6 ms·
New York Establishes Stringent Protections to Safeguard Kids on Social Media
- tastyfreeze 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- eastof 2y ago> New Dork Establishes the Nation’s Most Stringent Protections To Safeguard Kids on Piles of Dry Tinder Governor Kathy Jochul today signed nation-leading legislation to combat match sales to protect kids. Sale of matches to children under the age of 18 is now prohibited. This historic legislation helps parents ensure their children can't self-immolate.
- WillPostForFood 2y agoThe law empowers parents. Off by default, but on with parental approval. If you care about parental responsibility, you should support this. It encourages parental involvement, and allows more options than the binary: use or don't use.
- Spivak 2y agoThere really seems to be no reason whatsoever these protections shouldn't be extended to people over 18. You don't have to check ages that way and the feature has to be there regardless. Also the "after midnight" rule is silly — not bad, just silly. Otherwise good law. A law to "protect the kids" that's actually good? Unheard of. I wonder how sites will handle content discovery that doesn't run afoul of the law. Like completely seriously Discover Weekly on Spotify sounds like it will have to be age gated since Spotify is technically a social network.
- zeroCalories 2y agoBro just stop using the feeds. You're an adult. Kids on the other hand should just be banned from social media. I don't want adult spaces to be molded around children.
- Spivak 2y agoGirl, a law that mandates you be able to turn off the feeds in favor of chronological is stopping using the feeds. Also lol at "you're an adult" like that's how addiction works. Just get more willpower bro. There's a reason you have the option to ban yourself from casinos and the option to do so is mandated by law.
- bluefirebrand 2y ago"ban this thing for everyone because some people have issues with it" is a non starter Personal problems do not get social solutions
- WillPostForFood 2y ago"a law that mandates you be able to turn off the feeds in favor of chronological" That doesn't sound like a ban, that sounds like consumer choice.
- zeroCalories 2y agoNah man, I don't mind the fun police checking my ice cream licence to make sure I haven't gone over my sugar allowance for the month. It's important that we all get punished so fatty doesn't gorge himself to death.
- Spivak 2y agoI don't want a ban good lord. How did you even take that from "companies should be legally required to let each individual turn off algorithmic feeds?" Gambling, alcohol abuse, drug addiction all get social solutions. This law is perfectly consistent how we deal with all other forms of addiction.
- SirensOfTitan 2y agoTo be perfectly honest, I’m extremely conflicted with this kind of legislation—natural physical social interactions have all but atrophied in huge swaths of American youth, and social media is the way kids ultimately communicate. I don’t think that limiting social media exposure will somehow restore in-person physical interaction, and it could just prove to atomize and isolate kids even more than they ultimately are. It is very typical that the state wields the law like a hammer and doesn’t consider the blowback—they should be thinking about how to restore real in-person intimate relationships amongst children.
- swatcoder 2y agoYour comment suggests you didn't look into what this policy actually does. It doesn't ban kids from connecting with their peers on social media or even from following popular (or esoteric) influencers. It just prevents providers from algorithmically optimizing kids' feeds for engagement or whatever else, and adds some limits to when notifications are allowed. Both are actually pretty modest and would seem entirely reasonable in light of what concerns you raised.
- drivebyhooting 2y agoI was at a pizza place and saw a group of 6 or more teenagers sitting together. They were all on their phones with the personification of ennui upon their faces. Just an anecdote.
- gonzo41 2y agoI've seen the same thing with a gaggle of boomers sitting in bar together all not talking and just drinking. No phones.
- ethbr1 2y agoAs someone who was a kid in the pre-iPhone / mobile internet era, I'd say, >> Life, uh, finds a way Things worked just fine over multi-tap keypad SMS, and there were even complaints about kids being sucked into their phones then! Pretty sure if you physically separated every teenager on the planet in a dark basement, they'd have rats carrying braille messages implemented in a week.
- ysofunny 2y ago> " or unless doing so is strictly necessary for the purpose of the website." so this legislation is active unless the website needs it... toothless legislation, looks like a classic market capture law
- newzisforsukas 2y agoS.7694B/A.8148A: https://nyassembly.gov/leg/?default_fld&leg_video&bn=A08148&term&Summary=Y&Text=Y https://nyassembly.gov/leg/?default_fld&leg_video&bn=A08148&... S.7695B/A.8149A: https://nyassembly.gov/leg/?default_fld=%0D%0A&leg_video=&bn=A8149A&term=&Summary=Y&Text=Y https://nyassembly.gov/leg/?default_fld=%0D%0A&leg_video=&bn... It looks like both of these bills give a lot of power to the AG to determine how they are implemented.
