4 ms·
The article completely ignores quantum field theory, which forms the basis of the standard model of particle physics, and in which particles are emergent (rathe
by layer8 2y ago
The article completely ignores quantum field theory, which forms the basis of the standard model of particle physics, and in which particles are emergent (rather than fundamental) features of the respective underlying field, which is described by wave equations.
- criddell 2y agoIf a particle is an excitation of a quantum field, what is a wave?
- itishappy 2y agoThe same thing. A wave is just something that obeys the wave equation by wiggling in a certain way.
- oneshtein 2y agoIn some mathematical models, a particle is an excitation of a field, e.g. a mountain is an excitation of a height field. It makes calculations much easier. In those models, waves can be represented in many different ways. In the real world, a particle can be a lot of different things, but usually we use this word to describe small parts of larger objects. There is no much physical difference between a small grain of sand and a planet, but we use different words for them, while we use the same word for small things, which can be different by many orders of magnitude. In the real world, a wave, is just a form of group behavior of particles, i.e. many particles are doing the same thing at once because of an interaction between them and some energy in a system. For example, merging of black holes makes waves in a galaxy, so we can watch that in super slow motion.
- gipp 2y agoI'd say it's more or less consistent with QFT -- it's saying essentially the same thing, just not in that exact language
- breck 2y agoAny chance you could provide some analogies to someone with deep computer expertise who wants to learn quantum physics? Is QFT analogous to binary? Everything builds up from QFT?
- layer8 2y agoThere are no good analogies I know of. I wouldn't say it's like binary in any way, but I also wouldn't say that that everything builds up from binary in CS. There is really no particular relation to (or benefits of having) computer expertise. Two recent popular books about QFT are: Matt Strassler’s Waves in an Impossible Sea (no math, just hand-wavy analogies): https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CB3LZXR9/ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CB3LZXR9/ Sean Carroll’s Quanta and Fields (tries to give you a basic understanding of the actual math): https://www.amazon.com/dp/0593186605/ https://www.amazon.com/dp/0593186605/
- breck 2y agoHelpful. Just got Quanta and Fields. Thanks!
- xeonmc 2y agoWould it be apt to say QFT is like ECS?
- lisper 2y agoElastic Container Service? Um, no. Or did you mean something else?
- xeonmc 2y agoEntity-Component-System
- lisper 2y agoOK, well, that makes a little more sense. But the answer still seems to me to be a pretty obvious "no". ECS is an engineering methodology. QFT is a mathematical formalism that combines quantum mechanics and special relativity. It's really apples and oranges.