4 ms·
If that were the case, you would expect the consequents of mental illness (most obviously suicide, but also violent crime) to have increased since 1900, around
by tptacek 2y ago
If that were the case, you would expect the consequents of mental illness (most obviously suicide, but also violent crime) to have increased since 1900, around the time that sanitized fairy tales were popularized; and: they have not.
- epx 2y agoThey have and a lot.
- colechristensen 2y agoSource your data. For example, the lowest suicide rate in the US in over a century (and ever, as long as records were kept) happened in 2000.
- llm_trw 2y agohttps://jabberwocking.com/raw-data-us-suicide-rates-since-1900/ https://jabberwocking.com/raw-data-us-suicide-rates-since-19... And today the rate is higher than in 1900 and raising. Sounds like whatever we did in the 1950-1980 worked extremely well and what we've been doing since hasn't.
- tptacek 2y agoThat is, obviously, not a graph of suicide trending upwards as a result of an intervention that occurred at roughly 1900.
- llm_trw 2y agoAnd it is also not a chicken. What does that have to do with suicides increasing in the last 25 years after falling for 50.
- tptacek 2y agoI don't know, but it sure won't have anything to do with sanitizing fairy tales, which is what we're talking about here.
- llm_trw 2y agoYou should probably read the reply above mine. Let me quote it for you in case tree based navigation is too difficult: >For example, the lowest suicide rate in the US in over a century (and ever, as long as records were kept) happened in 2000. If you'd like more context, which I understand can be difficult to remember after reading two 20 word posts, I'd be happy to provide it.
- hifromwork 2y agoYour snark is unnecessary, unjustified, and frankly probably breaking this site rules. The original claim was: >would expect the consequents of mental illness (most obviously suicide, but also violent crime) to have increased since 1900, around the time that sanitized fairy tales were popularized i.e. "if fairy tales are the cause of suicide, it should increase consistently since 1900". This is clearly not the case, as proven by your own data. "Things we were doing in 1950-1980 worked and things we did later don't" is a very different discussion and not the one you were having. It seems to me that it is you who misunderstood the argument and are aggressive to your opponent for absolutely no reason.
- colechristensen 2y agoI doubt that fairy tails in particular could be isolated from the whole culture of insulating children, and it was never, as far as I can tell, a sudden change. You can watch kids movies from the 80s and see a significant difference in the things which children were being exposed to compared to new releases. The change is gradual and has been ongoing for a long time.
- tptacek 2y agoWhat changes are you referring to, since the 1980s? We can pick some of them, call them the next intervention you want to propose as responsible for increases in adverse events, and then look if the epidemiological data lines up with it. I bet, though: the data won't work out for you.
- actionfromafar 2y agoOn the other hand, kids these days can pretty easily get access to stories which were extremely hard to find way back when.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 2y ago> they have not. That's a bold claim. Especially given your starting year, where religious attitudes predominated, and suicide was considered a mortal sin. It seems that quite possibly suicides might have increased since 1900, if only because it has become an organic disease instead of an express ticket to an eternity of torment. Do you have any numbers to back this up? For that matter, we've also noticed from time to time that there are upswings and downswings in suicide (usually explained by economics), and cultural differences. There's plenty of room for for differences in suicide rates over that time period, and it wouldn't really surprised anyone.
- akira2501 2y ago> you would expect the consequents of mental illness (most obviously suicide, but also violent crime) to have increased since 1900 As long as literally everything else remained the same, or in changing, had zero implications on the mental health of the population.
- magicalist 2y agoSeems like a better objection to your GP's post? Or do the covariate "kids these days are coddled" vibes it's based on cancel each other out.
- lazyasciiart 2y agoMore importantly, you would expect not to see high rates of childhood mental illness.
- giantg2 2y agoSeems to me like the blame is with the schools and parents - bringing kids up as helpless victims (can't fight back and the schools don't do much to the bullies), the over use of screens, and surveillance culture never letting them start over (stuff follows you forever now).
- tuatoru 2y agoMy wife was for a time on the board of a local hospital. I recall her recounting a report from the head of the mental health unit saying that there was an increasing number of upper-middle-class young women with "princess syndrome" in the unit: they have been brought up to believe life is a Disney fairy tale, and cannot cope when they get out into the world. So they end up in the mental health unit. This is maybe ten years back? The Disney Corporation has a lot to answer for.
- andrewflnr 2y agoI don't think that's a sound prediction. There are lots of kinds of mental illness, and at least in my view the ones in question are mostly depression, anxiety and the like. Not exactly famous for producing violent outbursts, and a lot of people get treated, which cuts down on suicide. Besides, I don't know if I would trust historical stats for suicide, but whatever. Also the GP comment was arguably more about sanitized childhood in general, which is a more gradual trend than starting at the 1900s exactly.
- tptacek 2y agoThe reason you look at suicide and violent crime is that they're clear indicators. Diagnosis of mental illness is not: definitions, diagnostic techniques, and access to diagnoses have changed radically over the last 100 years. It's similar (though less rigorous, for several reasons) to homicide being the gold standard crime statistic. I'm not making a claim that mental health doesn't matter if it doesn't result in suicide or incarceration. I'm saying: those are two sets of numbers you can find going back to the intervention (the sanitization of fairy tales) and trace since then. The story those numbers tells doesn't match the just-so story the comment provides. Maybe there's more going on than those numbers represents! But I think you'll have a tough time supporting that argument with facts. For instance: the claim was made across the thread that suicide levels were artificially suppressed in 1900 because of religious norms, which works against the story; moreover: you can see in the actual charts what suicide tracks with (it's not a smooth line).
- lmm 2y ago> I'm not making a claim that mental health doesn't matter if it doesn't result in suicide or incarceration. I'm saying: those are two sets of numbers you can find going back to the intervention (the sanitization of fairy tales) and trace since then. That's like the drunk searching for his keys under the streetlamp because that's where the light is! Yes, those are the numbers we have, but do they reliably measure the things we care about? (Are you denying that the millennial mental health crisis exists at all? The fact that it doesn't show up in your preferred statistics is completely independent of any discussion of what the causes may be)
- llm_trw 2y agoSince 1900 we have invented painless dentistry. As someone who got to experience a minor filling done without anesthetic when I was 9 I'd say that alone improved mental health by an order of magnitude.
- entropicdrifter 2y agoI had a full-blown pulpotomy (baby tooth root canal) done with no novocaine injection. I was terrified of the needle. I'm prone to bouts of depression but that's probably got more to do with reading too much news and chronically overextending myself.