right to stop you and demand you show your papers for no reason. And that's assuming everything going on is above-board. If he came across a corrupt cop, it's pretty terrifying to think about the possibilities of what could happen. And this is becoming the norm, simply because we as a society have decided that virtually everything is permitted to "protect our borders."
- greeneggs 14y agoThere is no evidence that they checked him against some database with everything he said online. It sounds to me like a completely routine check. This is standard procedure, and it is not a bad thing. If you are a border control agent and you want to assess if a businessman coming through is a security threat, you don't ask him, "Are you a security threat?" No, you ask about his work and get into his conversation. If he's honest and straightforward, you move on. If you catch a discrepancy in his story or he is oddly defensive (as it sounds was the case here), you ask some more questions to figure out what is going on. Personally, I enjoy talking about my work. I cross a lot of borders and it can be a pleasure to converse with an agent who is honestly interested. Yes, 45 minutes to an hour would be annoying, but it isn't that terrible and in this case he may have brought it on himself, we can't know.
- eli 14y agoI see no evidence of that.