7 ms·
> It makes for an excellent litmus test to ask, sometimes literally out loud, whether someone who advocates for the legislation of a specific religion's rules w
by rayiner 2y ago
> It makes for an excellent litmus test to ask, sometimes literally out loud, whether someone who advocates for the legislation of a specific religion's rules would be OK with being forced to comply with a different religion's rules and tenets.
This overlooks the difference between majority religions and minority religions. If the majority want to legislate a rule, it shouldn’t matter what is the rationale behind that rule. Everyone relies on moral frameworks based on non-falsifiable axioms to formulate political opinions.
In the German state of Bavaria, all public buildings are required to display Christian crosses: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-43892329 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-43892329. This is a reasonable exercise of democratic will in a Christian-majority place.
A better question is to ask the same person how they feel about legislation motivated by religious principles in a country where the majority follow that religion. I expect you’d find that most American Christians don’t care if India wants to legislate based on Hindu principles.
> A secondary litmus test is whether a person can even understand the reasoning behind the idea of the separation of church and state
A better litmus test is whether someone can identify where in the Constitution it says anything about “separation of church and state.”
- saagarjha 2y agoAmerican Christians don’t care what India does for a large part because they don’t live there. But they do care when it leads to rights abuses of minorities.
- rayiner 2y ago> American Christians don’t care what India does for a large part because they don’t live there But that’s the critical distinction. Democracy means that people who live in a place get to decide what kind of place they want to live in. Complaining about what Hindus are doing in India is hypocritical and none of American Christians’ business.
- saagarjha 2y agoThat's not actually how the world works. You can be sovereign all you want but when you are doing human rights abuses people are well within their rights to call you out on that.
- johnklos 2y ago"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances." Please explain where the prohibition from religious based law (that is, the separation) is vague.
- rayiner 2y agoThat says that: 1) Congress cannot create an official national church or regulate the official state churches that existed at the time the First Amendment was written. (The term "establishment of religion" is not an old-timey way of referring to religiously-motivated laws, but instead refers to "established churches": https://firstamendment.mtsu.edu/article/established-churches-in-early-america/ https://firstamendment.mtsu.edu/article/established-churches...) 2) Congress cannot prohibit individuals from exercising their religion freely. Neither of those provisions prohibits the majority having religious motivations for otherwise-permissible laws. For example, the government can obviously commerce. If the majority wants to use the government's power over commerce to ban the sale of alcohol on Sundays, that's totally permissible. The fact that people's motivation for doing that is based on Christianity makes no difference.