4 ms·
You’re overlooking that all the money goes into the universal service fund, from where it is redistributed to the carriers that service those high-cost customer
by rayiner 2y ago
You’re overlooking that all the money goes into the universal service fund, from where it is redistributed to the carriers that service those high-cost customers. AT&T gets some of that money, but very few of its customers are high cost. Most of the money goes to different, smaller providers. (At the same time, the tax on AT&T’s service reduces AT&T’s revenues, like any other tax.)
- FireBeyond 2y agoRight, so it's proportionally allocated to providers based on their service to those challenging customers. I'm not sure what's being overlooked.
- rayiner 2y agoOP called the USF fee on his AT&T bill “compensation” to AT&T for maintaining landlines. That overlooks that the vast majority of that money is redistributed from AT&T and its customers to other carriers serving a small population of very high cost customers.
- saghm 2y agoThe USF isn't a final destination for money though; it's spent on those small population customers in proportion to the carriers that serve them. You seem to be arguing that because 100% of the money doesn't go to AT&T, paying that fee somehow isn't relevant to the discussion of AT&T serving those remote customers, but the amount they get is literally determined by how many of those customers they serve. By the same logic, other carriers collect the same fee from their customers that could get funneled to AT&T! I'm not sure if you're just trying to argue semantics about the fact that only part of the fee goes to AT&T or if you misunderstand how the USF actually works, but AT&T isn't disadvantaged at all compared to other carriers by this fee; they're all on the same playing field in terms of having to collect the fee and then only getting it back in proportion to the costs of serving the customers that the article discusses.