4 ms·
> Last month, Jensen Harris, the director of product management for the Windows user experience team, wrote a lengthy blog post in which he documented all the w
by jessriedel 14y ago
> Last month, Jensen Harris, the director of product management for the Windows user experience team, wrote a lengthy blog post in which he documented all the ways that Windows has changed over the last 27 years—and how people always hated these changes until they got around to loving them.
I still hate the ribbon. I haven't met anyone in real-life who likes it.
I still hate the way the control panel apps are organized, and their weird layout in Windows Vista/7. I have gotten used to it, but I still like the old way better.
The user control agent stuff doesn't bother me any more like it did in Windows Vista, but that's because it doesn't go off all the time like it used to.
I liked the new behavior of the taskbar in Window 7 (just an icon, windows grouped by programs) immediately.
I liked the way notification icons were handled in Windows 7 immediately.
I just can't think of anything I hated at first but ended up liking. Can someone help me remember?
- AlexandrB 14y agoI know this isn't real life, but I love the ribbon in MS Office. Made common tasks much more accessible/findable for me.
- kbolino 14y agoI don't think anyone can really argue with the idea that common tasks are simpler to find and do with the ribbon interface (excepting the vertical screen real estate issue). The issue with the ribbon is uncommon tasks; they were always hard to find, and people ended up memorizing the specific sequence of menus, shortcuts, and what have you that were necessary to access them. Then along comes the ribbon, and all of those memorized sequences are useless. That's the real issue: I used to know how to do this, and now I have no freaking clue. The online help is usually sufficient, but it still adds time to the process without adding any value. Also, another change that I've never really seen anyone comment on: the context-sensitive help (where you click the question-mark icon in the titlebar and then click on a widget to see a detailed tooltip description) was basically gutted (I think this was in 2003, so before the ribbon per se) and replaced with a generic and significantly truncated help page that's nearly useless.
- jakejake 14y agoI feel the same way. Perhaps new users who didn't use the old versions don't feel this way. But its strange how windows "improvements" manage to be so painful for the faithful users.
- drzaiusapelord 14y agoI love the ribbon. I just got sick of memorizing arbitrary locations. I also manage IT and see even our more clueless users able to use it with ease. From a non-power user perspective its actually nice. Not sure whats going on with this metro stuff, but the ribbon has been a pretty big success outside the group of people who have long memorized menus and are annoyed they need to learn something else.
- jessriedel 14y agoIt wasn't just the re-learning that was a pain with the ribbon (although that in itself needs to be justified by some gain, which I just couldn't find in the ribbon that hadn't been found in the graphical tool bars in previous versions). It was that lots of functions weren't even there to find! You had to customize the ribbon just to access functions I used every day. It also took up a third of my screen real estate on my netbook, so I had to choose the 'auto-minimize' option, and wait for it to slide open every time I wanted to change a font size. What a pain...
- jamesgeck0 14y agoI had to leave my cozy Linux system and start using Word 2003 a few months before Office 2007 came out. Even after a few months of exposure to 2003, I had a much easier time navigating the ribbon than I did the menus. My father, coming from Office 1997, hated the ribbon with a passion.
- laserDinosaur 14y ago"I still hate the way the control panel apps are organized, and their weird layout in Windows Vista/7. I have gotten used to it, but I still like the old way better." GOD THIS. I still have to visually scan for a good 10-20 seconds to find what I want. I'm not sure why XP was easier, maybe because the fonts were smaller with more focus on the icons, plus less of them.
- atesti 14y agoAll the old code (e.g. start menu) will still be around and easy to maintain. MS always does it like that. Why not keep a group policy around to enable it? That's what's to hate! The devious removal of things people love. They can make the default all this Metro stuff, but they must make it possible to get the old version back
- bsphil 14y agoI can't remember the last time I actually went to the control panel to open something up. I'm too content using the start menu search to bring up control panel menus.