5 ms·
Lawyers' Committee Opposes New Draft of American Privacy Rights Act
- idontknowtech 2y agoThis seems to be the crux of their argument, and I find it convincing: > Passing comprehensive privacy legislation would be a major public good–but APRA no longer can be called comprehensive. Civil rights guardrails are essential for consumer trust in a system that allows companies to collect and use personal data without consent. The new draft strips out anti-discrimination protections, AI impact assessment requirements, and the ability to opt-out of AI decision-making for major economic opportunities like housing and credit. We cannot abide a regime that would perpetuate, in the words of Dr. Ruha Benjamin, a form of ‘Jim Code’: ‘the employment of new technologies that reflect and reproduce existing inequities.’
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoI don’t find it convincing at all. Why do privacy protections need to be coupled to anti discrimination language? Pass them as a separate bill, and start with blanket protections on privacy, explicit consent, a ban on data brokers who operate without end user consent, and transparency around how data is obtained. This just looks like an uncontroversial and obvious good (privacy) is being bogged down with politically loaded riders.
- karmajunkie 2y agoFTA: > The new draft of APRA also creates a massive loophole for personal data collected and used on an individual’s device. Tech companies would be able to do almost anything they want with data that stays on a personal device–no data minimization rules, no protections for kids, no advertising limits, no transparency requirements, no civil rights safeguards, and no right to sue for injured consumers. As AI and computing become more powerful, allowing more processing to occur on a device, this loophole will grow. As a result, this draft of APRA is weaker than state laws it is preempting. That hardly amounts to an uncontroversial and obvious good—I would say regardless of your feelings on the anti discrimination provisions that it should be the uncontroversial to reject this legislation.
- spencerflem 2y agoIf it stays on your device, how is it a privacy violation? It sucks that this preemps stronger laws ofc.
- SamuelAdams 2y agoIt depends on how you define what data must stay on the device. You see this all the time with data processing. Individual actions and usernames are recorded. Let’s call that personal data. That has to stay on the device. But what if I also ran a “collect usage metrics” process that ran once a week and summarized your actions, removed your username and replaced it with a random GUID, and otherwise painted a profile of how you used my software over the last seven days? Is that summary level data still considered protected? Can I send that back to my servers without telling you, or if I add a settings toggle for “share usage data to help improve our products”, is that ok? At what point does data become generic enough to not be personal?
- karmajunkie 2y agoThis guy GDPRs... ^^
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- lesuorac 2y agoAlso that data when it's anonymous might be done with a K-Means of 1 or 3 which is basically unanonymous. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K-means_clustering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K-means_clustering
- giantg2 2y agoSo by what logic can you support privacy? If the systems recreate existing inequalities, then we haven't solved these issues in real life. How can we solve these issues comprehensively? Seems a better approach is pass privacy protections, then pass laws addressing specific things as we have solutions for them. The AI impact assessment would be better in an AI specific bill that tackles other AI issues too (like law enforcement or government use, what types of systems should require human in the loop, etc).
- thomastjeffery 2y agoI think any talk of anti-discrimination falls way too far behind the bar. Privacy is an incredibly basic and fundamental right. If there is any provision for data collection without consent ("AI" or otherwise), then that right is violated. No amount of "guardrails" can recover that violation.
- flax 2y agoWhile I agree with their aim and their reasoning on this bill with regard to the fact that it has been unacceptably weakened, I take issue with this quote: "the core purpose of privacy: to ensure that who we are cannot be used against us unfairly." No. Privacy is an end in itself. It is a human right. Falling back to economic justifications weakens the foundation of fighting for privacy.
- MisterBastahrd 2y agoThey're the exact same thing. There's no point to privacy if there's no reason for having it. Simply declaring it a human right is worthless if you can't justify why it is one.
- marshray 2y agoMust we justify the right to a speedy trial by the argument that indefinite detention would unfairly limit our ability to obtain an auto loan?
- MisterBastahrd 2y agoIf you can't figure out why indefinite detainment after an arrest is bad, I'm afraid that nobody is going to be able to help you.
- marshray 2y agoGreat. Now substitute "the absence of privacy" and listen to how it sounds.
