7 ms·
Tesla investor Steve Jurvetson drives off in the first Model S
- OstiaAntica 14y agoA wealthy "investor" in a rigged game-- a company backed by half a billion dollars in taxpayer loan guarantees-- gets a new toy car. A car for which there is no market and is worse for the environment than regular cars, as it relies on toxic batteries and an inefficient power grid that is majority coal burning.
- cgs1019 14y agoSo many citations needed
- OstiaAntica 14y agoTesla gets crony capitalist, Solyndra-type loan with the worst terms possible for taxpayers: http://www.thecuttingedgenews.com/index.php?article=53001&pageid=&pagename= http://www.thecuttingedgenews.com/index.php?article=53001... http://techcrunch.com/2009/06/23/the-government-comes-through-for-tesla-with-a-465-million-loan-for-its-electric-sedan/ http://techcrunch.com/2009/06/23/the-government-comes-throug... Coal is majority of the U.S. power grid: http://www.ucsusa.org/clean_energy/coalvswind/c01.html http://www.ucsusa.org/clean_energy/coalvswind/c01.html Tesla batteries are cleaner than older versions, but they contain some Cobalt, and Lithium has many impacts and risks for humans.
- rjtavares 14y agoI can't find the half billion figure for Tesla in that article (only for Fisker). Also, Tesla is a public company and therefore discloses their finantials. Their total debt is 270M, and they have 280M in cash (therefore, negative net debt).
- OstiaAntica 14y agoHere's some more info: http://www.businessweek.com/news/2012-05-11/tesla-to-begin-repaying-u-dot-s-dot-loans-by-end-of-2012 http://www.businessweek.com/news/2012-05-11/tesla-to-begin-r...
- mtgx 14y agoI think they've just announced that they will be the first EV company to start paying their debt to the Government by the end of the year or something. If there's a good side to Government funding at all, it's this - investing in future technology that starts being useful right away, and can become mainstream within 10 years, which is a much better investment than subsidizing something like the oil industry for many decades, even though they keep scoring record profits.
- twoodfin 14y agoIf it can become useful and mainstream right away, why do they need government funding? And to point out the obvious, the Federal government extracts far more money from the oil companies (and hence oil consumers) by way of gas taxes than it pays out in subsidies.
- rscale 14y agoAs I see it, the government's real pay-off isn't Tesla paying back it's loans, but rather is the increase in energy policy flexibility that is gained if EVs become popular. If it's easier to provide energy security, that reduces military burden and also reduces our need to be involved in some unfriendly parts of the world. This payoff can't be captured by a private investor, so the government has incentive to invest earlier (and at higher risk levels) than private investors.
- j_col 14y agoDoesn't stop me from wanting to buy one (badly). If only they exported to Europe (hey, we send you our cars, so why not return the love?).
- OstiaAntica 14y agoActually, Daimler-Mercedes bought 10% of Tesla a month before the U.S. government announced the loan. U.S. taxpayers are going to get the downside if the company fails but the European automaker gets the upside if it makes it. Well played.
- arethuza 14y agoOut of interest, what appeals to you about the Tesla S? It's clearly a lovely bit of technology but personally I can't get past the idea of the limited range (maximum of 300 miles) and obvious potential difficulties around recharging. [NB I'm in no way implying that anyone has to justify their tastes in cars (or anything else) - I'm just interested!]
- rweba 14y agoI think 300 miles is plenty for most people (for me definitely). Most people drive less than 30 miles a day. I could even drive from DC to Pittsburgh without having to recharge (about 240 miles).
- Retric 14y agoHow often do you actually drive 200+ miles in a single day? Personally I have averaged 8k miles per year over the last 5 years and renting a car for the single long trip 340 miles I have made over that time period is not exactly a big deal. PS: People talk about how long it takes to get a full charge but if you can add 100 miles to the range in an hour while your stopped for lunch that bumps the daily range to 400 which would have more than covered me, but they can apparently get close to a full charge in 45 minutes.
- arethuza 14y ago"How often do you actually drive 200+ miles in a single day?" I'm probably not an average driver - I don't drive at all during the week (walk to work and pretty much everywhere else, taxi to airport) but when I do drive to go walking/cycling/skiing the total I drive in a weekend is probably close to 300 miles - either in one day or parking car where recharging won't be available.
