3 ms·
> I don’t personally agree with the term “overcorrecting” because they aren’t correcting anything. When I think of "correctness" in programming, to me that mea
by kelnos 2y ago
> I don’t personally agree with the term “overcorrecting” because they aren’t correcting anything.
When I think of "correctness" in programming, to me that means the output of the program conforms according to requirements. Presumably a lawful person who is looking for an AI assistant to sift through resumes would consider something that is biased against disabled people to be correct and conform to requirements.
Sure, if the requirements were "an AI assistant that behaves similarly to your average recruiter in all ways", then sure, a discriminatory AI would indeed be correct. But I'd hope we realize by now that people -- including recruiting staff -- are biased in a variety of ways, even when they actively try not to be.
Maybe "overcorrecting" is a weird way to put it. But I would characterize what you call "correct according to the inputs" as buggy and incorrect.
> If people are discriminatory or racist or sexist, it is not correct to attempt to hide it.
I agree, but that has nothing to do with determining that an AI assistant that's discriminatory is buggy and not fit for purpose.
- throwaway7ahgb 2y agoI don't disagree with what you wrote here, however who gets decide what "correcting" knobs to turn (and how far)? The easy obvious answer here is to "Do what's right". However if 21st century political discourse has taught us anything, this is all but impossible for one group to determine.
- steveBK123 2y agoAgreed, problem as well is "do what's right" is a thing that changes a lot over time. And while “the arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice.” .. it gyrates a lot overcorrecting in each direction as it goes. Handing the control dials to a educationally/socially/politically/etc homogenous set of San Fran left wing 20 somethings is probably not the move to make. I might actually vote the same as them 99% of the time, while thinking their views are insane 50% of the time.
- throwaway7ahgb 2y ago> while thinking their views are insane 50% of the time. As a moderate conservative I feel the exact same.
- alan-hn 2y agoI think in this case, correctness can refer to statistical accuracy based on the population being modeled Remember that's all this is, statistics not a logical program. The model is based on population data