- Barbara230 2y ago[flagged]
- zombiwoof 2y agoAnd you are surprised ? Instead of talking to your partner you hired a hacker
- MOARDONGZPLZ 2y agoThis is a sign of an unhealthy relationship. They should have hired a therapist or gone to marriage counseling. If anyone is looking for a marriage counselor get in touch at [ Remote spy therapist @ g(m) ail . c0m ]
- zombiwoof 2y agoThe current internet and app landscape are the largest honey pot mental health crisis this planet has ever seen If I was President I’d turn off the internet for 3 days and watch everyone melt
- akersten 2y agoThis is great, I hope they look into fixing addictive music next. Chechnya is way ahead of the game on solving these societal woes [0]. [0] https://www.cnn.com/2024/04/08/europe/chechnya-music-ban-scli-intl/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2024/04/08/europe/chechnya-music-ban-scl...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- EternalFury 2y agoAs a parent, I wish people who monetize attention had not hurt the development of my children’s social skills. We really tried to curb their engagement with attention-channeling apps and devices, but it got to a point where restricting was enough to label parents as harsh, strict luddites. I suspect it will take a generation or two to revert the effects of that attention hijacking.
- Waterluvian 2y agoThe weirdest thing to me is just how scattershot this problem is. My kids are still young but I’ve got friends who are having a terrible time with this issue, and friends who have had no problem at all with their kids. I’ve been trying to figure out if there’s some environmental factor I might leverage but I just don’t see a meaningfully obvious difference. I guess people are varied and complex.
- pants2 2y agoI bet the most significant factor is social group. If their friends are classmates are constantly talking about things they’ve seen on TikTok, then it’s going to be very difficult to keep your kids off it.
- EternalFury 2y agoPeer pressure is the biggest factor. There is probably a threshold beyond which your kids are going to give their attention away because so many of their friends are doing it. I once hosted a birthday party where after the cake was cut, all 7 kids were on their phones, barely interacting. That was one of the most dystopian thing I have experienced.
- BenFranklin100 2y agoI imagine it will depend on the child. I recall a friend years ago discussing PTSD and how one soldier will return home scarred for life while another just 50 ft away in another foxhole is just fine.
- 2y ago
- biophysboy 2y agoRegulations concerning new problems often provoke cynical reactions that rely entirely on intuition. You see it being applied here: this will backfire, this will isolate kids more, this will make parents less responsible, etc. These kinds of reactions are simplistic and cut off debate. There is a wide array of things we can do between nothing at all and a paranoid "protect-the-kids", state-run total technology shutdown.
- tbrownaw 2y ago> The law will also prohibit social media platforms from sending notifications regarding addictive feeds to minors from 12:00 a.m. to 6:00 a.m. without parental consent. So they'll need to verify a user's age, and possibly also relationship to another user. That seems like it would interfere with anonymity which is necessary to be able to speak freely on contentious issues. Or will people saying heretical things just not be able to use fancy feeds or all-hours notifications? (Or instead of political dissidents, maybe consider people who have a crazy stalker ex.)
- akersten 2y agoYeah, those cheering this on are missing the trees for the forest - laws with these kind of identity/age validation requirements are the path to normalizing deep bureaucratic integration with the internet at large, it's disheartening to see the TOTC[0] argument work so well here, but it's been proven to be Ol' Reliable especially w/r/t similar legislation targeting adult media companies. As a former child with internet access who turned out Just Fine, and a strong privacy advocate, the next decade of similarly-inspired lawmaking hurts my heart. There are some good morsels in these laws like the limits on data exchange, but the pieces relying on age, identity, and rules about the presentation of site content are extremely problematic to me. Especially the last piece - I don't see how the State telling a site how its recommendation algorithms can or can't behave doesn't run afoul of the site operator's constitutional freedom of expression in determining the display of its user-generated content. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children
- devwastaken 2y agoThe nature of the Internet is for adults. It should be 18+ and enforced with a universal identity system using an x509 like cert signing system. It is the ethically correct decision to reverse the chaotic entropy that turned the Internet into the predatory, low quality and abusive system it is today.