- adventureful 14y agoBy that standard, we should never develop any new technology, because in the process of developing ANY new technology (including wind power and solar power) you're going to generate some level of pollution, including most likely using fossil fuels. By your standard, we can never progress at all, and must eventually regress to a primitive state. If that had been followed, we could have NEVER developed solar panels, and so many other important, cleaner technologies.
- OstiaAntica 14y agoLook, Tesla is billed as being greener than traditional autos but it is not. Drawing power from the grid is amazingly wasteful, and is often COAL. Trading oil for coal is not an environmental win-- Tesla's basic premise is a fraud. It reminds me of ethanol, another big government effort for the "environment" which makes things worse.
- gfodor 14y agoUnlike traditional vehicles, Tesla's cars have the potential to be run on nuclear, solar, or other future green energy sources as more and more of those options come online. One would think this goes without saying.
- stephengillie 14y agoCome drive in Washington State, where our grid is powered by the water which falls from our sky, as it flows back to the ocean. Also WSDOT just installed 7 EV charging stations along Interstate 5: http://www.wsdot.wa.gov/News/2012/05/30_newevstations.htm http://www.wsdot.wa.gov/News/2012/05/30_newevstations.htm
- nitrogen 14y agoAIUI coal is still cleaner per mile than gasoline.
- schraeds 14y agoThat is on the grid. One would assume in a couple years wind and solar would power the grid. Also, Tesla refers to itself as a technical innovator. Whether they succeed or not commercially, they will undoubtedly advance the date of electric vehicles. Elon Musk is an extraordinary visionary.
- bdfh42 14y agoNot exactly streaming out of the showrooms are they? They remain very much a toy but maybe one day someone will be able to build one that will work on a practical day to day basis. I feel there is a lot of mileage (pun intended) in the "diesel electric" combination where the juice is generated by an internal combustion engine that can be run very efficiently and then fed to the electric drive (with a small battery back-up for peak demands).
- bking 14y agoI am going to assume that your first comment is directed at a "lack of interest" from buyers in "Showrooms". I am pretty sure all the 2013 models have been pre-sold, and the waiting list for the next year is 1500 deep.
- lisperforlife 14y agoProbably once LFTRs come in or we find other ways to get away from coal for energy this would stop being a toy and get rid of our reliance on gasoline for ever.
- rdl 14y agoI think natural gas electrical generation + electric cars is a lot more likely to happen than natural gas vehicles (CNG or LNG). To the extent that NG displaces coal (which is already happening due to cost of NG being so low, at least in the US; we could accelerate it with regulation or long-term fuel contracts when building new plants), it's a big win. From a security (vs. environmental) perspective, burning US coal is superior to importing oil.
- jonknee 14y agoIt's strange to say there is no market for a car that has a 10,000 person waiting list (with a $5,000 down payment to be on it) before anyone had actually gotten behind the wheel. I'd say that's pretty damn good and already close to a billion dollar market. Mercedes "only" sold 9,804 S-Class models in the US last year. Maybe they'll step it up.
- jlgreco 14y ago> "...it relies on toxic batteries..." http://www.teslamotors.com/blog/teslas-closed-loop-battery-recycling-program http://www.teslamotors.com/blog/teslas-closed-loop-battery-r...
- linhat 14y agoThe key is an actual (albeit stylized) miniature version of the Model S [1], you can see it right in the beginning of the video being handed over. Why did nobody think of this before. I just love the immediate connection one makes with this object. While the features it brings to the table (unlocking car doors on approach, loading personal settings, etc.) are nothing really new, there seems to be one missing: the only thing I don't see is a way to connect it to my keychain, but that would probably only destroy its beautiful finish. So how is this kind of design strategy called, if there is a name for it at all? I am asking, because it strikes me as really obvious, while it seems like one does not see it too often. [1] http://www.teslamotors.com/models/features#/styling http://www.teslamotors.com/models/features#/styling (scroll down to about half of the page)
- obilgic 14y agoPorsche has the same type of key https://www.google.com/search?q=porsche+key&hl=en&safe=off&prmd=imvns&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ei=_m3QT93HCez34QTZ-Mm6DA&ved=0CFgQsAQ&biw=1436&bih=806 https://www.google.com/search?q=porsche+key&hl=en&sa...
