3 ms·
I've been reading the original brother's grimm to kids for _years_ and the stories are always gripping. I don't love the reinforcing motifs of the world as perp
by wonder_er 2y ago
I've been reading the original brother's grimm to kids for _years_ and the stories are always gripping. I don't love the reinforcing motifs of the world as perpetually experienced as dangerous, however.
I've been LOVING working through the Studio Ghibli anthology with my toddler. Been curating a list (and then finding the right file) of the movies they like with the best audio tracks. (she cannot read, so watching them in the original audio, while engaging, isn't as helpful as good dubs. Some english dubs have been terrible, some quite good.
We most recently watched Ponyo ["poh-noh-fish" as its sometimes called around here], had it playing on the background a few more times. She's been vastly less drawn to things like baby shark and it's ilk, with the availability of Ghibli's works, and we discuss the characters and events and the ups and downs in the movies throughout, and after.
The pacing, the anti-imperial bent, dignifying many oft-de-dignified tropes, the art, the music, the foley, the mystery and the spiritualism and obvious deep love of the harmony of nature. mmm. I've paid Jeff Bezos more than I wish I had in my pursuit of the best/easiest files, but alas. Here's my beta, if you'd like. [0]
I discovered Studio Ghibli only as an adult, more than 30 years old, so for anyone who doesn't know about it, you might be one of today's lucky 10,000. huzzah [1]
[0]: https://josh.works/recommended-reading#studio-ghibli https://josh.works/recommended-reading#studio-ghibli
[1]: https://xkcd.com/1053/ https://xkcd.com/1053/
- cebu 2y agoMaybe the world is dangerous, but maybe that doesn’t mean we have to be afraid. It’s dangerous business stepping out your front door after all
- techostritch 2y agoIs it though? I mean yes, but one argument I would have against overly glorifying some of these fairy tiles is that the way the world is dangerous today is very different from the way it was two hundred years ago.
- wonder_er 2y agoexactly. Also, there's so much adventure to be experienced, so much beauty to appreciate. It's worth it. Also, the world _does not have to be experienced as constantly dangerous_ and it's important to allow a respite from that message. That the world is dangerous is self-evident, but it's not interesting to me to force that message into places it ought not be. And I think adults conceptions of 'the world is dangerous' does not always match the harm as experienced by children. They know the world is dangerous. They experience it all the time.
- cebu 2y agoOf course. It certainly depends on context. Maybe some children need a respite from safe places. Others, an invite into them
- _carbyau_ 2y agoMan, "Grave of the Fireflies" crushed me - once. I certainly couldn't handle having it "playing in the background".
- wonder_er 2y agoYeah this isn't one of the background ones. 'My neighbor Totoro', 'howls moving castle', ponyo, princess calagua