> If the typical rational user will have seen many posts about YC critical news not related to celebrity gossip they will immediately know such claims are unfou

> If the typical rational user will have seen many posts about YC critical news not related to celebrity gossip they will immediately know such claims are unfounded and have public references to it. No, if it looks to them like many/most/all of those posts have been more or less subtly de-emphasized, the impression they'll get is the exact opposite of what you postulate.