- Too 14y agoAs if todays car keys aren't big enough already! Seriously, why is everything you have to carry with you getting bigger and bigger. Phones and car keys being the two main villains here.
- rdl 14y agoI was kind of annoyed after a meeting (and an annoying electrical problem with my audi's parking sensors) the other day, so I drove over to the Tesla dealer in Menlo Park -- sitting in an awesome $100k car is a great motivator to work on a startup faster (so as to be able to buy a Tesla and a house to charge it in). The interesting thing I learned is that a lot of the Tesla Roadsters will be available as Certified Pre-Owned, starting in Fall 2012 and pretty much into 2013. They had a bunch of them out for "lease a Roadster until your Model S is ready", and those are delivery positions in Fall 2012; there was also a lease program which will be expiring in 2013 as well (since the Roadster is no longer in production). I am still a lot more into a Model S sized car (luxury and functionality over performance and "fun"), but it would be a good option.
- mhb 14y agoWhy did they discontinue Roadster production?
- mhb 14y agoInfo on Roadster discontinuation: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/08/automobiles/08TESLA.html?_r=2&emc=eta1 http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/08/automobiles/08TESLA.html?_...
- techdmn 14y agoThanks for the link. The article states that Tesla hopes to have a next generation Roadster available in 2013 or later. Arguably a production gap, which isn't unheard of even for larger auto makers. It is an awfully long gap though, a few months would be more typical. "Or later" is a little ominous as well.
- sp332 14y agoReminds me of the Magratheans sleeping until the galactic economy was ready for custom planets again :) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magrathea#Magrathea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magrathea#Magrathea
- kondro 14y agoSo… when do these start shipping to Australia? :-)
- cynix 14y agoAt double the price of what people in other countries pay, I'm not sure if I should look forward to it.
- andyjohnson0 14y agoRich guy get new expensive car. Why is this important?
- pilif 14y agoRich guy gets to drive a car built by the company he has invested in despite the fact that what the company is doing was, until very recently, said to be completely impossible. Now, as an engineer, I of course value actually building the thing much higher than investing into getting it built, but I still would give the investors some credit for actually believing that Tesla was able to accomplish the very unlikely. In the context of HN, this is IMHO interesting a) because it's about the engineering feat of building that car and b) about investors investing in something they actually believe in as opposed to something to make a quick buck with.
- andyjohnson0 14y agoThe article says nothing about the engineering technology used to construct what I agree is an impressive vehicle. And it doesn't say anything useful about how Tesla aims to get traction in the electric vehicle sector. Instead we learn how a wealthy guy can write a cheque on impulse for a very expensive new car "...and then toss it across the table. Everyone was stunned.”. I don't begrudge the guy his money. I'm sure he's earned it and he gets to decide how to spend it, but the fawning style of this article annoyed me. Telsa's technology and Telsa the business are totally on-topic for HN, but this article isn't about any of those things.
- planetguy 14y agoIt's not about the fact that the rich guy's getting it, it's about the fact that the car is now in production.
- andyjohnson0 14y agoYes, but why is this significant? Its not like this is the first time that Tesla have brought a vehicle to production. They've had cars on the market since 2008.
- bking 14y agoIf I were a few more years along into my career I would have preordered my Model S for sure. I will have to wait a few years I guess.
- IanDrake 14y agoI'm surprised by the amount of negativity here. These are some of the most advanced cars ever made and they're made in the US. Keep in mind, Tesla is at the very beginning of the adoption curve for electric cars. When I was a kid, in 1984, my dad bought a CD player for $1K. It was an expensive "toy" for rich people. I'll spare you the rest of the story. As for the government backed loan, I blame the government, not the corporations that take it.
- srik 14y agoThere's more to the loan than meets the eye. Do listen to Musk's short explanation here - http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=IiPJsI8pl8Q#t=344s http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v...
- redorb 14y agoA friends dad once told me he wasn't responsible for his credit card debt because the companies kept sending him credit card offers. I believe in personal responsibility. Let the government do what it does best.. Schools, prisons (I dont like the privatization of prisons), streets, highways .... But I wish they would stay away from business loans