3 ms·
Well, as much as a I find this sort of thing annoying, I’m going to have to be the drive-by “is it just statistics?” guy. > breast cancer, colorectal cancer, h
by bee_rider 2y ago
Well, as much as a I find this sort of thing annoying, I’m going to have to be the drive-by “is it just statistics?” guy.
> breast cancer, colorectal cancer, hypertension, cardiovascular disease, metabolic syndrome, multiple sclerosis, Alzheimer’s disease, autism, asthma, type 1 diabetes and myopia. Vitamin D has long been considered the principal mediator of beneficial effects of sun exposure. However, oral vitamin D supplementation has not been convincingly shown to prevent the above conditions; thus, serum 25(OH)D as an indicator of vitamin D status may be a proxy for and not a mediator of beneficial effects of sun exposure.
Quite a few, not all, but most, of the maladies they list seem to be well connected to a sedentary lifestyle. Is it possible that this, rather than insufficient sunlight, could be the cause?
I also wonder (wild stereotyping here, but) if there could be some correlations between some of the childhood stuff—Autism, asthma, autoimmune disorders and parents’ class. For example, if someone is an indoor worker, they are probably more likely to be white collar, right? Are we more likely to detect autism for white collar parents (who tend to be a bit more intrusive)?
I don’t have any real suggestions, just a worry that amount of time spent outdoors is a proxy for tons of stuff, including class basically, so it seems incredibly hard to study.
- tvier 2y agoThe biggest study I've found for this (which gets reference in the OP) seems to have done a pretty good job with this[1]. Like you I'd feel much more confident if we had a good understanding of the mechanism, but the effect size just seems too big. [1] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43630-021-00017-x https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43630-021-00017-x
- robomartin 2y agoNot to mention the pandemic of disease being caused by highly processed foods. The damage being done at a global scale is hard to quantify. No perfect analogy for this. One of the many I have used over the years is to have someone imagine driving their car on the highway while pressing on the accelerator all the way down, as far as it will go. To control speed, use the brakes. And then, when the inevitable happens, we blame the brakes. That's what's happening to billions of people. Except for corner cases, obesity is 100% caused by toxic nutrition. The same statement holds for type 2 diabetes. In the US, the FDA (Food and Drug Administration) is complicit in that they do nothing to prevent what could be characterized as poisonous food from entering the market. I think I can say that most food found at a supermarket is horrible stuff that will hurt you over the long run. Let's put it this way: Drugs require prescriptions because, among other things, they would be dangerous to consume freely, without a real medical reason to have them. If you read the ingredients in most food items sold, given what the consequences, it would be easy to wonder why this stuff doesn't require medical supervision to consume. And then we blame vitamin D? C'mon. It's the brakes, not the engine going full throttle down the road. Right.