- tqi 2y ago> Addictive feeds, or algorithmically driven feeds, facilitate unhealthy levels of social media use. This legislation will require social media companies to restrict addictive feeds on their platforms for users under 18. Unless parental consent is granted, users under 18 will not receive addictive feeds. Notably, the SAFE for Kids Act is the first bill of its kind to be signed into law in any state across the nation. What is an "algorithmically driven feed"? Does sorting by most commented, most upvoted, or most viewed count? Does Hackernews count as social media, and will it now require age verification / parental consent?
- newzisforsukas 2y ago> Despite numerous exceptions, an “addictive feed” is a platform where multiple pieces of media generated or shared by users are recommended, selected, or prioritized based on user-related information. From: https://www.hinshawlaw.com/newsroom-updates-pcad-new-york-child-privacy-protection-bills.html https://www.hinshawlaw.com/newsroom-updates-pcad-new-york-ch...
- 1propionyl 2y agoThe term "algorithmic" in this context is frustratingly, but obviously, not the general CS usage. What's meant, more or less, as indicated by the "addictive", are feeds that: 1. Optimize for user engagement. 2. Are opaque to the user. 3. Are not controlled by the user. A sort by a field does not constitute such an "algorithm". One might argue that even having a default to sort by "most views" or "popularity" is a gray zone, but I'd say they differ per #2/3 in that the data used to order the items are completely visible to the user, and they are making an affirmative choice to sort by that data. I would prefer the use of terminology such as "metric-driven/metric-independent", "user-opaque/user-transparent" and "user-controlled/service-controlled". I would also prefer we refer to "predictive models" rather than algorithms, as that immediately implies the presence of some likelihood/metric being optimized for (by the service, not the user) in an almost certainly opaque or incomprehensible way. That said, I think for now we're stuck with "algorithm" having a very overloaded lay definition and just have to play ball rather than split hairs. There's too much at stake.
- Aloisius 2y ago
- xg15 2y ago> Legislation S.7695B/A.8149A enables the New York Child Data Protection Act to prohibit online sites from collecting, using, sharing or selling personal data of anyone under the age of 18, unless they receive informed consent or unless doing so is strictly necessary for the purpose of the website. That's a lot of "unless" there, which doesn't make me very optimistic for its impact. I haven't heard yet from a scenario where selling a minor's personal data is strictly necessary for the technical operation of a site, but I'm sure we'll discover lots of such cases very soon... Also, as an adult, I find it interesting that the "informed consent" requirement is restricted to kids only. Sure, adults should be trusted to decide for themselves whether or not they want to share their data, but wouldn't they at least need some opportunity to decide for that?
- card_zero 2y agoThis is kind of unreadable because the page is full of vacuous quotes from smartly-dressed people applauding one another and saying "we applaud this safer safety safeguarding model for the tireless future of the children of the nation in the digital age," and very little mention of the implementation. Will they check age by asking? Is it essentially a law that means that if you're under 18 and want to use social media, you have to lie?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- chimeracoder 2y agoYou can read the full text here: https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2023/S7694/amendment/A https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2023/S7694/amendm... https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2023/S7695/amendment/B https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2023/S7695/amendm...
- card_zero 2y ago> THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL PROMULGATE REGULATIONS IDENTIFYING [...] AVAILABLE AGE DETERMINATION TECHNIQUES [...] PREVALENT PRACTICES OF THE INDUSTRY [...] SUCH REGULATIONS SHALL SET FORTH MULTIPLE COMMERCIALLY REASONABLE AND TECHNICALLY FEASIBLE METHODS [...] INCLUDING AT LEAST ONE METHOD THAT EITHER DOES NOT RELY SOLELY ON GOVERNMENT ISSUED IDENTIFICATION OR THAT ALLOWS A COVERED USER TO MAINTAIN ANONYMITY It looks like the plan is for the companies to do age verification somehow. Details to be arranged later, by somebody.
- chimeracoder 2y ago> INCLUDING AT LEAST ONE METHOD THAT EITHER DOES NOT RELY SOLELY ON GOVERNMENT ISSUED IDENTIFICATION OR THAT ALLOWS A COVERED USER TO MAINTAIN ANONYMITY I honestly have no idea what this is supposed to mean.
- card_zero 2y ago
- ynac 2y agoThat's one aspect, but what about the internal decisions of knowingly harming an audience (under age or not) for higher margins? When a company knows they make more money by increasing harm to their "livestock" and repeatedly choose that path - that's a line crossed in my world. I'm open to philosophical capitialistic justifications, money is SO cool to have. But going after little girls with that attitude as FBook did; it's just kind of a dead end for me.