3 ms·
Sure, it's energy intensive, but if that energy comes from the sun, who cares? I don't understand we keep using "energy intensive" as a euphemism for "emits ca
by stavros 2y ago
Sure, it's energy intensive, but if that energy comes from the sun, who cares?
I don't understand we keep using "energy intensive" as a euphemism for "emits carbon". The two aren't synonymous. Energy-intensive processes aren't a problem at all, the problem is dirty energy generation processes. Fix your energy generation, and there's no problem.
- cogman10 2y agoThere's a (diminishing) correlation that shouldn't be ignored. I'm not saying we should abandon solar because of that correlation but it should at least be factored in. For example, I think it's a dumb idea to turn every road into a "solar road" just because "who cares".
- stavros 2y agoI was replying to a specific argument: That producing solar panels is energy-intensive, and thus bad (this part was implied). My counterargument is that energy-intensive is irrelevant when you've got basically-free, clean energy. If your energy is dirty, fix your energy. Don't make downstream consumers feel bad instead.
- cogman10 2y agoI don't disagree, just taking the conversation a slightly different direction as I think you'll agree that the "it takes energy to make renewables" argument is generally made in bad faith. I think there is irresponsible consumption of solar panels, particularly when it's done more as a performative action rather than actually producing power to be used.
- mlyle 2y agoYah. I am glad we are deemphasizing residential solar. Utility-scale solar has better capacity factors and installation economics. I think it's going to be barely possible to keep our current quality of life and reach a low-CO2 economy. We have limited resources, and even if a residential solar panel "pays back" its energy in 2.5 years, we are better off putting it in a desert where it will pay back that energy in a year.
- mulmen 2y agoWhat about the economies of scale? Does/did residential solar create enough demand to ramp up utility scale production?
- mlyle 2y ago> did I think residential solar was a decent bridge to get things going, and the installed capacity we have is helpful. Now, though-- at midday we have a glut of power. Residential installations are more expensive per kilowatt hour and don't do as well in reaching into the late afternoon when we need power most. There's no need to add more capacity like this. Better for those panels to go somewhere else. There are still times that non-utility scale solar make sense-- it's usually when you get some kind of non-normal-generation related benefit that tips it over into worthwhile, e.g. - getting a shade structure for a parking lot as part of the rollout - if you want power backup for your house, adding a bunch of storage and solar etc.
- mulmen 2y agoAre there benefits to distributing generation? If I can top up my car on a sunny day the grid doesn’t even have to know.
- mlyle 2y agoThere were some early benefits to grid stability, but not to the extent we've done it, no. At this point, there are a lot of residential neighborhoods that need more distribution and even transmission capacity (because their peak power movement is now exporting power at mid-day rather than the previous smaller peak loads used). And operating the grid has become a much more complicated task.
- mulmen 2y agoDoes a battery system solve this mid day export problem?
- XorNot 2y agoThe oil companies all rebranded themselves as energy companies over a decade ago, my presumption is it was a convenient part of a long term promotional plan to mix up the definitions to get the environmental movement to fight itself. Same as how the idea of a "carbon footprint" was sponsored out into the world by the same people. The trick to good propaganda is to create something that makes you say "well I know it's propaganda, but this doesn't seem so wrong..."