> After a rebase you have commits where no one's ever run the tests, no author ever intended to get the repo into that state. I take it that you've never revie

> After a rebase you have commits where no one's ever run the tests, no author ever intended to get the repo into that state. I take it that you've never reviewed a PR where the commits were a series of "wip" commits that don't even type check, much less pass the tests? Undisciplined developers will be undisciplined. Forcing a rebase-free workflow mostly makes it less likely that these developers will lose work, it doesn't magically give you a clean commit history from them.