4 ms·
Europe's solar power surge hits prices, exposing storage needs
- euroderf 2y agoMostly OT but: Consumer-facing simplicity please. Don't make me think. Give me a solution I can buy at the hardware store, that has 1, 2, or 3 standard panels (300W-400W) and that I can connect to 1, 2, or more old gasoline-car batteries (or UPS batteries). With measurement outputs over wifi that I can capture with Home Assistant. And with an AC output that I can connect to a TV to watch football, or to a blender to mix daiquiris. After I get some experience with power storage, I can scale it up and integrate to the grid.
- Iulioh 2y agoSolutions like this do exist, the problem is the fact that aren't cheap. I mean, it's pretty common with basically any permanent modifications you can make to your house if you think about it, is not like you can build a porch without a lot of experience or detailed instructions. Solar pannels are like that, pretty doable but you need to do your homework
- ForOldHack 2y agoSome company named Tesla makes home storage systems, but it was found to be out performed by a set of golf cart batteries by one house, and a saline flow battery at another. Much homework and education are always empowering.
- aitchnyu 2y agoWhats that saline flow battery? I thought it was still RnD or commercial tech.
- hnbad 2y agoAt the EU level these exist. In Germany they're called balcony power plants: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balkonkraftwerk https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balkonkraftwerk They're capped at 800 W in Germany for fire safety reasons and because residential fuses are rated at 16 A. You can buy complete sets at hardware stores and even supermarkets like ALDI. They plug into a wall socket like any household appliance. You can use a WiFi connected smart socket to measure the output if the inverter doesn't come with an API. I've seen an 800 W "ready to use" one at a German discount supermarket for €300, although prices can reach €1500 and more for some of the fancier models. You do have to register them online but you don't have to inform your electrical company. If you're a tenant, your landlord has to approve of you installing one unless they have a legitimate reason to refuse you (generic "safety concerns" or complaints about them being ugly are not valid).
- snowpid 2y agoI love that one guy who made the Catalan article. Pure dedication.
- michaelt 2y agoYou can buy products kinda like this already. Portable solar panels, portable all-in-one charger/battery/inverter, charging from the grid if you want, and basically available off-the-shelf. They're sold for camping, RVs, boats etc. No ability to feed power back into the grid though.
- quickthrowman 2y agoWhat you’re asking for exists already > https://theinverterstore.com/product/120-watt-solar-kit-1000-watt-power-inverter-charger/ https://theinverterstore.com/product/120-watt-solar-kit-1000... If you want to attach to the grid, you add another piece of equipment (you don’t need to sell power to the grid, it will take years and years to pay the equipment off by selling power)
- tcfhgj 2y agoWhy are there negative prices when wind and solar can mostly be shut down almost instantly to 0kw production?
- p_l 2y agoTL;DR - they are a signaling method. They are used to signal the producers to shut production down, actually - as in, the energy producer's dispatch team uses negative prices to signal to power plants to change production schedule. In case of wind power, some power plants can actually make money on negative prices because modern wind turbines can be dynamically made into an energy sink. Similarly negative prices are used as signal to storage providers.
- ForOldHack 2y agoYou would think they would mention that they are one of the very top users of pumping water storage, and developers of gravity systems, but marketing and economics take the front row seat? Seems short sighted. Battery storage is still in it's infancy. A large fleet of electric cars would help - but it looks like all this is an afterthought.
- aitchnyu 2y agoUmm, can you expand on wind turbines being energy sinks in a way solar cannot?
- p_l 2y agoSolar panels essentially give you DC output from light hitting them. You can't make a sink out of it in any way. You cannot connect power to solar panel and make it generate light or otherwise consume it (other than maybe melting it ;)) Wind turbines however provide rotational energy that has to be turned into electricity. Modern turbines use somewhat complex alternators, often with multiply of 3 phases, which is normally used to provide delicately adjusted power output in sync with the grid. Fine adjustments of phase skew are usually used to control power provided to the grid and to keep generated power in phase with the grid. However, such alternator can be driven in a way where the electricity provides braking power. You can think of it as similar to how many electric engines are both generators and sinks. It's however way more fine tuned than toy examples.
- asplake 2y ago> On the flip-side, the power market is now seeing a bigger gap between low and high-priced hours, increasing the incentive to invest in storage, he added. Seems like the system is working
- darthrupert 2y agoFree markets always work. Some people just don't like how they work.
- sschueller 2y agoTell that to the 346 that died in a Boeing 737 max. Half of those where on the second plane when the problem was well known.
- utensil4778 2y agoFree markets work for people with power and wealth. Free markets do not work for people who need insulin to survive, for one example. The free market failed so spectacularly that we had to introduce legislation to regulate the insulin market. You know, so people don't die horrific deaths because they can't afford a medicine that costs essentially nothing to produce.
- AtlasBarfed 2y agoCan someone explain the game theory of a "pure free market" where the second a competitor gains any advantage, how wouldn't it mathematically imply total domination of the market?
- michaelt 2y agoHere in the UK, we kinda have two energy storage problems in parallel. One problem is that the highest solar power output is around mid-day, but the highest power demand is in the evening. This is ideal for batteries to help with - and if you build a storage facility that buys electricity for £70 and sells it later for £100, you can make that profit 365 times a year. The other problem is the country uses a lot of power for heating during the winter - but solar output is 5x higher during the summer months. This is much more difficult for batteries to help with, because even if you somehow manage to buy electricity for £20 in summer and sell it for £200 in winter, that's still a much smaller return than a battery you cycle daily. I'm not sure what the solution to the latter problem is - nuclear might help, but we've really struggled to get it built at a sane price. Solar generation in other countries could help, but brexit shows an independence-minded go-it-alone streak that I suspect would make our politicians reluctant to spend billions on power plants in north africa. Wind is of course great, but is it enough?
- spacebanana7 2y ago> One problem is that the highest solar power output is around mid-day, Tariffs that reward charging electric bikes, cars and home backups at these times can also really help. > The other problem is the country uses a lot of power for heating during the winter Sadly I doubt the UK will ever be able to move away from winter gas. It's hardwired into many heating appliances and, as you say, it's challenging for batteries to shift the load.
- Qwertious 2y agoDoes targeting charging ebikes make any sense? If the average bike is 500Wh, and bikes mostly aren't completely depleted (a trip to the shops might only take 10% of the battery) then you're talking about maybe 100-200Wh normally. And you're probably charging from a normal wall socket, so there's no easy way to signal to the bike when to charge. Please don't say "add WiFi", bikes should not have WiFi and don't need it. So, how would tariffs targeting ebike charging even work? Telling people "put WiFi on your bike so we can tax you" is a poor strategy that guarantees noncompliance, its load isn't particularly different from other wall-plug appliances so if the tariffgot too high then people would just pretend they're using the microwave, and the total electrical cost of charging might be under 10 cents, so a 10% tariff would be less than 1 cent - so who would even care?
- flurdy 2y agoIt references Statkraft, the Norwegian power company. When they talk about storing power in batteries, they mean lakes and reservoirs at altitude. They are basically giant batteries.
- AtlasBarfed 2y agoPumped hydro is apparently really efficient, cheap, and very high capacity. It's just geographically restricted. Probably can also double as a water reservoir for a local town/city. Christ, the entire Norwegian coastline is a battery in that case.