4 ms·
Eh, the biggest blocker IMO is far more esoteric. Money. There is nothing we are aware of that is even close to expensive/worthwhile enough (except perhaps inf
by lazide 2y ago
Eh, the biggest blocker IMO is far more esoteric. Money.
There is nothing we are aware of that is even close to expensive/worthwhile enough (except perhaps information) to justify the cost in energy to move it that distance. Even if the energy is essentially free.
Do the math - rocket fuel isn’t very expensive in bulk, but even moving ‘free’ gold, platinum, iridium, etc. is not even close to worth it.
And information can be gathered with telescopes or transmitted with lasers or radio at faster speeds, so why bother with the trek?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Do the math - rocket fuel isn’t very expensive in bulk, but even moving ‘free’ gold, platinum, iridium, etc. is not even close to worth it What math are you on? The entire reason moving the "free" ore in the asteroid belt to Earth is expensive is propellant. If we had cheap interplanetary transport, it would absolutely make sense to mine and return matter.
- lazide 2y ago‘If we had cheap interplanetary transport’ Which we don’t. And how do you expect to get it? Especially when the ‘cheap’ part is already too expensive to make it cost effective even within our own neighborhood? That’s the point! You might as well complain there is no point in being poor when you could just be rich. Or that I could take all vacations I wanted if it was free to take vacations. Thanks?
- pixl97 2y agoI mean, that's not a great backup plan. If you're not running a Redundant Array of Independent Planets then you're just one crash away from total data loss. I mean just looking at the energy expenditure growth rate of Earth, you spend as much energy as kings used to in a day. And there is still an absolutely massive amount of solar energy left to harvest.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Redundant Array of Independent Planets Might want to keep workshopping that one.
- pfdietz 2y agoEnergy could be beamed across interstellar distances. It just requires larger apertures than for beaming it across shorter distances. The best way to extract detailed information about a star system is to colonize it. Remote sensing only goes so far.
- lazide 2y agoAnd do the calculations for the energy required. It’s monstrous. Then think for a moment about all the other things we’d probably prefer to do with such a monstrous amount of energy. That’s the opportunity cost, even if that energy is free. We’re entirely speculating on that colonization part - we’ve never tried it.
- pfdietz 2y agoThe energy required is utterly trivial compared to the energy available. If you scale up current society to use the entire output of the Sun, the energy cost of interstellar colonization would be (proportionally) less than a Kickstarter project.
- lazide 2y agoAnd if I had infinite energy, I'd have infinite energy. But we don't, and near as I can tell, it's just a fantasy. A fantasy that even if it happened, would be competing with other things - like powering future air conditioning, or the equivalent of 3D porn, or solving world hunger, or building more aircraft carriers, or the like. So will never be free or actually infinite eh? That’s the opportunity cost part of the equation.
- pfdietz 2y agoIt does get down to the central question behind all of this: can we assume growth indefinitely, or at least up to hard limits? I propose we should, since any subgroup that doesn't grow will be overshadowed by groups that do. If propensity to reproduce has a genetic component it will be selected for.