3 ms·
The real "Boeing is TBTF" list is this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_Defense,_Space_%26_Security https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_Defense,_Space_%26
by pjc50 2y ago
The real "Boeing is TBTF" list is this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_Defense,_Space_%26_Security https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_Defense,_Space_%26_Secu... ; continuity of supply is why forcing them into real non-operating bankruptcy is inconceivable. Nothing more onerous than Chapter 11.
> Especially as we’re lining up for a potential war in the South China Sea, Boeing’s military-industrial ties may actually be what forces those who’d prefer to look the other way to stare down the problem. We can’t win that war, if we have to fight it, with Boeing a shitshow. And we’re more likely to have to fight it every time Beijing sees it’s a shitshow.
So this is a very interesting question, but it's not clear to me whether it can be resolved until the shooting actually starts. WW2 was a huge driver for fixing broken things (USN torpedoes didn't work reliably at the start, for example, in ways that only appeared under live conditions!). The Iraq war was on the other hand a huge opportunity for grift. Pallets of dollar bills vanished. Someone made a lot of money from non-functional mine detectors.
What's the difference? Well, the Iraq and Afghan wars were completely irrelevant and invisible to the Homeland, just a money and lives sink shown on TV, while WW2 kicked off with a bit of Actual America (Hawaii) being bombed.
The China war will probably have no real effects on the US until the GPUs stop arriving, at which point most of NVIDIA's $3tn market cap vanishes and Americans feel it in their retirement accounts. Then, and only then, will people take it seriously enough to overcome corruption.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> continuity of supply is why forcing them into real non-operating bankruptcy is inconceivable. Nothing more onerous than Chapter 11 Correct. But that’s still bankruptcy. It wipes out the shareholders and lets the creditors, which presumably includes the government, reörganise the company as it sees fit. (I’d start with cleaving BDS from the rest of Boeing.) > it's not clear to me whether it can be resolved until the shooting actually starts Do you have a source on the torpedo story? Hadn’t heard that one before, and it sounds fun. I recently read about how “the US went into [WWII] with fewer carriers than the Japanese, it was the US that was almost out of carriers in the Pacific in late 1942, and the US that had suffered the larger percentage of carrier losses—not the Japanese” [1]. We still won, as the author puts it, not with “the fleet that [we] started the war with,” but “the fleet that [we] ended it with.” How? Because “by December 8, 1941, the United States had already undergone 3 cycles of investment in only 8 years, with the last being one of the largest peace-time defense investments in US history.” Put another way, it’s not clear we can wait until the shooting starts. What’s germane to this discussion is less whether that is true, but whether those in government with power over Boeing believe it is. > China war will probably have no real effects on the US until the GPUs stop arriving I’m not sure. Unless we try to fight it à la Ukraine, and it’s unclear that’s even an option, I expect the opening moves will involve the deaths of American soldiers. That brings it closer to “a bit of Actual America (Hawaii) being bombed.” (I assume a strike on a CVN would incur similar emotions, though that’s just a guess.) [1] https://phillipspobrien.substack.com/p/war-and-deterrence-in-the-indo-pacific https://phillipspobrien.substack.com/p/war-and-deterrence-in...
- AnimalMuppet 2y ago> I recently read about how “the US went into [WWII] with fewer carriers than the Japanese, it was the US that was almost out of carriers in the Pacific in late 1942, and the US that had suffered the larger percentage of carrier losses—not the Japanese” I don't dispute your overall point, but I don't think this is right. I couldn't read your source without a signup, so I went looking around. According to https://www.statista.com/statistics/1353080/wwii-japan-us-aircraft-carrier-strength-and-losses/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1353080/wwii-japan-us-ai... the Japanese lost 14 carriers in the war, and ended with 18 in service, so they lost 14 out of 32. The US lost 5 and ended with 34 in service, so it lost 5 out of 39. That's really hard to turn into "the US suffered the larger percentage of carrier losses". As I said, I don't disagree with your overall point. As to the torpedo story: IIRC, there were two problems. The torpedoes themselves had an issue. I don't recall exactly, but it may have been that they didn't run at the depth they were supposed to. The second problem was the detonators. They didn't trigger if they hit square on, but only if they hit at an angle. So the better the shot on a ship, the less likely the torpedo was to actually explode. They didn't get consistently working torpedoes until September 1943.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> couldn't read your source without a signup Honestly worth the sign-up, but here you go in the meantime [1]. (Never mind, Substack got smarter.) The greater loss ratio claim is limited to aircraft carriers in 1942. America lost as carriers as Japan that year and wound up the year in worse shape, numerically, despite Midway. What got us through wasn’t a decisive naval battle in June of ‘42 but the production infrastructure laid down in the decade prior. We built our way out of the hole, because in attritional war, stocks are less important than flows. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20240611165959/https://phillipspobrien.substack.com/p/war-and-deterrence-in-the-indo-pacific https://web.archive.org/web/20240611165959/https://phillipsp...
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoOK, if you're talking about 1942 only, I could see it. And the quote I cited did say "in late 1942", so, OK, I should read more thoroughly. > in attritional war, stocks are less important than flows. Yeah. And a prolonged war turns into an attritional war. And the US isn't in a great place for that right now. One good thing about the Ukraine war is that it pointed this out to the US, now, while we're not directly involved.
- safety1st 2y agoNot sure if the last paragraph was sarcasm. One third of global shipping passes through the South China Sea. If war breaks out and it becomes unsafe to ship along those trade lanes, it will be absolutely cataclysmic for the global economy, and while the US will be more insulated from the worst shocks than many other countries, Americans will absolutely feel it hit their wallets on day one.