4 ms·
I'll try really hard to assume you're not trolling here. I think it should be obvious that your suggestion doesn't work, because that's already an option right
by kelnos 2y ago
I'll try really hard to assume you're not trolling here.
I think it should be obvious that your suggestion doesn't work, because that's already an option right now... and it doesn't work. People's lives aren't neat and tidy, and people don't always do the safest things in the heat of the moment. Even if they want to, this kind of testing likely isn't available everywhere, or easily, or cheaply.
A twice-a-year shot is much more likely to be effective and actually used than ad-hoc, on-demand testing.
> ... unless you are extremely active.
Some people are. Are you suggesting that if someone is "extremely" sexually active, they don't deserve a reasonable, affordable way to avoid getting HIV?
> it's better to address the root cause—being hyperactive
If people want to be "hyperactive" when it comes to sex, that's their business, and there's nothing wrong with that. Measures that can make that safer are good things, not bad things.
Reading between the lines, I'm guessing you have some pretty puritanical views toward sex, and some misconceptions about the availability of healthcare and health-related testing in different places in the world. Maybe dial down the level of judgment, and learn a bit more about how people different from you live.
- bobthepanda 2y agoGiven how much of a hot mess mass COVID testing was, and that was just a nasal swab, it is hard to imagine systematic blood draws for STI screening getting anywhere near feasible.
- bruce343434 2y ago> there's nothing wrong with [a hyperactive sex live] Well, clearly nothing except for the increased risk of STD exposure. I'm not GP and I wouldn't call myself puritanical, but let's not pretend like choices don't have consequences, and activities don't have risks. Yes, maybe the risk is more palatable for some, but when they knowingly take on that risk, they don't get to cry in conginitive dissonance about how their situation (STD) is not somehow a consequence of their choices (lots of different partners who are untested). In my opinion they knew what they were getting themselves into. Now, yes, people are stupid, so it's good that backup options exist and are being developed. Still, let's just call it what it is: stupid. I think the modern trend of acting like nothing is ever anybody's fault and consequences don't exist is very harmful. People need to take personal responsibility. And if they can't or won't, we need to recognize that for the bad thing that it is. It's just this incessant infantilisation of people who are perfectly capable of reasoning and agency, where we pretend like nothing is every anybody's fault and therefore don't feel bad about it nor change anything about your ways. And all of that is completely orthogonal to being either a puritan or sex positive.
- foldr 2y ago>Still, let's just call it what it is: stupid. Or maybe it's stupid to refrain from enjoying your sex life when the technology exists to enjoy it safely. All a question of perspective. One thing's clear: there's nothing in your comment that's actually actionable. Sourpusses have been droning on about personal responsibility for centuries – and everyone else has been happily ignoring them. Making PrEP and other such treatments available will actually make a positive difference to people's health.
- bruce343434 2y agoYeah, giving in to our low level desires without doing some high level reflection on it is the easier thing to do. And statistically it is inevitable that at least some people some of the time act on it, so indeed maybe we should throw out the baby with the bathwater and all act that way so we don't get labeled a "sourpuss" when we talk about responsibility. Look, I'm not arguing against backup options here. I'm just saying people should be as responsible as reasonably possible. Edit: it's good that this exists. However, anecdotally: I know some promiscuous people and none of them are on prep. Some don't use protection at all because they are gay and there is no risk of pregnancy for them. When one person acts this way, it's their problem. When many people act this way, having sex at all becomes riskier for everyone. Recently, STDs have been on the rise. People just want to have fun and not feel bad about anything. They think they're the exception or something. And if you dare say something about it, you get called names like "sourpuss" or worse.
- foldr 2y agoYou mostly seem to be complaining about people who aren’t on PrEP. So you should be happy that there may now be an easier option for these people. It’s because you instead choose to complain about (literally!) people who have fun and don’t feel bad about it that you come across as a sourpuss. If you actually have some kind of concrete alternative proposal to making PrEP more widely available then I’m all ears, but you seem just to want to complain about people who have more than some arbitrarily-determined quantity of sex.