3 ms·
> Socialisation is a system, nationalisation an act. Socialism, the system, requires widespread nationalization in the form of both control and ownership of as
by ceejayoz 2y ago
> Socialisation is a system, nationalisation an act.
Socialism, the system, requires widespread nationalization in the form of both control and ownership of assets.
> There are zero legal scholars or historians who consider break-up orders nationalisation.
Again, nationalization is taking state ownership or control. A forcible government breakup of an organization is clear state control of it, albeit for a brief period.
Thought experiment:
Venezuela, instead of outright confiscation, chooses instead to leave shareholders in possession of their shares in oil production. They install state-selected management and impose a 100% tax on profits. Is this nationalization?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> forcible government breakup of an organization is clear state control of it You’re defining control in a way that extends to all regulation. The AT&T break-up has been heavily cited and written about. Do you have a single expert who agrees with your claim that it constituted nationalisation? (Let’s even assume AT&T was actually ordered to break up, versus voluntarily doing so to settle a lawsuit.) > instead of outright confiscation, chooses instead to leave shareholders in possession of their shares in oil production. They install state-selected management and impose a 100% tax on profits. Now remove the confiscation of profits and selection of state-selected management.