- monitorlizard 2y agoYour rhetoric is clever, but I see a hole in it. Indefinite detainment is a logical consequence of lacking a right to a speedy trial, but is not identical to it. I think it is in fact quite apt to say that the right to a speedy trial is to indefinite detainment as the right to privacy is to your information being used against you. Both are material consequences of lacking those rights.
- claytongulick 2y agoIs this a case of perfect being the enemy of good? I don't know anything about the legislation, but the linked article's main complaint seems to be that anti discrimination language was removed from the bill. Ok. I don't understand all the issues involved with that, or what that language was. Regardless, is it still good without that? Does it increase our privacy rights? Why not move the needle in the right direction and then lobby for additional things?
- throwway120385 2y agoAnti-discrimination is the meat of this. We shouldn't allow opaque AI systems to be used as justification for discriminatory actions. Without anti-discrimination they will certainly be used in this way.
- jdp23 2y agoWhile it has some good features (data minimization) it's also got some major weaknesses -- for example state attorneys general say they wouldn't be able to enforce it, it preempts existing stronger privacy laws in states like California and Illinois (and potentially Washington to some extent), EFF's warned about some big loopholes, etc. And that was even before these latest changes. > Why not move the needle in the right direction and then lobby for additional things? Two reasons. Preemption not only weakens some existing laws, it keeps states from passing future stronger laws -- so it caps protections. And, politicially, no privacy law in the US has ever been strengthened by Congress (or state legislatures) ... so, it's very unlikely that the lobbying for additional things will have an affect.
- hedora 2y agoI’m not sure about Illinois, but the California privacy laws are laughably weak.
- 23B1 2y agoBefore HN gets triggered by the word 'discrimination' they're not talking exclusively about skin culture/identity politics, they're talking about all forms of discrimination - which is precisely what privacy rights are supposed to do.
- glitchc 2y agoDiscrimination cannot be avoided by hiding who we are. Removing discrimination requires actively exercising merit in spite of information bias. As long as we have humans with different skin colours, biases will continue to exist. Discrimination occurs when bias informs a decision where it is not a factor.
- hedora 2y agoYes, but a universal right to privacy would ban most current forms of automated bias/discrimination.
- kemitchell 2y agoAny sign of the latest draft they're referring to? I didn't see a link in the post. The May 23 Innovation-Data-Commerce markup? I'd be interested to see what kind of non-discrimination provision was removed. A rule against discriminating against people for exercising their privacy rights, like we see in the California Consumer Privacy Act, GDPR, &c.? Or a more general, civil rights-style prohibition, perhaps incorporating a list of protected classes? They mention the new draft could be weaker than state laws it would preempt. I take it that's most likely a reference to California law. But it comes after discussion of a loophole they see for on-device data, not the part of about non-discrimination. It makes sense for a civil rights organization to want strong nondiscrimination language in a federal privacy bill. But I'm not sure we've seen those bundled in one law and passed before. We have with AI-specific legislation. If the APRA is turning into more of an Omnibus Big Tech Bad Behavior bill, AI regs included, that might make political sense.
- jdp23 2y agoA new draft was released last week -- the committee markup's on Thursday. https://iapp.org/news/a/new-draft-apra-released-ahead-of-27-june-markup/ https://iapp.org/news/a/new-draft-apra-released-ahead-of-27-... has a summary. https://punchbowl.news/wp-content/uploads/PRIVACY_05_xml-005.pdf https://punchbowl.news/wp-content/uploads/PRIVACY_05_xml-005... is the text. I htink there were three key sections that got cut out: 1) "A covered entity or service provider may not collect, process, retain, or transfer covered data in a manner that discriminates in or otherwise makes unavailable the equal enjoyment of goods or services on the basis of race, color, religion, national origin, sex, or disability." This was hugely important, it was sa major victory to get a bipartisan committee majority supporting similar language in APRA's predecessor ADPPA. 2) Requirements for algorithmic impact assessments by large companies (I forget the exact threshold). 3) A requirement to let people opt-out of consequencial automated decisions (with some exceptions), somewhat similar to California's CCPA.
- kemitchell 2y agoThanks so much for taking time to share links and notes!