5 ms·
I think that’s an example of “bad facts make bad law.”
by rayiner 2y ago
I think that’s an example of “bad facts make bad law.”
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> that’s an example of “bad facts make bad law” How? The Allies defeated Hitler and more or less said no more wars of conquest, especially in Europe. That precedent was cemented with MAD and the bipolar world order. Putin is relitigating that line. If anyone has a say in that (and the firepower to back it) it’s the Allies. (Or at least the ones that survived.)
- rayiner 2y agoHitler was a unique threat that doesn’t justify an overarching global military regime that interferes with regional conflicts. Nazi Germany was used as precedent to justify countless mistaken wars in the second half of the 20th century, from Korea to Vietnam to Iraq. The US has spent trillions of dollars since 1945 intervening in border conflicts that weren’t in America’s interest.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> US has spent trillions of dollars since 1945 intervening in border conflicts that weren’t in America’s interest I agree. Which is where Europe being different comes into play. Europe has a history of multilateral border agreements with external guarantors, from the Treaty of Westphalia (the actual one, concerning the Holy Roman Empire, not the meme) and Congress of Vienna to the Paris Peace Treaties and Maastricht/Lisbon. It’s also a clear American economic and security interest. I’m not arguing for or against any specific action here. Just that if there is a group with a precedent of checking imperial dictators in Europe, it’s the Allies.
- rayiner 2y agoIf Europe wants to check Russian expansion, they can do that. But it’s none of America's business. I don’t think it actually affects someone in Ohio if the French were speaking Russian tomorrow.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> it’s none of America's business It’s as much our business as Hitler was. We didn’t go into WWII to stop the Holocaust, we went into stop Hitler. > don’t think it actually affects someone in Ohio if the French were speaking Russian tomorrow Ohio is an industrial and agricultural export powerhouse. 17% of its exports go to Europe, $1.1bn of which to France [1]. Even if we reduce this to a pockebook issue, Paris falling into Moscow's sphere of infuence makes Ohio poorer. More pointedly: we made a promise to Europe, through NATO and various agreements, to protect it from Moscow. If Putin's in Paris, we're treaty bound to fight him. (And if Ukraine is a borderline issue in America, you know Western Europe won't be. Dithering on Ukraine increases the chances we get sucked into a massive foreign war.) [1] https://dam.assets.ohio.gov/image/upload/development.ohio.gov/business/export/2021-Ohio-Exports-Report.pdf https://dam.assets.ohio.gov/image/upload/development.ohio.go...
- rayiner 2y ago> It’s as much our business as Hitler was. We didn’t go into WWII to stop the Holocaust, we went into stop Hitler. Hitler plausibly threatened American security. I don’t see any indication that Russia could do the same. Realistically, Russia can’t even take over Western Europe. Look, we know where playing world police—treating every border aggression like it’s literally Hitler—takes us. For the last 80 years we have pissed away trillions of dollars and countless American lives defending borders few Americans could find on a map. It’s not worth it, and most of the world (except Europe who gets to free-ride on the security we provide) hates us for it. > Ohio is an industrial and agricultural export powerhouse. 17% of its exports go to Europe, $1.1bn of which to France If we stopped dicking around being the world police, why would a Russian-controlled France stop buying stuff from Ohio? As to NATO—it’s obsolete.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Hitler plausibly threatened American security. I don’t see any indication that Russia could do the same How? Hitler wasn’t in Cuba [1]. Putin challenges America directly in a way Hitler never did prior to our entering the war. > It’s not worth it I agree in general. Not in Europe, and not with Putin. > why would a Russian-controlled France stop buying stuff from Ohio? Same reason Europe and our allies in the Middle East preferentially buy from us. Commercial ties follow spheres of influence. It’s not some random coincidence our trading partners in the Middle East, Africa, Caucasus and Southeast Asia track our military alliances. > NATO—it’s obsolete You’d prefer another European free for all? Because again, when that happens, it’s obvious we’d get involved. You may prefer we not. But we would, and then you’ve got a major foreign war on your hands. [1] https://apnews.com/article/russia-military-warships-caribbean-cuba-venezuela-e8a9d4342e346e17b05a567e7ad9d384 https://apnews.com/article/russia-military-warships-caribbea...