4 ms·
The "commercial real estate conspiracy" angle always strikes me a little like the tail wagging the dog. The market cap of the set of all companies making the RT
by ryandrake 2y ago
The "commercial real estate conspiracy" angle always strikes me a little like the tail wagging the dog. The market cap of the set of all companies making the RTO/WFH decision must dwarf the market cap of Commercial Real Estate. Yet, somehow, Commercial Real Estate is pulling the strings and making the decisions? Not sure I buy it.
- mulmen 2y agoDon’t these companies have investments in commercial real estate? I would expect Dell to own their HQ buildings.
- ryandrake 2y agoWe can check their balance sheet. Dell doesn't even report "Land and Improvements" anymore. The last time they did in 2021, it accounted for ~3.8% of their total assets--a tiny drop in the bucket. Take Apple, who just built their spaceship campus: Land and Improvements is ~6.6% of their assets. Google, who own most of Mountain view are ~18% real estate. So, I suppose maybe that tail is wagging the dog... For some companies?
- riahi 2y agoThe argument I’ve seen is that management of these companies is heavily invested in commercial real estate themselves, so corporate management has a conflict of interest in RTO in that it benefits their personal investments rather than the company.
- derf_ 2y agoManagement is usually heavily compensated via the stock of the company they are managing, precisely to align incentives and overcome conflicts of interest like that.
- cyanydeez 2y agoBut it's pretty clear these CEOs leverage their assets to invest in things they can directly use to make liquid. They can't sell their stock options but they can take out loans and get real estate.
- simoncion 2y ago> The market cap of the set of all companies making the RTO/WFH decision must dwarf the market cap of Commercial Real Estate. Yet, somehow, Commercial Real Estate is pulling the strings... a) The business districts of many cities become much smaller or (in some cases) effectively nonexistent if they don't have folks coming into the city's office buildings and going out for meals and entertainment throughout the day. This makes for a substantial reduction in sales tax revenue due to the reduced sales, and (for places that aren't like California and have the ability to actually make meaningful increases in property tax income over the years) property tax revenue as the on-paper value of those commercial properties plummet because there's neither people willing to put their asses into leased seats, nor foot traffic to feed those businesses anymore. This makes cities DESPERATE to get asses in seats and willing to threaten or bribe businesses with local offices to make it happen. b) Market cap is a handy proxy to get an idea of what the size of a business might be. Given that nVidia is currently the biggest publicly-traded company in the world according to this metric, one should notice that it's a metric that really needs to be evaluated in concert with others to get a full and accurate picture of what's going on with a particular business. (It's particularly instructive to notice that if a company were to sell all of its publicly-traded stock, it would receive WAY less for the sale than the "Wow, look at that market cap!" numbers would indicate it should.)
- alephnerd 2y agoI work closely with some people who make these kinds of decisions and ime it's not commercial real estate (though I'm sure there might be isolated cases of this happening - Washington DC's city government is a notable example of this) Based on my network, their reasoning is a mix of: - communication breakdowns due to the difficulty of building an async communication model (remember that most people are not as text/writing and async driven as Internet commenters on a tech forum), and operational work like quarterly planning, QBRs, product line prioritizations, etc can be done much faster in person instead of over 10-15 Zoom calls over 3-5 weeks. - situations where remote workers are domiciled in a different location from where they were hired AND they didn't tell HR (this leaves companies legally liable for various tax, business incorporation, and safety regulations) - the occasional case where a major security incident occurs due to lack of in-person verification (eg. The recent North Korea remote worker scandal, the ongoing Snowflake break) - Justify US headcount. One of the portfolio companies I was an observer for went public a couple years ago. When they switched to remote during the pandemic, they realized they could cut down their entire US engineering presence and overhire in Eastern Europe, Israel, and India and drastically reduce margins. Most larger institutional investors are clamoring for this now, and they have a point to a certain extent. IBM, Google, Crowdstrike, and Amazon have unofficially started this, and I'm not surprised if other companies are doing the same There are ways to change an organization to resolve these issues, but they are hard, expensive, and not scalable for large organizations.
- salawat 2y ago>- situations where remote workers are domiciled in a different location from where they were hired AND they didn't tell HR (this leaves companies legally liable for various tax, business incorporation, and safety regulations) This right here is entirely a result of government leveraging employers as a social control mechanism, that hitherto hasn't been so much of an issue; but with things like the Internet and computers, has now become highly disruptive to comply with. The answer to "who gets the tax revenue?" has previously been "the jurisdiction of record for the employee". Anything more fine grained than that starts to become indistinguishable from serfdom, and reels of government overreach.
- 2y ago
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoSame with it all being about middle managers' egos. Like, senior management is more than willing to throw out middle management, especially in tech.